Category Archives: Judaism

The Hero System of Literary Critic Robert Alter

Robert Alter (b. 1935) gives part of a working morning to the word “and.” In the Hebrew of Genesis the verses run on the conjunction vav. And the earth welter and waste. And darkness over the deep. And God said. … Continue reading

Posted in English, Hebrew, Jews, Judaism | Comments Off on The Hero System of Literary Critic Robert Alter

‘A Big Misunderstanding’

David Pinsof writes: I spend a lot of time with intellectuals—writers, thinkers, social scientists, etc. If I had to sum up their worldview in one sentence, I could hardly do better than this one: “Everything that’s wrong in the world … Continue reading

Posted in Judaism | Comments Off on ‘A Big Misunderstanding’

Lawrence Grossman and the Institutional Record of American Judaism

Lawrence Grossman stands among the scholar-editors who shaped the documentary record of postwar American Judaism from inside the institutions they studied. A native New Yorker, he earned his rabbinical ordination along with BA and MHL degrees from Yeshiva University and … Continue reading

Posted in Judaism | Comments Off on Lawrence Grossman and the Institutional Record of American Judaism

The Market For Chastisement

One thing that surprised me in my journey into Judaism was how user-friendly it was. From the outside, Orthodox Judaism looked intimidating. From the inside, it was sweet. While my conversion was not easy, that was largely due to my … Continue reading

Posted in Judaism, R. Avigdor Miller | Comments Off on The Market For Chastisement

‘Jewish Studies Draws a Line on Tablet’

This 2022 article by Mari Cohen says The Association for Jewish Studies paused its advertising relationship with Tablet after members complained. The AJS statement noted that some members felt direct harm from views Tablet had promulgated. The specific grievances included … Continue reading

Posted in Judaism | Comments Off on ‘Jewish Studies Draws a Line on Tablet’

The Costume and the War: Halachic Dispute as Coalition Warfare in the 2025 Lakewood Boycott

The academic study of Orthodox Judaism has developed a sophisticated language for describing internal change. It can map ideological shifts, note sociological pressures, and gesture at “political factors.” What it does not do is cross the line into naming certain … Continue reading

Posted in Judaism, Lakewood | Comments Off on The Costume and the War: Halachic Dispute as Coalition Warfare in the 2025 Lakewood Boycott

Decoding Jewish New Testament Scholar Amy Jill-Levine

Per Alliance Theory: Amy-Jill Levine functions as a high-status neutral arbiter who manages the inflation of moral threats between competing religious coalitions. According to the framework of David Pinsof, humans use moral language and scholarship to coordinate alliances and attack … Continue reading

Posted in Academia, Amy Jill-Levine, Anti-Semitism, Bible, Christianity, Judaism | Comments Off on Decoding Jewish New Testament Scholar Amy Jill-Levine

Orthodox Judaism’s Leading Apologists

From age eight to eleven, living at Avondale College in Australia, I had to read thirty to forty pages of Christian apologetics every day but the Sabbath and then type a one-page summary to show my father I had understood … Continue reading

Posted in Christianity, Judaism, Marc B. Shapiro, R. J. B. Soloveitchik, R. Natan Slifkin | Comments Off on Orthodox Judaism’s Leading Apologists

Rethinking Jewish Philosophy: Beyond Particularism and Universalism by Aaron W. Hughes (2014)

Aaron W. Hughes’s book, Rethinking Jewish Philosophy: Beyond Particularism and Universalism, presents a critique of Jewish philosophy that aligns closely with David Pinsof’s Alliance Theory. Hughes argues that “Jewish philosophy” is not a neutral quest for truth but a form … Continue reading

Posted in Judaism, Philosophy | Comments Off on Rethinking Jewish Philosophy: Beyond Particularism and Universalism by Aaron W. Hughes (2014)

The Rise & Fall Of Rabbinic Judaism

ChatGPT says: Alliance Theory would see rabbinic, Talmud-centered Judaism not mainly as a theological development but as one of the most successful long-run alliance-engineering projects in history, followed by partial fragmentation under modernity. Rise. After the destruction of the Second … Continue reading

Posted in Judaism | Comments Off on The Rise & Fall Of Rabbinic Judaism