The Insurrectionist

* This novel reads like Andy Nowicki’s fantasy of a woman coming along and inspiring him to save the world.

* I’m struck by how Andy writes like he talks (wordy, meandering, conspiratorial). He badly needed an editor. I would have liked more vivid scene-by-scene construction using realistic dialogue, multiple points of view, and paying close attention to status details.

* I didn’t experience much emotion while reading the book except for some mild amusement at times — Nowicki has a good ear for how news is disconnected from truth, how religion often sells out to the status quo, and the absurd ways our betters lecture us.

* There are three types of characters in the book — the good guys, the bad guys and the indifferent. There’s not much nuance and not much empathy. All truth and righteousness lies with one side (those out of power).

* A turning point in the story is an interview that goes off script, a bit like the one Andy and I did July 15.

* The book concludes with a noble rebellion in progress against the globalists. “…a sleeping giant seems to have been awakened. And that sleeper’s hate exceeds all bounds; indeed, it can scarcely be contained. Great Lucifer, beneficent ally, please have mercy upon us in our time of need!”

* At just 67 pages, I was able to read the book in less than an hour.

* Like Brave New World, it’s a novel primarily about ideas rather than story. If you liked Brave New World, and if you think Covid is some kind of sinister hoax perpetrated by our elites to amass power, then you’ll like The Insurrectionist. I don’t think most readers were mesmerized by the story in Brave New World, but those who loved the book were stimulated by the ideas in it. Similarly, nobody is going to be thrilled by the story in The Insurrectionist, but you might like the ideas and you may be amused by its commentary on life in 2021.

Here are some highlights from this novel by Andy Nowicki:

* You stood on my door that day (whatever day it was), wearing a resplendent smile that caught me up short. Despite my unprepossessing appearance and slovenly disposition, I somehow felt bold enough to invite you to come inside, though not without lowering my eyes with a certain mortification, painfully aware that my hovel-like apartment was not a fit resting place for such a creature as you, not even for the span of a moment…

* It was revealed to me then, how puny and ineffectual I had proven to be in most respects.

* …I had opted to visit a friend of mine in Nashville. He dwelt in a squalid little apartment, worked a series of menial retail jobs, and in his spare time dreamed of making it big in the country music industry…I too had musical aspirations… We would craft a type of music that could finally bring people together after years of engineered crises had everyone at one another’s throats.

* Global Government Quorum… had managed to forge a historic alliance between nations across the world as a culmination of a proclaimed need for “greater federated authority” in the wake of the social unrest which had grown exponentially during the present “age of plague,” with one mysterious virus after another breaking upon the populace for the span of nearly a decade, creating a crescendo of panic that seemed to be ever-cresting and never receding…

Eventually, there came to be a great clamoring, at least among many holding official positions in federal, state, and municipal bodies of governance, for humanity to “finally to answer the perennial call to unite and centralize” so that the problems of perpetual pandemics and sporadic rioting in cities, based on one inexplicable upheaval after another, might finally be brought under control, in order that the much sought after principle of world peace might at long last become reality, and a reign of righteous order could be summoned forth after all these uneasy years of chaos and revolt.

* I had, after all, always been the misfit of my family; they had never understood, nor even cared to attempt to understand me…I had long resented how they had tended to view me with a combination of concern and annoyance. I was, after all, a college dropout, never able to hold down a decent job, trying but so far failing to be a writer/musician…

* I was now tormented, feeling that my anger and contempt, having been aroused by my family’s general rejection of my ideas and ambitions, had somehow, in some way, played a role in igniting their destruction. My parents and my sisters had been practical people, with concrete minds, while I gravitated toward more of an ethereality of temperament.

* Earlier that day, my friend and I had joined others in the streets for what amounted to one desperate, collective cry for our earthly rulers to level with us for once, concerning what was really going on…

* …a sector-wide edict had been issued, solemnly instructing people to remain inside for an indefinite period in order to prevent further unrest. Once more, the many and varied major media outlets sang an identical tune, using the exact same words and phrases, with only minor variations; they all implied strongly that the best decision for us to make as a human race was simply to “stay put” in our homes and “wait for further instructions,” which “would be dispensed at the appropriate time.”

* What I was seeing on the news bore little to any resemblance to reality…

* People wanted to join in the war effort against the Overlords in any and every way possible, yet the rulership of the world refused even to field a war effort; moreover, they depicted such a notion as pathological and destructive, even subversive and treasonous.

* “Such self-appointed ‘militias’ fetishize the concept of freedom and shamelessly weaponize the grief, anger, and sense of loss that many humans share during this time of unprecedented difficulty. “According to Dr. Rebecca Schlossberg, a well-regarded practicing psychiatrist and professor at McGill University in Montreal, such incidents as these are commonly driven by ‘men who feel themselves possessed of a kind of savior complex. “’They think that the world needs to be ‘rescued from ruin,’ and that they are the ones who need to do the rescuing…such people, while believing strongly in their own righteousness, are also prone to adopting a simplistic, binary, black-and-white, ‘us-against-them’ mentality,’ Dr. Schlossberg explained. ‘They see themselves as self-sacrificing would-be heroes. Yet at the same time, they clearly operate from grandiose motivations that are actually quite selfish and self-centered at heart.’

* “Yes, you lost so much,” she allowed, with a trained facade of pseudo-sympathy, “but, perhaps you could just sit with the possibility that these ‘theories’ you have developed about the government and so forth could simply be an outgrowth of your trauma?”

* Having grown up Catholic, albeit in a lax if not lapsed family, my attention at times had been drawn to occasions in history when the Church had stood boldly against novel impositions of unholy customs…

* I had quite naively believed that I would find refuge from the barrage of indoctrination and lies within the hallowed halls of Mother Church…

* …I felt stirred by the notion that I almost seemed to be playing a different character, as an actor might in a movie or a play. And I thought to myself: might it indeed be possible to become an entirely different person under different circumstances?

* I had rarely taken to social media, for example, and when I did, it was only for personal, not political ends. I hadn’t transformed into a dissident until the post-catastrophe days, during which I didn’t bother with such pathetic trifles as social media; as a result, I would have no electronic paper trail testifying against me should I emerge as one claiming to be friendly to the principalities and powers in the age of the Overlords.

* In no time, I became a playboy and a player…

* I hated, despised, and loathed all of this “in crowd” that I now courted so successfully. They were supposed to be the crème de la crème, but in fact they were mostly dumb as dust. True, a few brains hovered amongst this horde of elite trash, and naturally enough, they were the ones to whom I devoted most of my attention. I learned to speak their language while at the same time to refrain from seeming to pander; in short, it was simply a matter of “letting the game come to me,” and not being overly anxious about attempting to accelerate the process of my ascendency.

* At this point, everyone on the transmission team had become aware that something was afoot, that things had gone astray. Yet all felt strangely paralyzed. If they abruptly called off the interview, the damage done would be incalculable. The PM had been challenged, and the challenger, having been quite insolent and underhanded in his method and manner, would certainly have to be dealt with. Yet in order to salvage things, the PM had to show herself to be equal to the challenge.

Posted in Andy Nowicki | Comments Off on The Insurrectionist

Do Whites Have Civil Rights? (7-21-21)

00:00 Do whites have civil rights? https://www.takimag.com/article/do-whites-have-civil-rights/
22:30 THE FINAL BOSS OF WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED TO THE DISSIDENT RIGHT, https://affirmativeright.blogspot.com/2021/07/shortpod-66-final-boss-of-what-actually.html
35:00 Am I a laughing stock? The answer might shock you. https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=141266
38:00 ‘I’m sorry, but it’s too late’: Alabama doctor on treating unvaccinated, dying COVID patients, https://www.al.com/news/2021/07/im-sorry-but-its-too-late-alabama-doctor-on-treating-unvaccinated-dying-covid-patients.html
41:00 U.S. life expectancy fell by 1.5 years in 2020, largest drop since World War II, https://www.latimes.com/science/story/2021-07-20/us-life-expectancy-in-2020-saw-biggest-drop-since-ww2
45:00 Alabama doctor’s emotional plea for people to get a COVID-19 vaccine: ‘It’s too late’, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRBtwH4N87s
1:03:00 Youtube voice, https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2015/06/that-weirdo-announcer-voice-accent-where-it-came-from-and-why-it-went-away/395141/
1:14:00 How should an influencer sound? https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2021/7/13/22570476/youtube-voice-tiktok-influencer-sound
1:21:00 That Weirdo Announcer-Voice Accent: Where It Came From and Why It Went Away, https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2015/06/that-weirdo-announcer-voice-accent-where-it-came-from-and-why-it-went-away/395141/
1:23:40 Covid Variants and Sectors Returning to the USA | Peter Zeihan, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rwJEcfQncDY
1:29:30 The Fall of China | Peter Zeihan
1:38:00 Life After The End Of The World | Peter Zeihan Interview
1:51:15 Tucker Carlson on January 6 Capitol Hill riot

NBCNews: Whites have civil rights, too, they say in a lawsuit filed in federal court in Texas. For Black farmers and civil rights groups, that’s a proposition that defies reality—and yet they are taking it very seriously, with generations of civil rights law potentially in the balance.
https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/behalf-white-farmers-trump-allies-wage-legal-war-against-equity-n1269737

Posted in America | Comments Off on Do Whites Have Civil Rights? (7-21-21)

News: ‘I’m sorry, but it’s too late’: Alabama doctor on treating unvaccinated, dying COVID patients

Report:

Dr. Brytney Cobia said Monday that all but one of her COVID patients in Alabama did not receive the vaccine. The vaccinated patient, she said, just needed a little oxygen and is expected to fully recover. Some of the others are dying.

