What Is Religion?: Debating the Academic Study of Religion

Here are some highlights from this 2021 book:

Jews who practice Judaism do not necessarily think they are practicing religion, unless they are part of a larger Western society that defines Judaism as such. Many ultra- Orthodox Jews do not, in my view, see themselves as practicing a “religion,” and perhaps not even “Judaism”; rather they are devoted to a series of beliefs and practices that they believe is the will of the one God who transmitted God’s will to Moses on Mount Sinai. “A” religion would imply other religions. But many devout Jews do not acknowledge
other religions that are in any way comparable to what they do; thus the term “idolatry” has long been a term Jews use to define the “religions” of others, or maybe religion itself. Religion is idolatry; Judaism is truth!

…My father- in- law is a professor emeritus of electoral politics. He does not vote in elections. When asked why, he says he does not want to tamper with the data… There is a story that every year on Passover, J. Z. Smith’s wife, who was an active member of a synagogue in downtown Chicago, would prepare a Passover seder. When the ritual of the seder began (which happens before the meal), Smith would get up from the table and go upstairs to his study. He would remain there until the ritual part of the seder was complete, then he would come downstairs and join everyone for the meal. I do not pretend
to know if and why he did that. But if he acted so, it may not be that different
from my father- in- law’s choice not to vote. Smith was a scholar of religion.

…J.Z. Smith once confessed to me his voracious and promiscuous television- watching habit, which both delighted and scandalized me as a graduate student.

…I have not seen a major textbook, nor scholar, for almost three decades that affirms the old Protestant “belief in God” model of religion, but that’s clearly still the common understanding of the public. Public discussions of religion, from television to the nightly news, revolve around what people believe, and whether they believe in “God,” as well as some code of ethics…

…Religion is whatever people think it is…

Posted in Judaism | Comments Off on What Is Religion?: Debating the Academic Study of Religion

Impulse Control Disorders

Here are some highlights from this 2010 book:

Pathological Gambling: Promoting Risk, Provoking Ruin

* Americans spend more money on gambling than on any other form of entertainment (Volberg 2001). From 1995 to 2006, consumer spending on commercial casino gambling almost doubled, from $18 billion to $34 billion. Revenues from casinos, pari-mutuel wagering, lotteries, legal bookmaking, charitable gambling and bingo, Indian reservations, and card rooms experienced similar growth, from $51 billion in 1997 to $94 billion in 2007.

* One hundred years ago, gambling was essentially outlawed in the United States, and it
remained so until 30 years ago, when it was first legalized. By 2007, there were casinos in 32 states, and every state except Hawaii and Utah had some form of legalized gambling.

* A preoccupation with gambling can result in poor job performance, absenteeism, health
problems, job loss, and unemployment. A national study established that problem and
pathological gamblers were more than four times as likely as low-risk gamblers to have
lost a job and more than three times as likely to have been fired within the past year. They were also six times more likely than their low-risk counterparts to collect unemployment.

* Efforts to replace words such as “pathological gambling,” “compulsive gambling,” and
“gambling addiction” with the term “disordered” gambling and the like are intended to
replace language clinically recognized by the American Psychiatric Association or well
established in the literature. Industry also substitutes the word “gaming” for “gambling” in an effort to have the public view their venues purely as entertainment and fun.

Virtual Violence: The Games People Play

* Experimental and correlational studies have reported that playing violent video games is associated with increased levels of physiological arousal, decreased prosocial behaviors, greater hostility, more frequent arguments with teachers and poorer school performance, and more frequent physical fights and aggressive or antisocial behavior…

* A hypothetical analogy may be useful here: how would society treat video games that
portray child abuse (physical or sexual)? Although exposure to such video games would not
necessarily cause one to abuse children, these games would be considered to promote or
condone child abuse, perhaps in a way that child pornography does. As a result, such video games would probably be illegal in most countries, as is child pornography. If exposure to most violent video games also promotes or condones aggression without necessarily causing it, why should these video games be legal and held to a different standard? This is a paradox that is ultimately related to societal attitudes and values. Video games that depict particularly extreme forms of violence such as decapitation and dismemberment or feature violence directed against defenseless women are less socially acceptable and are frequently banned or censored in some countries. However, many modern Western societies consider “ordinary” aggressive behavior to be to some extent socially acceptable and tolerate it, while (at least publicly) showing zero tolerance for aggressive behavior toward children. As a reflection of these societal norms, in the realm of video games, killing an adult might seem more acceptable than hitting a child. This double standard sends conflicting and confusing messages about the type and amount of aggression that is or that could be tolerated by the society.

