Category Archives: Carl Schmitt

Democracy in America

I respect Alexis De Tocqueville’s Democracy in America for its stories. I respect how it serves academic status claims and fetish games. I respect that this book by a French aristocrat flatters intellectuals and that they love playing with it … Continue reading

Posted in America, Carl Schmitt, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Democracy in America

Stephen Turner’s Unfinished Work: Gaps, Needed Boldness, and a Freer Intellectual Trajectory

Stephen Turner’s reconstruction of democratic theory begins as an act of intellectual hygiene. Strip away the myths. Discard the will of the people, justice, and the rule of law as normative ideals. What remains is procedure. Law is a hierarchy … Continue reading

Posted in Carl Schmitt, Democracy, DSM, Martin Gurri, Max Weber, Opiods, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Stephen Turner’s Unfinished Work: Gaps, Needed Boldness, and a Freer Intellectual Trajectory

The Sovereign Decision: What the Laws of War Say About Who Rules

Every legal system requires someone to decide what the law cannot cover. The rules run out at some point — in the hard case, the emergency, the situation the drafters did not anticipate — and at that point someone must … Continue reading

Posted in Carl Schmitt | Comments Off on The Sovereign Decision: What the Laws of War Say About Who Rules

It’s Hard & Often Pointless To Regulate War

Carl Schmitt argued that law cannot control politics in moments of existential conflict. His famous formulation, “sovereign is he who decides on the exception,” means that real authority belongs to whoever can suspend normal rules when survival is at stake. … Continue reading

Posted in Carl Schmitt, Human Rights, International Law, International Relations | Comments Off on It’s Hard & Often Pointless To Regulate War

Democracy and the Politics of the Extraordinary: Max Weber, Carl Schmitt, and Hannah Arendt (2008)

This book by Andreas Kalyvas helps us understand the Iran War. 1. Wars Create “Extraordinary Politics” That Break Normal Rules The book argues that democratic systems normally operate through routine institutional politics, but occasionally politics shifts into an extraordinary phase … Continue reading

Posted in Carl Schmitt, Iran | Comments Off on Democracy and the Politics of the Extraordinary: Max Weber, Carl Schmitt, and Hannah Arendt (2008)

Decoding Carl Schmitt

ChatGPT says: Carl Schmitt is best decoded, through Alliance Theory, as the theorist who made alliance logic explicit and then stripped it of moral camouflage. David Pinsof’s Alliance Theory starts from a psychological claim. Moral language coordinates coalitions. Schmitt arrived … Continue reading

Posted in Carl Schmitt | Comments Off on Decoding Carl Schmitt

Decoding Jacob Taubes

Gemini says: Jacob Taubes remains one of the more enigmatic and controversial figures in 20th-century intellectual history. He was a man of immense erratic energy who moved through the highest circles of academia while maintaining a reputation for personal and … Continue reading

Posted in Carl Schmitt | Comments Off on Decoding Jacob Taubes

Decoding Carl Schmitt

ChatGPT says: Carl Schmitt still fascinates academics, and Alliance Theory explains why better than ideology or scandal. 1. He names the thing institutions hide Modern liberal orders prefer to talk about rules, norms, procedures. Schmitt talks about decision, friend–enemy distinction, … Continue reading

Posted in Carl Schmitt, Elites | Comments Off on Decoding Carl Schmitt

Thomas Hobbes and Carl Schmitt: The Politics of Order and Myth

John P. McCormick writes an essay in this 2013 book: * In both Political theology and Roman Catholicism, [Carl] Schmitt suggests that a dangerous, unqualified belief in humanity’s natural goodness motivates a peculiarly modern agenda bent on tearing down all … Continue reading

Posted in Carl Schmitt | Comments Off on Thomas Hobbes and Carl Schmitt: The Politics of Order and Myth

Trump’s State Of Exception

The government took away many rights during Covid by invoking a state of emergency, and now Trump & Elon are implicitly stating that America is in a state of emergency, and that the executive has to grab the rudder to … Continue reading

Posted in Carl Schmitt | Comments Off on Trump’s State Of Exception