Category Archives: R. Daniel Sperber

Halakhic Liberal Democracy 3.0: Expert Capture in Sperber’s Project and Hollander’s Analysis

R. Daniel Sperber’s Modern Orthodoxy project wants to give more power to experts with elite secular educations such as himself. Stephen Turner’s work on expertise and democracy is a good tool for examining the expert capture of a communal practice. … Continue reading

Posted in R. Daniel Sperber, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Halakhic Liberal Democracy 3.0: Expert Capture in Sperber’s Project and Hollander’s Analysis

R. Daniel Sperber and the Historicization of Halakha

R. Daniel Sperber (b. 1940) occupies an unusual position in postwar Orthodox Jewish scholarship. He combines the sensibility of a classical philologist with the responsibilities of a working halakhist, and the result is a body of work that has reshaped … Continue reading

Posted in R. Daniel Sperber | Comments Off on R. Daniel Sperber and the Historicization of Halakha

Strange Bedfellows in the Beit Midrash: Coalition Politics in Sperber’s Project and Hollander’s Analysis

David Pinsof, David O. Sears, and Martie G. Haselton’s “Strange Bedfellows: The Alliance Theory of Political Belief Systems” gives the reader the tools to see what Hollander cannot see and what Sperber cannot afford to admit. The framework is simple. … Continue reading

Posted in R. Aviad Hollander, R. Daniel Sperber | Comments Off on Strange Bedfellows in the Beit Midrash: Coalition Politics in Sperber’s Project and Hollander’s Analysis

Convenient Beliefs in the Halakhic Beit Midrash: Sperber, Hollander, and the Sociology of What Cannot Be Said

Applying Stephen Turner’s frame of convenient beliefs to the Daniel Sperber controversy yields reinterprets a beit midrash that has become methodologically aware of itself. Convenient beliefs, in Turner’s account, are the beliefs that survive within a profession because holding them … Continue reading

Posted in R. Aviad Hollander, R. Daniel Sperber | Comments Off on Convenient Beliefs in the Halakhic Beit Midrash: Sperber, Hollander, and the Sociology of What Cannot Be Said

The Humanistic Halakha and the Crisis of Rabbinic Authority: On Aviad Hollander’s Study of Daniel Sperber

R. Aviad Hollander’s study of Rabbi Prof. Daniel Sperber’s (b. 1940) halakhic methodology, “The Humanistic Halakha: Clarifying the Nature of Rabbi Prof. Daniel Sperber’s Approach to Halakha,” recognizes that the contemporary crisis of halakhic authority is about power as expressed … Continue reading

Posted in R. Aviad Hollander, R. Daniel Sperber | Comments Off on The Humanistic Halakha and the Crisis of Rabbinic Authority: On Aviad Hollander’s Study of Daniel Sperber