Category Archives: Elites

Moral Grammars of American Elite Life: Four Cities and Four Accounts of Legitimate Influence

From a distance, American elite life looks like one culture. Up close it splits into rival moral orders, and the clearest fault lines run between cities. New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Washington each reward a different virtue, punish … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Los Angeles, New York, San Francisco, Washington D.C. | Comments Off on Moral Grammars of American Elite Life: Four Cities and Four Accounts of Legitimate Influence

The Outside Auditor: Steven Brill and the Engineering of Elite Transparency

Steven Brill (b. 1950) belongs to a generation of entrepreneurs who treated reporting as an instrument for restructuring elite systems rather than as a craft of observation alone. Across five decades he moved among media, law, technology, public policy, and … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Expertise, Journalism, Law | Comments Off on The Outside Auditor: Steven Brill and the Engineering of Elite Transparency

The Two-Tier Country: How American Elites Live Inside the Rules They Write for You

A Note on Scope This essay does not argue that elite institutions are corrupt. Corruption is the wrong frame. The frame is sociological. American elites operate inside a system in which formal rules are universal and operational rules are stratified … Continue reading

Posted in America, Elites | Comments Off on The Two-Tier Country: How American Elites Live Inside the Rules They Write for You

Ten Convenient Beliefs For Leaders At The Counsel On Foreign Relations

Stephen Turner’s convenient beliefs are operating at full institutional speed in the Council on Foreign Relations’ New York ballroom, Washington offices, Foreign Affairs editorial meetings, and the private briefing rooms right now. With the U.S.-Israeli campaign in its second month, … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Expertise | Comments Off on Ten Convenient Beliefs For Leaders At The Counsel On Foreign Relations

Stephen Turner on Elite Expert Efforts to Curate the Online World

For most of the twentieth century, elite institutions did not need to hide dissent. They could afford to ignore it. The New York Times, the Council on Foreign Relations, and the Brookings Institution derived their authority from prestige, access, and … Continue reading

Posted in Censorship, Elites, Expertise, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Stephen Turner on Elite Expert Efforts to Curate the Online World

Robert Pape, Jacob Siegel, Edward Fishman & The Pantomime Of Profundity

University of Chicago political scientist Robert Pape, Tablet magazine essayist Jacob Siegel, and Chokepoints author Edward Fishman do not compete for authority by saying they want status. They compete by invoking the languages of empirical rigor, regime-level historical theory, and … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Expertise, Jacob Siegel, Robert Pape | Comments Off on Robert Pape, Jacob Siegel, Edward Fishman & The Pantomime Of Profundity

Why do elites love the word ‘mechanism’?

Because it does a lot of social work for them. First, “mechanism” signals scientific seriousness without having to prove it. If you say “there’s a mechanism here,” you’re borrowing prestige from fields like biology, economics, and engineering. You sound like … Continue reading

Posted in Elites | Comments Off on Why do elites love the word ‘mechanism’?

Elites Hate Power & Discretion In The Hands Of Non-Elites

Michael O’Hanlon is “chair in defence and strategy at the Brookings Institution and the author of ‘To Dare Mighty Things: US Defense Strategy Since the Revolution’.” He writes for the FT: “Congress must not give Trump a blank cheque for … Continue reading

Posted in Elites | Comments Off on Elites Hate Power & Discretion In The Hands Of Non-Elites

The Jurisdictional Wars: Alliance Theory and the Battle for Professional Managerial Class Authority

Elites within the professional managerial class (PMC) do not compete for authority by openly admitting they seek power and status. They compete by invoking moral and ethical languages that frame their claims as fidelity to social justice, loyalty to equity … Continue reading

Posted in Elites | Comments Off on The Jurisdictional Wars: Alliance Theory and the Battle for Professional Managerial Class Authority

Genre Errors: Why the Wrong Rulebook Ruins Everything

Football players follow the rules of football. This is not a profound observation on a pitch. Everyone there already knows it. But move from the field to culture, politics, and media, and the obvious evaporates. We judge people by the … Continue reading

Posted in America, Blogging, Elites, Expertise | Comments Off on Genre Errors: Why the Wrong Rulebook Ruins Everything