Outside Of Chabad, Hasidic Women Are Not Allowed To Drive

In his second 2007 lecture on David Zvi Hoffman, Dr. Marc B. Shapiro says: If some Hasidic leader got up and said that we value our women so much, that is why they’re not allowed to drive. We believe that we should be taking them everywhere because they’re better than us.

Most of us would look at that as apologetics and not serious.

Luke says: Apologetics is usually a dirty word in Judaism but not so in Christianity. I read many works of Christian apologetics growing up the son of a Seventh-Day Adventist minister.

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on Outside Of Chabad, Hasidic Women Are Not Allowed To Drive

Is James Kugel Orthodox?

James Kugel is a famous Bible scholar who takes unorthodox approaches to understanding the origins of the Torah.

Dr. Marc B. Shapiro says in a 2007 lecture for Torah in Motion on Rabbi David Zvi Hoffman: “The idea that the Torah is a patchwork of different ideas from different time periods reflecting different personalities. For an example of this, see James Kugel’s recent book. I know him. I was his TA (teacher’s assistant) for two years. He wears a big black yarmulke. He’s shomer Torah mitzvot (observes the laws of the Torah). They all call him Orthodox but if Orthodoxy has anything to do with traditional dogmas regarding Torah, he obviously isn’t. If Orthodoxy means shomer Torah mitzvot, he is, as is [Umberto] Cassuto, Zecharias Frankel, Louis Finkelstein.”

Posted in Bible, James Kugel, Marc B. Shapiro | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Is James Kugel Orthodox?

The Chief Rabbi Of Rome During The Holocaust Afterward Converted To Christianity

I found this guy a shocker: Israel Zolli (September 27, 1881, Brody, Galicia – March 2, 1956, Rome, Italy) was from 1939 to 1945 Chief Rabbi of Rome. After the war, he converted to Roman Catholicism, taking the name Eugenio in honor of Pope Pius XII.

Posted in Christianity, Conversion | Comments Off on The Chief Rabbi Of Rome During The Holocaust Afterward Converted To Christianity

Jewish Santa Claus, John Huntsman on Israel, Ultra-Orthodox Keeping Women in the Back of the Bus, and More…

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Jewish Santa Claus, John Huntsman on Israel, Ultra-Orthodox Keeping Women in the Back of the Bus, and More…

Pitching My New Practice

Photo by Jonah Light:

Posted in Alexander Technique | Comments Off on Pitching My New Practice

Denying Science Makes A Mockery Of Orthodox Judaism

In a 2009 lecture on Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch for Torah in Motion, Dr. Marc B. Shapiro says: “It’s impossible to cover up these things now they’re out there [online].

“Hirsch says we’re not bound to any opposition to science. He wasn’t any great lover of evolution because it hadn’t been proven, but like Rav Kook, he said we could accept this. We could make our tradition work with this. Hirsch was a big believer that if it is scientifically true, it works with Torah. We can not get up and say that the Torah by definition is opposed to any form of science because you never know what is going to be in the future. We don’t accept all of science just because some hypothesis comes around, but we always have to be open.”

“Hirsch says that chazal (the rabbis of the Talmud) are not interested in determining science. It is a desecration of God’s name and makes a mockery of Judaism to say otherwise. If you assume that everything chazal says is from Sinai and infallible, then it makes a mockery because when you see proof that creatures described by chazal are mythical creatures then someone will say that if chazal was wrong on this and everything is from Sinai, then Sinai is a joke. Reject all of Torah. Hirsch saves Judaism by saying that chazal were great figures who dealt with every eventuality. They weren’t concerned with whether or not there was such a creature. If you tell me there was, then lets look at the halachos (laws) about it.”

