Category Archives: Expertise

Why Are Journalists Embracing ‘Goldilocks’ Descriptions?

The word “Goldilocks” comes from a 19th-century fairy tale in which a girl tests three versions of the same thing and finds the middle option just right. The porridge is neither too hot nor too cold. The bed is neither … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Expertise, Iran, Journalism | Comments Off on Why Are Journalists Embracing ‘Goldilocks’ Descriptions?

The Jurisdictional Wars: Alliance Theory and the Battle to Define Legitimate Power in the Trump Presidency

Thomas Edsall writes in the New York Times: Trump’s Smash-and-Grab Presidency Reaches New Heights Moynihan agreed that “there are significant strategic motivations for the U.S. military action” against Iran. But for Trump, “the key point seems to be the impulsiveness, … Continue reading

Posted in America, Elites, Expertise, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on The Jurisdictional Wars: Alliance Theory and the Battle to Define Legitimate Power in the Trump Presidency

High-Brow New York Times Op/Ed By Iran Expert Destroyed By Reality

Eyal Yakoby posts: “BREAKING: Mojtaba Khamenei was reportedly severely injured, one of his legs has been amputated, and he may not even be aware that he is the Supreme Leader.” I spent my weekend reading the 2025 book “Iran’s Grand … Continue reading

Posted in Blob, Expertise, Iran, Journalism, Pundits | Comments Off on High-Brow New York Times Op/Ed By Iran Expert Destroyed By Reality

Reluctant Relief That Trump Is Bombing Iran Seeps Through Elite Commentary

You can see hints of it. It rarely appears as open approval. It leaks out in tone, framing, and what journalists choose to emphasize. One signal is the grudging competence frame. Analysts who strongly dislike Trump will write things like … Continue reading

Posted in Blob, Expertise, Iran, Journalism | Comments Off on Reluctant Relief That Trump Is Bombing Iran Seeps Through Elite Commentary

MSM Symmetry In Iran Coverage

Most national security reporters sit inside the same information ecosystem as the officials they cover. Their sources are Pentagon officers, intelligence briefers, congressional staff, and think tank analysts. When a crisis hits, those relationships become the primary pipeline of information. … Continue reading

Posted in Blob, Expertise, Iran, Journalism | Comments Off on MSM Symmetry In Iran Coverage

Where Is The Expert Herd Going On The Iran War?

Elite expert opinion on the Iran war does not shift all at once. It moves the way a herd moves, with a few animals at the edge turning first while the center holds its position a little longer. The useful … Continue reading

Posted in Expertise, Iran | Comments Off on Where Is The Expert Herd Going On The Iran War?

How Expert Are International Relations Experts?

I am fascinated by expertise and by decoding what is real expertise and what is self-aggrandizement and socially destructive. I grew up on college campuses, the youngest son of a Religion professor. I love ideas. I love learning. And I … Continue reading

Posted in Blob, Elites, Expertise | Comments Off on How Expert Are International Relations Experts?

Experts Love Proportionate Response

In the real world, when a deliberate harm is inflicted, the victim rarely responds proportionately. They tend to up the ante. The appeal to “proportionate response” comes from two places. One is international law, especially the doctrine of proportionality in … Continue reading

Posted in Expertise | Comments Off on Experts Love Proportionate Response

Decoding Richard Haass

Richard N. Haass is a useful case for Alliance Theory because he sits at the center of the American foreign policy establishment. His career is not primarily about commanding armies or winning elections. It is about coordinating elites. Council on … Continue reading

Posted in America, Blob, Elites, Expertise | Comments Off on Decoding Richard Haass

The Pitt

I love this TV show, but its propaganda is hard to take. It’s all doctor knows best, expert knows best. It’s always pushing the ideology of the expert class, but maybe that is the norm for doctor shows? Yes, that … Continue reading

Posted in Expertise | Comments Off on The Pitt