Category Archives: Hirhurim

Turning The Hirhurim Blog Into A Book

Rabbi Gil Student blogs: "Response has been extremely underwhelming. What gives? Is it the choice of material? The price? Will the few thousand of weekly visitors only read if it’s free? I’ve decided to offer a 20% discount to all … Continue reading

Posted in Hirhurim | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Turning The Hirhurim Blog Into A Book

The Blog ‘Hirhurim’ Becomes A Book

Rabbi Gil Student writes: Today marks the end of the Hirhurim blog’s fifth year. I’d like to thank all of the readers and commenters, and all of my fellow posters: the regulars — Steve, Joel and R. Ari; and the … Continue reading

Posted in Hirhurim | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on The Blog ‘Hirhurim’ Becomes A Book

Religious Gratitude For The Atheist Wave

Rabbi Gil Student writes: There is a thought-provoking opinion piece in today’s Wall Street Journal (link) in which the religious author suggests that he is grateful for the recent wave of vocal atheism: Why should believers welcome this emergence of … Continue reading

Posted in Hirhurim | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Religious Gratitude For The Atheist Wave

Naming Sources

David writes on Hirhurim: "Maybe the Rambam had a stronger basis on which to be ‘somech’ his methodology of not naming sources, i.e. from Moshe Rabbenu himself. After all, at the beginning of Devari-im when Moshe starts his review of … Continue reading

Posted in Hirhurim | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Naming Sources

The Prophetic Documentary Hypothesis

Biblical scholarship is the single most uncomfortable matter for discussion among Orthodox Jews, particularly those familiar with the unanimous acceptance of the Documentary Hypothesis by university scholars. Orthodox rabbi Gil Student blogs: You might recall the "Jacobs Affair", in which … Continue reading

Posted in Hirhurim | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on The Prophetic Documentary Hypothesis

I Want To Be A Rebbe II

Ari writes to Hirhurim: I think this is a bit of a tempest in a teapot. There are some people who think that any mention of their group-identity is inherently offensive. That’s most of what I saw. There was nothing … Continue reading

Posted in Hirhurim | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on I Want To Be A Rebbe II

Is There A Jewish Political Tradition?

Lawrence Kaplan writes to Hirhurim: "Ruth Bevan’s article "Is there a Jewish Poliitical Tradition?" is exceptionally thin. To cite Tevye from "Fiddler on the Roof" as proof of a Jewish anti-political tradition is embarrassing. At least she might have referred … Continue reading

Posted in Hirhurim | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Is There A Jewish Political Tradition?

The Secrets Of Making Converts To Orthodox Judaism

Rabbi Gil student writes: Urim Publications recently published A Circle in the Square, a book that is a combination of a biography of R. Shlomo Riskin until his aliyah in 1983 and the story of the innovation that is Lincoln … Continue reading

Posted in Hirhurim | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on The Secrets Of Making Converts To Orthodox Judaism

Is There Anything Good About Growing Old?

Rabbi Gil Student writes: Aging forces people to slowly withdraw from their careers, allowing them more time for contemplation of ultimate issues. It also places them face-to-face with their mortality. It gives them the opportunity to see the true, spiritual … Continue reading

Posted in Hirhurim | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Is There Anything Good About Growing Old?

YU’s Transgendered Professor

From Rabbi Gil Student: According to an article in The Commentator (link), my judgment (link) on the subject of a transgender professor at YU matched that of R. Hershel Schachter and R. Hershel Billet. The article quotes the two rabbis … Continue reading

Posted in Hirhurim | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on YU’s Transgendered Professor