“If you look at the internet and the way these gadolim [condemning Natan Slifkin and evolution] have been mocked and made to look like idiots, if you have any education…”

Posted in Evolution, Marc B. Shapiro, Orthodoxy | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Denying Science Makes A Mockery Of Orthodox Judaism

SATIRE: Alexander Teacher Moonlights As Massage Therapist To Make Ends Meet

LOS ANGELES—When the cool evening sun sets over Hollywood, Bill Robinson does not go home to his wife and family. For this Alexander Technique teacher, the work day has only just begun.

Robinson, 38, is a two-year veteran of the Alexander police force. Despite earning “danger pay,” he still struggles to stay afloat financially, and has had to take on a second job as a massage therapist just to make ends meet.

“After my electricity and water supply were restored, I suddenly had a lot more bills to pay,” Robinson said. “Jobs are still pretty scarce, but I figured Thai massage pads are always hiring.”

Robinson, who has previously supplemented his income with such part-time jobs as teaching yoga and reading auras, said he was initially unsure that he was qualified for massage work.

“My buddy Frank High worked at the Brotherhood Of Total Thai Massage, and he said he’d put in a good word for me with the head sheik,” Robinson said. “I didn’t expect to hear back for a while, but before I knew it, I got an interview.”

While Robinson had worried that his lack of experience and his creased suit would hurt his chances of being hired, he later said “the only thing they seemed to care about was whether I had a car, a cowboy outfit, and could do out-call.”

Although happy to have extra work, Robinson is not always able to fulfill his duties as a therapist, resulting in some unexpected complications.

“During the day, I enforce non-doing. So many Alexander teachers are tempted to do, to tug or to pull on their students to assist the lengthening and widening. Some teachers so want to make their students feel good that they forget their role is to teach, not to give happy feelings.

“Then at my night job, it’s all doing. It’s all about making the client feel good. Whatever it takes. There’s no educating. There’s no bringing awareness to certain habits that interfere with the client’s good use. Yeah, massage work pays more, but I feel cheap afterward.

“I’d rather be teaching the Alexander Technique, but I just can’t sell this stuff, so I’m forced to join the Alexander police during the day and arrest any teacher who makes a joke of the Technique.”

Robinson lost his left eye six months ago when breaking up a street fight between followers of Patrick MacDonald and Walter Carrington. “Those Patrick blokes are tough dudes,” he said. “Ex-Mossad.”

After less than a month as a massage therapist, the physical and mental strain of working 70-hour weeks can be seen in Robinson’s tired, sunken eyes and stooped posture. Complaining of exhaustion, Robinson said that he doesn’t “know what job [he’s] at half the time.”

“I was screaming that Feldenkrais practicioners are infidels when I realized that I was at the pad,” Robinson said. “Luckily, the other masseuses either weren’t paying attention or they agreed with me.”

Posted in Alexander Technique, Satire | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on SATIRE: Alexander Teacher Moonlights As Massage Therapist To Make Ends Meet

You Can Live A Lie For Only So Long

I did not shave or cut my beard for almost four years. Then I cut it off three months ago.

A couple of weeks ago, Matisyahu cut off his beard.

Many people have asked me for my opinion.

I say — you can live a lie for only so long.

Most people can keep up a front for a limited time.

After a while, if you’re a Jew with a beard, you either conform your life to your beard or you conform your beard to your life.

Matisyahu and I conformed our faces to our lives. We weren’t living as traditional Orthodox Jews and after a while, we abandoned the pretense.

I have not meaningfully reduced my Jewish observance since cutting off my beard. While I had my beard, I was a little more careful to dress up to the beard in Jewish contexts.

Posted in Orthodoxy, Personal | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on You Can Live A Lie For Only So Long

Letting Go Of Acid Reflux

Many of my friends suffer from acid reflux.

One tells me: “I need to lower amount of acid in my gut, I think. Last two nights were pretty nasty, and maalox does not suffice. Basically every time I went horizontal I was in pain, and only by standing or sitting straight up could I stop it. Sucks to be me right now.”