The Sex Industry: Public Vice, Hidden Victims

* Sanders (2004), in interviews with women working mainly in indoor settings, found
that emotional and psychological distress related primarily to feelings of depersonalization and loss of self-esteem as well as to the fear of discovery by family and intimate partners. The workers identified the practical and emotional difficulties encountered in keeping their working and private lives separate as a greater threat to their well-being than either violence or infection. There seems little doubt that sex trading as an occupation has a propensity to cause psychological distress, although common sense also suggests that the context in terms of the physical setting, levels of violence, drug dependence, coercion from pimps, and pressure from police must have a major impact on the extent to which this occurs.

Sex work is a dangerous business. The constant threat of violence, the consequences of sexually transmitted disease, and the cumulative damage to mental health are all compounded by the effects of heroin, crack cocaine, and other drugs.

Posted in Addiction | Comments Off on Impulse Control Disorders

Harvard Psychologist Steven Pinker Lectures On Rationality At UCLA 2 (5-30-24)

Posted in Steven Pinker | Comments Off on Harvard Psychologist Steven Pinker Lectures On Rationality At UCLA 2 (5-30-24)

Donald Trump Convicted On 34 Felonies (5-30-24)

Posted in America | Comments Off on Donald Trump Convicted On 34 Felonies (5-30-24)

Decoding War (5-29-24)


01:00 You’re Being Lied To By Billionaire-Funded Fake Racialist Boomers | JFGT #1108, https://odysee.com/@JFGTonight:0/jfgt1108:f
04:00 NPR: Americans Are Shrinking, While Chinese And Koreans Sprout Up, https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2016/07/27/487391773/americans-are-shrinking-while-chinese-and-koreans-sprout-up
06:00 Why are Asian-Americans taller than their parents?, https://www.quora.com/Why-are-Asian-Americans-taller-than-their-parents
10:30 Realism in the Age of Rising Disorder, Uncertainty & Chaos with Dr. Randall Schweller, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=120wiWJbuvk
12:50 Charges dropped against Scottie Scheffler after arrest outside PGA Championship, https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/5526909/2024/05/29/scottie-scheffler-charges-dropped-pga-championship/
39:00 Why have we given $200 billion to Ukraine?
55:30 Angelo John Gage dresses up like a Hxmxs terrorist
59:00 Information entropy
1:01:20 The State of Israel with Dan Senor | Andrew Roberts | Hoover Institution, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=POkK5i-pm_g
1:03:00 Most American Jewish philanthropy goes to non-Jewish causes
1:07:00 Psychosocial Boundaries – How to maintain your mental sovereignty and resist the pull of others, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F-J2vLuYD-c
1:11:00 How To Stop Feeling Attached To Someone, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8a3TqE3MyU
1:19:00 The Biggest Blindspot Of People With Low Self-Esteem (& How To Keep It From Ruining Relationships), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HFUIv2YXRjw
1:24:45 How Do Doctors Get Corrupted by Ideology? Lessons from the Holocaust, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J9J_UUDYIUA

Posted in International Relations | Comments Off on Decoding War (5-29-24)

Decoding International Relations (5-28-24)

