Category Archives: Modern Orthodox

The Question MO Will Not Ask

Do you accept historicism (that everything is a product of a time and place)? If not, on what grounds? The question is simple to state. It is difficult to answer. It is the question Modern Orthodox scholarship will not ask, … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, Modern Orthodox, R. Aviad Hollander, R. Shlomo Goren | Comments Off on The Question MO Will Not Ask

Meir Soloveitchik Could be a Real Thinker

David N. Myers and Pini Dunner, “A Haredi Attack on Rabbi Joseph Ber Soloveitchik: A Battle over the Brisker Legacy.” Jewish Quarterly Review 105, no. 1 (2015) This is Myers co-authoring with Pini Dunner, who is a complicated figure inside … Continue reading

Posted in Modern Orthodox, R. J. B. Soloveitchik, R. Meir Soloveichik | Comments Off on Meir Soloveitchik Could be a Real Thinker

The Coalition Will See You Now

SCENE: A Manhattan study, lined with sefarim. A RABBI sits at a desk, wearing a dark suit and kippah. A small bust of Lincoln sits prominently on the shelf. He is mid-sentence, speaking to camera. RABBI: As Lincoln said in … Continue reading

Posted in Modern Orthodox | Comments Off on The Coalition Will See You Now

Platform, Pulpit, Archive: Three Models of MO Rabbinic Self-Presentation in Los Angeles

While surfing Rabbi Pini Dunner’s website, I learned: Mavericks, Mystics and False Messiahs NOW AVAILABLE! “A thoroughly engaging introduction to some of the most colorful episodes in Jewish history. A wonderfully enjoyable read.” – Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks “Rabbi Pini … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Beth Jacob, Bnai David-Judea, Los Angeles, Modern Orthodox, R. Elazar Muskin, R. Jonathan Sacks, R. Kalman Topp, R. Meir Soloveichik, R. Pini Dunner, R. Yitzchak Etshalom, R. Yosef Kanefsky | Comments Off on Platform, Pulpit, Archive: Three Models of MO Rabbinic Self-Presentation in Los Angeles

The Sophisticated Silence: Sinai, Taboo Enforcement, and the Architecture of Modern Orthodox Theology

In 1975, the sociologist Charles S. Liebman described what he called a “silent intellectual split” within American Modern Orthodoxy. Educated rabbis and lay leaders, he observed, often held views about revelation that diverged from the literal claim embedded in Maimonides’ … Continue reading

Posted in Modern Orthodox, Orthodox Union, Orthodoxy, R. Norman Lamm, Tamar Ross, Yeshiva University | Comments Off on The Sophisticated Silence: Sinai, Taboo Enforcement, and the Architecture of Modern Orthodox Theology

The Costume and the War

Raising the Cost of Simplification: Marc B. Shapiro and the Limits of Orthodox Self-Understanding The Librarian of Epistemic Defeat: Marc B. Shapiro and the Orthodox Intellectual After Sinai The Terrain Where They Still Win: Alliance Theory and the Quality of … Continue reading

Posted in Modern Orthodox, Orthodoxy | Comments Off on The Costume and the War

The Terrain Where They Still Win: Alliance Theory and the Quality of Life Pivot in Modern Orthodoxy

The prevailing narrative in the academic study of Modern Orthodoxy frames the community’s shift from strong epistemic truth claims to pragmatic “quality of life” arguments as intellectual maturation. Educated rabbis, confronted with biblical criticism, archaeology, and historical scholarship, are said … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, Modern Orthodox | Comments Off on The Terrain Where They Still Win: Alliance Theory and the Quality of Life Pivot in Modern Orthodoxy

The Librarian of Epistemic Defeat: Marc B. Shapiro and the Orthodox Intellectual After Sinai

The first essay described what Marc B. Shapiro does. This one describes the world he does it in. That world is Modern Orthodoxy after the collapse of its strongest truth claims, a community where the most intellectually serious rabbis have … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, Modern Orthodox, Orthodoxy | Comments Off on The Librarian of Epistemic Defeat: Marc B. Shapiro and the Orthodox Intellectual After Sinai

Raising the Cost of Simplification: Marc B. Shapiro and the Limits of Orthodox Self-Understanding

Marc B. Shapiro has changed how a living religious tradition understands itself. His career sits at the fault line between academic history and Orthodox Jewish self-definition. His importance lies less in any single book than in the cumulative pressure his … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, Modern Orthodox, R. J. J. Weinberg | Comments Off on Raising the Cost of Simplification: Marc B. Shapiro and the Limits of Orthodox Self-Understanding

Decoding Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum

Per Alliance Theory: Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum did not just lead a community; he constructed a social fortress. Using Alliance Theory and Niche Construction provides a clear lens to see how he turned a shattered population into a global demographic power. … Continue reading

Posted in Chabad, Modern Orthodox, Satmar | Comments Off on Decoding Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum