Category Archives: Expertise

The Outside Auditor: Steven Brill and the Engineering of Elite Transparency

Steven Brill (b. 1950) belongs to a generation of entrepreneurs who treated reporting as an instrument for restructuring elite systems rather than as a craft of observation alone. Across five decades he moved among media, law, technology, public policy, and … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Expertise, Journalism, Law | Comments Off on The Outside Auditor: Steven Brill and the Engineering of Elite Transparency

Meta-Expertise and the Accountability Collapse: Columbia, the IMF, and 9/11

Stephen Turner’s two case studies, “Expertise and Political Responsibility: The Columbia Shuttle Catastrophe” in The Politics of Expertise (Routledge 2014) and “Expertise and Complex Organizations” in The Oxford Handbook of Expertise and Democratic Politics edited by Gil Eyal and Thomas … Continue reading

Posted in Expertise, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Meta-Expertise and the Accountability Collapse: Columbia, the IMF, and 9/11

Ten Convenient Beliefs For Leaders At The Counsel On Foreign Relations

Stephen Turner’s convenient beliefs are operating at full institutional speed in the Council on Foreign Relations’ New York ballroom, Washington offices, Foreign Affairs editorial meetings, and the private briefing rooms right now. With the U.S.-Israeli campaign in its second month, … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Expertise | Comments Off on Ten Convenient Beliefs For Leaders At The Counsel On Foreign Relations

Which Experts Feel The Most Insecure Now?

Groups whose authority rests on institutional trust that has visibly eroded since 2020 feel the most insecure right now. Public health officials sit at the top of this list. The CDC and FDA’s credibility losses during COVID, the mask guidance … Continue reading

Posted in Expertise | Comments Off on Which Experts Feel The Most Insecure Now?

Stephen Turner on Elite Expert Efforts to Curate the Online World

For most of the twentieth century, elite institutions did not need to hide dissent. They could afford to ignore it. The New York Times, the Council on Foreign Relations, and the Brookings Institution derived their authority from prestige, access, and … Continue reading

Posted in Censorship, Elites, Expertise, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Stephen Turner on Elite Expert Efforts to Curate the Online World

AI and its Enemies

In his 2013 paper, The blogosphere and its enemies: the case of oophorectomy, Stephen Turner noted: The blogosphere is loathed and feared by the press, expert-opinion makers, and representatives of authority generally. Part of this is based on a social … Continue reading

Posted in Blogging, Expertise, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on AI and its Enemies

The System Still Counts

The Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center (PTMC) does not exist, but it does a great deal of cultural work. The Pitt, Max’s real-time emergency medicine drama, unfolds across a single fifteen-hour shift, one episode per hour, and its formal commitment to … Continue reading

Posted in Expertise, Medicine | Comments Off on The System Still Counts

Robert Pape, Jacob Siegel, Edward Fishman & The Pantomime Of Profundity

University of Chicago political scientist Robert Pape, Tablet magazine essayist Jacob Siegel, and Chokepoints author Edward Fishman do not compete for authority by saying they want status. They compete by invoking the languages of empirical rigor, regime-level historical theory, and … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Expertise, Jacob Siegel, Robert Pape | Comments Off on Robert Pape, Jacob Siegel, Edward Fishman & The Pantomime Of Profundity

The Salivation Economy

Deans of public health, senators, tort lawyers, and foundation heads do not compete for authority by admitting they want power. They compete by invoking languages of child safety, evidence-based governance, and protecting the vulnerable. These are not descriptions of what … Continue reading

Posted in Expertise | Comments Off on The Salivation Economy

Genre Errors: Why the Wrong Rulebook Ruins Everything

Football players follow the rules of football. This is not a profound observation on a pitch. Everyone there already knows it. But move from the field to culture, politics, and media, and the obvious evaporates. We judge people by the … Continue reading

Posted in America, Blogging, Elites, Expertise | Comments Off on Genre Errors: Why the Wrong Rulebook Ruins Everything