01:00 Why no cold war yet with China, https://foreignpolicy.com/2024/05/07/cold-war-cold-peace-united-states-china-xi-decoupling-trade/
04:00 Three cheers for Donald Trump, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=155233
09:30 On Realism, Interview with Randall Schweller, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fm30l0ycwLs
10:10 The Paper Chase (1971), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paper_Chase_(film)
11:00 IR scholar Randall Schweller, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randall_Schweller
20:00 Destiny is the king of livestreams
43:00 The chimera of global convergence, https://newleftreview.org/issues/ii87/articles/sean-starrs-the-chimera-of-global-convergence
44:00 The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rise_and_Fall_of_the_Great_Powers
1:06:00 The Craft of Writing Effectively, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=154774
1:08:30 Bandwagoning for Profit: Bringing the Revisionist State Back In,
Randall L. Schweller
1:14:00 Realism in the Age of Rising Disorder, Uncertainty & Chaos with Dr. Randall Schweller, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=120wiWJbuvk
1:27:00 Should Liberalism Die? | Bo Winegard and Noah Carl, https://www.aporiamagazine.com/p/should-liberalism-die-bo-winegard
1:36:00 Entropy in International Relations
1:37:30 Realists don’t think history is going forward. Realists believe in cyclical history. Realists expect a tendency towards disorder, not progress.

Posted in International Relations | Comments Off on Decoding International Relations (5-28-24)

Different Peoples, Situations Require Different Styles Of Government (5-27-24)

Michael Hirsh writes for ForeignPolicy.com May 7, 2024:

So why are so many observers putting the worst possible face on the conflict?

In an interview with Foreign Policy, [Randall] Schweller said that when he first entered the academic job market in 1993, just after the collapse of the Soviet Union, international security (IS) studies were fizzling fast. Now, they’re hot again.

“Promoting the idea of Cold War 2.0 definitely promotes the careers of IS scholars,” Schweller wrote in an email.

And that’s true on the Chinese side as well, said political scientist Eun A Jo of Cornell University. “Hawks in competing states benefit from each other in their domestic battles,” she said in a phone interview. Like the Soviet and U.S. hard-liners of the Cold War, the militarists in China are eagerly promoting the idea that the United States seeks to contain China. “The deepening ideological tensions between the two countries today are more likely a product of this dynamic than China’s growing evangelism” about becoming a world power, Jo said.

August 13, 2018, Randall Schweller wrote for ForeignPolicy.com (copy):

Donald Trump’s victory in the 2016 U.S. presidential election heralded nothing less than certain catastrophe. At least, that was and remains the firm belief of “the Blob”—what Ben Rhodes, a foreign policy adviser in the Obama administration, called those from both parties in the mainstream media and the foreign policy establishment who, driven by habitual ideas and no small amount of piety and false wisdom, worry about the decline of the U.S.-led order. “We are very probably looking at a global recession, with no end in sight,” the New York Times columnist Paul Krugman forecast after Trump’s victory. Others prophesied that Trump would resign by the end of his first year (Tony Schwartz, the co-author of Trump: The Art of the Deal), that he would be holed up in the Ecuadorian embassy in six months (the liberal commentator John Aravosis), or that the United States might be headed down the same path that Germany took from the Weimar Republic to the Third Reich. That last warning came from former U.S. President Barack Obama last December at the Economic Club of Chicago, where he invoked the specter of Nazi Germany. “We have to tend to this garden of democracy or else things could fall apart quickly,” he said. “Sixty million people died, so you’ve got to pay attention—and vote.”

So far, the world has not come to an end, far from it. A year into Trump’s first term, the Islamic State, or isis—a fascist organization, by the way—had been virtually defeated in Syria and eliminated from all its havens in Iraq, thanks to the Trump administration’s decision to equip the largely Kurdish militia fighting isis in Syria and give U.S. ground commanders greater latitude to direct operations. All the while, Trump has continued the Obama doctrine of avoiding large-scale conventional wars in the Middle East and has succeeded where his predecessor failed in enforcing a real redline against Bashar al-Assad’s use of nerve gas in Syria by launching targeted air strikes in response. In North Korea, Trump’s strategy of “maximum pressure” has cut the country’s international payments by half, forcing Kim Jong Un to realize that his only choice is to negotiate.

