Category Archives: Epistemics

The Jurisdictional Wars: Alliance Theory and the Battle for America’s Master Institutions

America’s high-status actors do not compete for power by admitting they want it. They compete by deploying moral languages that frame their authority as necessary, virtuous, or inevitable. This is the central insight of David Pinsof‘s Alliance Theory: moral vocabularies … Continue reading

Posted in America, Elites, Epistemics | Comments Off on The Jurisdictional Wars: Alliance Theory and the Battle for America’s Master Institutions

When the Epistemology Collapses: Stephen Park Turner and the Post-Liberal Catholic Project

There is no famous direct encounter between the sociologist Stephen P. Turner and the Harvard law professor Adrian Vermeule. They operate in different institutional worlds and have rarely, if ever, addressed each other by name. Turner works in the philosophy … Continue reading

Posted in Adrian Vermeule, Epistemics, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on When the Epistemology Collapses: Stephen Park Turner and the Post-Liberal Catholic Project

But It Violates A Canon!

I feel like I’m getting ripped off when an expert explaining religion or politics points out how this or that manifestation violates the canon of this or that, as though canons are universal, transcendent, and global rather than post hoc … Continue reading

Posted in Epistemics, Islam | Comments Off on But It Violates A Canon!

So You Want To Be A Truth-Optimizer?

The first and hardest thing is learning to tolerate uncertainty without rushing to fill it. Most people reach for an explanation the moment something confuses them, and the first explanation that feels satisfying tends to stick. A truth-optimizer waits. He … Continue reading

Posted in Epistemics | Comments Off on So You Want To Be A Truth-Optimizer?

Is It Truth Or BS?

How can I tell whether an expert is feeding me his best attempt at truth optimization vs feeding me BS (in the David Pinsof evolutionary psychology sense)? The simplest way is to stop listening to what the expert says he … Continue reading

Posted in Epistemics | Comments Off on Is It Truth Or BS?

‘I Know Things That You Do Not Know’

All of my adult life, more institutionally embedded people than myself told me, “I know things that you don’t know.” At least half the time, this special knowledge was not decisive. When someone inside an institution says, “I know things … Continue reading

Posted in Epistemics | Comments Off on ‘I Know Things That You Do Not Know’

Why Do Elites Keep Predicting The Death Of Fundamentalism?

Everybody has a hero system, and just because you think this other hero system is outdated does not mean it will fade away any time soon. As the decades go by, the masses keep clinging to their guns and to … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Christianity, Epistemics, Orthodoxy | Comments Off on Why Do Elites Keep Predicting The Death Of Fundamentalism?

Why You Should Believe Your Eyes, Not Elite Descriptions

Elite institutions routinely advance narratives that clash with what people can see and feel. This happens when official data, approved language, or moral framing require citizens to discount their own sensory experience to remain socially compliant. The result is not … Continue reading

Posted in America, Elites, Epistemics, Journalism | Comments Off on Why You Should Believe Your Eyes, Not Elite Descriptions

Decoding America’s Moral Landscape

Gemini says: Alliance Theory suggests humans treat moral disagreements as loyalty tests rather than searches for objective facts. People signal their belonging to a coalition by adopting the group’s moral stance. This mechanism turns public debate into a series of … Continue reading

Posted in Academia, America, Epistemics | Comments Off on Decoding America’s Moral Landscape

American Epistemics

Written with help from Gemini: The concept of “no-fly zones” in social discourse refers to the informal but powerful taboos that prevent open critique of specific groups. This creates tension between the protection of minority communities and the epistemic health … Continue reading

Posted in America, Crime, Epistemics, Health, Journalism | Comments Off on American Epistemics