I tell them: The acid reflux is a symptom not a cause of your problems. It is a manifestation of a body wrapped in unnecessary tension, pushing all your organs tighter together.

When you tense up in reaction to anxiety and try to push your problems down into your gut, your gut rebels.

Try this exercise every day and see what happens.

I suffered from acid reflux but I haven’t had the problem since I started training to become an Alexander teacher in 2009.

Then I wrote:

“Do you have any thoughts on stomach aches?” I ask my Alexander Technique teacher today.

“When do you get them?” he asks.

“When I start worrying. I find myself clenching.”

“Well, what would you say to a friend with this problem?”

“I don’t know.”

“You’d say that you’re probably moving down when it happens, pushing your stomach down, playing a loop of worrying thoughts, and you’re probably tipping your head back. So the solution is to flow up. You’re too smart of a guy for this. You know this.

“Why do people throw up when under stress? Because they push down, they tip their head back, they catastrophize and the bile flows up.”

Check this:

I came to the Alexander Technique in desperation with raging indigestion, which had been diagnosed as chronic acid reflux. It made my life a misery and after numerous faddish food diets and extensive tests, my consultant suggested that my posture might be the problem. I have a stressful life as a lawyer and had spent years in training and practice hunched up over books, compounded by the constant demands of professional life. I was thus collapsing at the front of my torso (hence hunched shoulders, aching back and a little pot belly) and this was all pushing down on my abdomen and causing damaging and painful acid reflux.

A chance conversation about this with a friend led me to the Alexander Technique. After several months of Alexander lessons, I had ceased taking all prescription antacid drugs, was able to eat what I liked and started to have a normal life for the first time in years. I was able to sleep uninterrupted too.

Through the Alexander Technique, I have come to understand the years of misuse I have unknowingly imposed on my poor body. The Technique is not a therapy but a way of life, self help if you like. I am a keen motoring fan and by way of analogy think of the Technique like performance tuning, to be able to operate more efficiently. Things go out of tune and hence my regular session with Quintin helps me to help myself keep tuned up.

I ignore looking after myself at my peril as my dreaded Achilles heel of chronic indigestion will come back if provoked. The warning sign is a hint of indigestion and I know then to come back to the principles of what one learns in an Alexander lesson.

Posted in Alexander Technique | Tagged , , , , , , | Comments Off on Letting Go Of Acid Reflux

What Exactly is A Nervous Breakdown?

I hear about people having nervous breakdowns. What exactly is a nervous breakdown?

My layman’s understanding is that “Nervous breakdown” equals not being up to taking on the tasks that life has for you. Becoming unable to function.

I know that sometimes when I am out socially, I’m unable to introduce myself to people. I just have so much anxiety.

Any time that I’m unable to do something normally expected because of my depression or anxiety, I’d say that is a tiny nervous breakdown.

What about when my life collapsed around me when I entered into Chronic Fatigue Syndrome in February of 1988? A syndrome that has not fully left me.

CFS dramatically cut down on my strength so that initially I was only able to do half as much as normal and eventually, only about a fifth of normal for about five years, until beginning a recovery in the end of 1993 that led me to my current state of being able to do about 70% of a normal life.

I think people not tightly connected to others, unmarried lonely people, are particularly prey to nervous breakdowns, CFS and the like. When you’re bonded with others, you’re more functional.

John emails: “But don’t they call that a “midlife crisis” these days? When was the last time you encountered the term “nervous breakdown” in popular culture? It comes up all the time in old movies from the fifties, but these days the expression seems to have vanished from view.”

Wikipedia says:

Mental breakdown (also known as a nervous breakdown) is a non-medical term used to describe an acute, time-limited phase of a specific disorder that presents primarily with features of depression or anxiety.

Mental breakdown (also known as a nervous breakdown) is a non-medical term used to describe an acute, time-limited phase of a specific disorder that presents primarily with features of depression or anxiety.

Posted in Psychology | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on What Exactly is A Nervous Breakdown?