On the domestic front, the unemployment rate fell to 3.8 percent in May, a level not seen since the heady days of the dot-com boom— with unemployment at an all-time low among African Americans; at or near multidecade lows among Hispanics, teenagers, and those with less than a high school education; and at a 65-year low among women in the labor force. Meanwhile, on Trump’s watch, the stock market and consumer confidence have hit all-time highs, the number of mortgage applications for new homes has reached a seven-year high, and gas prices have fallen to a 12-year low. Finally, with Trump pledging to bring to an end the era in which “our politicians seem more interested in defending the borders of foreign countries than their own,” illegal immigration was reduced by 38 percent from November 2016 to November 2017, and in April 2017, the U.S. Border Patrol recorded 15,766 apprehensions at the southwestern border—the lowest in at least 17 years.

As his critics charge, Trump does reject many of the core tenets of the liberal international order, the sprawling and multifaceted system that the United States and its allies built and have supported for seven decades. Questioning the very fabric of international cooperation, he has assaulted the world trading system, reduced funding for the un, denounced nato, threatened to end multilateral trade agreements, called for Russia’s readmission to the G-7, and scoffed at attempts to address global challenges such as climate change. But despite what the crowd of globalists at Davos might say, these policies should be welcomed, not feared. Trump’s transactional approach to foreign relations marks a United States less interested in managing its long-term relationships than in making gains on short-term deals. Trump has sent the message that the United States will now look after its own interests, narrowly defined, not the interests of the so-called global community, even at the expense of long-standing allies.

This worldview is fundamentally realist in nature. On the campaign trail and in office, Trump has argued that the United States needs its allies to share responsibility for their own defense. He has also called for better trade deals to level a playing field tilted against American businesses and workers and to protect domestic manufacturing industries from currency manipulation. He is an economic nationalist at heart. He believes that political factors should determine economic relations, that globalization does not foster harmony among states, and that economic interdependence increases national vulnerability. He has also argued that the state should intervene when the interests of domestic actors diverge from its own—for example, when he called for a boycott against Apple until the company helped the fbi break into the iPhone of one of the terrorists who carried out the 2015 attack in San Bernardino, California.

This realist worldview is not only legitimate but also resonates with American voters, who rightly recognize that the United States is no longer inhabiting the unipolar world it did since the end of the Cold War; instead, it is living in a more multipolar one, with greater competition. Trump is merely shedding shibboleths and seeing international politics for what it is and has always been: a highly competitive realm populated by self-interested states concerned with their own security and economic welfare. Trump’s “America first” agenda is radical only in the sense that it seeks to promote the interests of the United States above all.

Posted in America, China, Donald Trump | Comments Off on Different Peoples, Situations Require Different Styles Of Government (5-27-24)

Decoding The Arab-Israeli West Bank Conflict (5-27-24)

01:00 Racial reckoning after George Floyd’s death leads to 50,000 extra deaths, https://www.unz.com/isteve/repeat-after-me/
03:00 Steve Sailer on Filthy Armenian Adventures, https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/72-sailer-on-the-green/id1591842383?i=1000653626248
12:00 Eucalpytus as an invasive species, https://www.cal-ipc.org/plants/profile/eucalyptus-globulus-profile/
15:00 Israeli settlers, https://www.nytimes.com/video/magazine/100000009469710/west-bank-settler-violence-israel.html
17:00 NYT: The Unpunished: How Extremists Took Over Israel, https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/16/magazine/israel-west-bank-settler-violence-impunity.html
25:30 ‘I Love Peace,’ Says Boyle Heights Cafe Owner Of Protest Over Support Of Trump Immigration Policies
30:30 Is Boyle Heights Coffee Shop Vandalism An Anti-Gentrification Message?
32:15 Jesse Lee Peterson: Antifa Attacks Pro-Trump Jewish Cafe (Asher Caffé, Boyle Heights)
50:00 The end of gentrification, https://www.takimag.com/article/the-end-of-gentrification/
1:03:00 White gentrification of South-Central L.A. , https://isteve.blogspot.com/2014/04/white-gentrification-of-south-central.html
1:07:00 Ethnic conflicts in elite school admissions, https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2023/07/on-white-flight-from-the-comments.html
1:08:00 UCLA Medical School’s DEI Admissions Push Is Letting in Incompetents, https://www.unz.com/isteve/ucla-medical-schools-dei-admissions-push-are-letting-in-incompetents/
1:14:00 This Invasive Species Caused The Most Costly Fire In California History, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vh8Vd6JLWc8
1:21:00 Elliott Blatt joins – the nihilism of illness
1:23:00 The craft of effective writing, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=154774
1:24:00 How Rony Guldmann ran into trouble at Stanford Law School, https://ronyguldmann.com/
1:25:00 Two Orientations Toward Human Nature by Rony Guldmann, https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N5C2KQU
1:31:00 Iceplant, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aizoaceae
1:39:00 The Mysterious Disappearance of JF Gariepy’s Wife, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Df8SFEOGUmE
2:07:00 Nick Fuentes: The Fake Controlled Right Wing, https://rumble.com/v4x1vd5-the-fake-controlled-right-wing.html
2:34:30 Destiny fans resent my assertion that the average IQ of his audience is about 100 while my audience median is about 130
2:58:00 “It’s called love, you eediot”- Destiny Debate Debacles ft. Jean-François Gariépy

