Category Archives: Elites

Decoding Stephen Walt

Stephen Walt occupies a particular niche inside the foreign policy discourse. Using David Pinsof’s Alliance Theory, the key question is not whether Walt is right or wrong about specific policies but which coalition he serves, how his rhetoric recruits allies, … Continue reading

Posted in Blob, Elites | Comments Off on Decoding Stephen Walt

Decoding Foreign Affairs Magazine

If you run Foreign Affairs through David Pinsof’s Alliance Theory, it stops being “a magazine about ideas” and becomes something clearer: a coordination hub for the American foreign policy establishment. Start with coalition. It sits inside the orbit of the … Continue reading

Posted in Elites | Comments Off on Decoding Foreign Affairs Magazine

Decoding Chatham House & The Iran War

The institutional competition between Chatham House, Brookings, and CSIS reveals how elite authority is being reshaped in real-time by the Iran war. While the initial “shock and awe” phase of the conflict favored the operational clarity of groups like CSIS, … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Elites, Iran | Comments Off on Decoding Chatham House & The Iran War

Calm Comes From Insulation, Not Wisdom

Tiers are situational. A corporate executive may react as high tier on foreign policy but low tier on cultural change if their social world feels exposed. A tenured professor may be high tier on climate but mid tier on AI … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Iran, Journalism | Comments Off on Calm Comes From Insulation, Not Wisdom

Who Can Narrate?

David Pinsof, along with David O. Sears and Martie G. Haselton, introduced the Alliance Theory of Political Belief Systems in their 2023 paper “Strange Bedfellows” (Psychological Inquiry). The core argument is that political belief systems are not primarily coherent philosophies … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Expertise, Journalism, Narrative | Comments Off on Who Can Narrate?

The High Status See Hypocrisy As An Acceptable Tradeoff

Those with mid status see strain as confusion. Those low in status see contradiction as injustice. High status actors think in precedent and reputation. Their clock runs long. Mid status actors think in compliance and consequence. Their clock runs medium. … Continue reading

Posted in Elites, Journalism, Status | Comments Off on The High Status See Hypocrisy As An Acceptable Tradeoff

Daniel Oppenheimer: ‘The Failure to Be Interesting: How High Status People Misunderstand What’s Interesting About Them When They Go Public’

Daniel Oppenheimer writes: Many of us enter into our professional lives with a kind of double consciousness. There’s what we say, to survive and advance within professional structures, and then there’s the internal critical commentary that accompanies it, the voice … Continue reading

Posted in Elites | Comments Off on Daniel Oppenheimer: ‘The Failure to Be Interesting: How High Status People Misunderstand What’s Interesting About Them When They Go Public’

Amusing Ourselves To Death

I do not begrudge selfishness. Everybody self-interested, and that is not a scandal. I do not expect strangers to care deeply about me, and I rarely care deeply about them either. There is a kind of honesty in admitting that … Continue reading

Posted in America, Buffered, Elites | Comments Off on Amusing Ourselves To Death

The Ruling Elite’s Ten Favorite Narratives About Economics

ChatGPT says: Inequality is a technical problem, not a power problem. Distributional outcomes are framed as data artifacts solvable by expert tuning rather than by conflicts between winners and losers. Growth cures all social pathologies. As long as GDP rises, … Continue reading

Posted in Economics, Elites | Comments Off on The Ruling Elite’s Ten Favorite Narratives About Economics

The Ruling Elite’s Ten Favorite Narratives

ChatGPT says: Structural injustice explains most unequal outcomes. This narrative shifts causation from individual action and institutional performance to diffuse systems. It protects elite managers by making failure impersonal and permanent while justifying endless oversight roles. Expertise must override popular … Continue reading

Posted in Elites | Comments Off on The Ruling Elite’s Ten Favorite Narratives