Category Archives: Alliance Theory

The Alliance Theory in the Academy

The reception of Alliance Theory followed the format built into the venue and then followed the theory’s own logic, which is the fun part. Psychological Inquiry runs target articles with peer commentaries and an author reply, and “Strange Bedfellows” appeared … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory | Comments Off on The Alliance Theory in the Academy

The Boundary at Sinai: Principle 8 as Coalition Technology

Principle eight is the live wire of Orthodox theology today, and Shapiro’s chapter on it is the most explosive in his 2011 book, The Limits of Orthodox Theology: Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles Reappraised. The Principle holds three claims at once. The … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Bible, Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on The Boundary at Sinai: Principle 8 as Coalition Technology

Reappraised: The Limits of Orthodox Theology: Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles Reappraised (2011)

Marc Shapiro’s The Limits of Orthodox Theology is a book about a coalition document that does not know it is a coalition document. Shapiro’s argument runs at the level of doctrine and historical scholarship. The thirteen propositions Maimonides put forward … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on Reappraised: The Limits of Orthodox Theology: Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles Reappraised (2011)

The Coalition Engineers: William F. Buckley, James Burnham, and the Architecture of American Movement Conservatism

Following David Pinsof, David Sears, and Martie Haselton’s “Strange Bedfellows,” political belief tracks coalition membership more reliably than ideology. Men hold positions because positions bind them to allies they need. The content of a position carries less weight than the … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, James Burnham, William F. Buckley | Comments Off on The Coalition Engineers: William F. Buckley, James Burnham, and the Architecture of American Movement Conservatism

Dehumanization is not a Malfunction of our Politics

The more diverse America gets, the less we have in common with our fellow citizens, the less likely we are to see each other as human. Even the biggest brains have limited capacity for empathy. Evolution designed us to use … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory | Comments Off on Dehumanization is not a Malfunction of our Politics

Why Do People Call Various Beliefs ‘Cancer’?

Alliance Theory treats moral language as coalition technology. Words like “evil,” “racist,” “fascist,” and “cancer” do not primarily describe the world. They mark sides, recruit allies, and coordinate action against enemies. The vocabulary tracks who you stand with more than … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory | Comments Off on Why Do People Call Various Beliefs ‘Cancer’?

Platform, Pulpit, Archive: Three Models of MO Rabbinic Self-Presentation in Los Angeles

While surfing Rabbi Pini Dunner’s website, I learned: Mavericks, Mystics and False Messiahs NOW AVAILABLE! “A thoroughly engaging introduction to some of the most colorful episodes in Jewish history. A wonderfully enjoyable read.” – Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks “Rabbi Pini … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Beth Jacob, Bnai David-Judea, Los Angeles, Modern Orthodox, R. Elazar Muskin, R. Jonathan Sacks, R. Kalman Topp, R. Meir Soloveichik, R. Pini Dunner, R. Yitzchak Etshalom, R. Yosef Kanefsky | Comments Off on Platform, Pulpit, Archive: Three Models of MO Rabbinic Self-Presentation in Los Angeles

Chris Kavanagh: Ritual, Fusion, and the Anthropology of the Guru Age

Chris Kavanagh grows up in Northern Ireland. The “Norn Irish” tag he wears online is not affectation. Ulster teaches what ritual, flags, marches, and sectarian identity do to ordinary people. Men there learn by twelve what group boundaries feel like. … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Guru | Comments Off on Chris Kavanagh: Ritual, Fusion, and the Anthropology of the Guru Age

The Pope Versus the President: An Alliance Theory Reading of the Leo XIV–Trump Feud

The clash between Pope Leo XIV and Donald Trump looks, on the surface, like a moral disagreement about war. A pope condemns a threat to destroy Iranian civilization. A nationalist president defends it as necessary deterrence. Commentators slot the conflict … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Catholics, Pope | Comments Off on The Pope Versus the President: An Alliance Theory Reading of the Leo XIV–Trump Feud

The Traumatized Sovereign: Jeffrey Alexander, David Pinsof, and the Ritual Reception of Carl Schmitt

Carl Schmitt argued that the sovereign decision never disappears. It migrates. What he could not have anticipated is that one of its most revealing migrations would occur within the institutions devoted to his reception. The academic encounter with Schmitt is … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Carl Schmitt | Comments Off on The Traumatized Sovereign: Jeffrey Alexander, David Pinsof, and the Ritual Reception of Carl Schmitt