Posted in Israel | Comments Off on Decoding The Arab-Israeli West Bank Conflict (5-27-24)

Decoding The Campus Protests (5-26-24)

01:00 Philosopher and author Rony Guldmann, https://ronyguldmann.com/
17:00 Why the swift crackdown on the protests?
33:00 Conservative Claims of Cultural Oppression, https://ronyguldmann.com/conservative-claims-cultural-oppression/
36:00 Joseph Bankman and Barbara Fried, Stanford Law profs and progenitors of disgraced FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried. https://ronyguldmann.com/faq/
42:00 Affirmative action and student protests
57:30 Rony’s memoir: The Star Chamber of Stanford, https://ronyguldmann.com/
58:20 The Craft of Writing Effectively, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=154774

Posted in Rony Guldmann | Comments Off on Decoding The Campus Protests (5-26-24)

Decoding Destiny aka Steve Bonnell Part IV (5-26-24)

00:10 Decoding Destiny Part One, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=154833
00:20 Decoding Destiny Part Two, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=154837
00:30 Decoding Destiny Part Three, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=154910
00:50 DTG: Destiny- Discussing Debates, Drama, Depravity & ‘Doing Your Own Research’, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zf1IjlbQ33E
05:45 Destiny wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destiny_(streamer)
12:30 Destiny clip on allegations about JF and the missing Mama JF, https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxyEzHYoVQjxMCV2S_AJBBy4qq96yqEy-G
13:00 Race Realism – Destiny Debate with JF, Andy Warski, Tara McCarthy, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRHTD0YMfpM
21:00 You’re Being Lied To By Billionaire-Funded Fake Racialist Boomers | JFGT #1108, https://odysee.com/@JFGTonight:0/jfgt1108:f
55:00 DTG Reddit discusses Destiny, https://www.reddit.com/r/DecodingTheGurus/
1:20:00 Simple ways to raise IQ, https://www.unz.com/isteve/micronutrient-supplementation/
1:25:00 Is vegetarianism healthy for children?, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10408398.2018.1437024
1:30:00 Duke: LEAD EXPOSURE IN LAST CENTURY SHRANK IQ SCORES OF HALF OF AMERICANS, https://today.duke.edu/2022/03/lead-exposure-last-century-shrunk-iq-scores-half-americans
1:32:00 Lead exposure reduces the average American IQ by 3 points
2:33:00 Destiny says his show became less dramatic since he got on vyvanse
2:37:00 DTG: Destiny: Debate King and/or Degenerate?, https://decoding-the-gurus.captivate.fm/episodes/2#showEpisodes
2:40:40 Will and ‘Destiny’ debate what it is to be American | Will Cain Show, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rkrGv7Zrhf0
2:44:00 Signs of Emotional Maturity – Know Who’s Worth Your Time & Who Isn’t!, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vqJJ0imOR50
2:52:00 5 Reasons Why People DON’T Understand You, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voSHsrvErKk
3:08:00 Ben Shapiro vs Destiny Debate: Politics, Jan 6, Israel, Ukraine & Wokeism, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tYrdMjVXyNg

Posted in Streaming | Comments Off on Decoding Destiny aka Steve Bonnell Part IV (5-26-24)