“I’m admitting young healthy people to the hospital with very serious COVID infections,” wrote Cobia, a hospitalist at Grandview Medical Center in Birmingham, in an emotional Facebook post Sunday. “One of the last things they do before they’re intubated is beg me for the vaccine. I hold their hand and tell them that I’m sorry, but it’s too late.”

…For the first year and a half of the pandemic, Cobia and hundreds of other Alabama physicians caring for critically ill COVID-19 patients worked themselves to the bone trying to save as many as possible.

“Back in 2020 and early 2021, when the vaccine wasn’t available, it was just tragedy after tragedy after tragedy,” Cobia told AL.com this week. “You know, so many people that did all the right things, and yet still came in, and were critically ill and died.”

In the United States, COVID is now a pandemic of the unvaccinated, according to the head of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. In Alabama, state officials report 94% of COVID hospital patients and 96% of Alabamians who have died of COVID since April were not fully vaccinated.

“A few days later when I call time of death,” continued Cobia on Facebook, “I hug their family members and I tell them the best way to honor their loved one is to go get vaccinated and encourage everyone they know to do the same.”

“They cry. And they tell me they didn’t know. They thought it was a hoax. They thought it was political. They thought because they had a certain blood type or a certain skin color they wouldn’t get as sick. They thought it was ‘just the flu’. But they were wrong. And they wish they could go back. But they can’t. So they thank me and they go get the vaccine. And I go back to my office, write their death note, and say a small prayer that this loss will save more lives.”

More than 11,400 Alabamians have died of COVID so far, but midway through 2021, caring for COVID patients is a different story than it was in the beginning. Cobia said it’s different mentally and emotionally to care for someone who could have prevented their disease but chose not to.

“You kind of go into it thinking, ‘Okay, I’m not going to feel bad for this person, because they make their own choice,’” Cobia said. “But then you actually see them, you see them face to face, and it really changes your whole perspective, because they’re still just a person that thinks that they made the best decision that they could with the information that they have, and all the misinformation that’s out there.

“And now all you really see is their fear and their regret. And even though I may walk into the room thinking, ‘Okay, this is your fault, you did this to yourself,’ when I leave the room, I just see a person that’s really suffering, and that is so regretful for the choice that they made.”

I notice a lot of right-wing Christians say we’re over-reacting to Covid. Well, what is the appropriate reaction to 4.1 million deaths and counting from a virus? What would Jesus say? No big deal, bro, it’s just the flu?

I interviewed Christian intellectual Andy Nowicki last week.
Luke: “When did you start to take Covid seriously?”
Andy: “Never.”

Most dissident right Christians I know take the same attitude. I think this is a mistake for them as individuals, as Americans and as Christians because this nonchalance is decidedly at odds with the deadly facts on the ground.

Los Angeles Times, July 20, 2021:

U.S. life expectancy fell by 1.5 years in 2020, largest drop since World War II

U.S. life expectancy fell by a year and a half in 2020, the largest one-year decline since World War II, according to report released Wednesday by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The decrease for both Black Americans and Latino Americans was even greater: three years.

Close to 74% of the overall life expectancy decline was due to the COVID-19 pandemic. More than 3.3 million Americans died last year, far more than any other year in U.S. history, with COVID-19 accounting for about 11% of those deaths…

Killers other than COVID-19 played a role. Drug overdoses pushed life expectancy down, particularly for whites. And rising homicides were a small but significant reason for the decline for Black Americans…

For decades, U.S. life expectancy was on the upswing. But that trend stalled in 2015 before hitting 78 years, 10 months, in 2019. Last year, the CDC said, it dropped to about 77 years, 4 months.

Other findings in the new CDC report:

• Black life expectancy dropped to 71 years, 10 months. It has not been that low since 2000.

• White life expectancy fell by roughly 14 months to about 77 years, 7 months. That was the lowest life expectancy for that population since 2002.

• COVID-19’s role varied by race and ethnicity. The pandemic was responsible for 90% of the decline in life expectancy among Latinos, 68% among white people and 59% among Black Americans.

• Life expectancy fell nearly two years for men, but about one year for women, widening a long-standing gap. The CDC estimated life expectancy of 74 years, 6 months, for boys versus 80 years, 2 months, for girls.

More than 80% of last year’s COVID-19 deaths were people 65 and older, CDC data show. That reduced the pandemic’s toll on life expectancy at birth, since it is swayed more by deaths of younger adults and children than those among seniors.

Posted in Christianity, Covid | Comments Off on News: ‘I’m sorry, but it’s too late’: Alabama doctor on treating unvaccinated, dying COVID patients

Integrated: Living Beyond the Sex Trade (7-20-21)

00:00 Integrated: Living Beyond the Sex Trade by Deanna Lynn, https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0995YDK3B/ref=tmm_kin_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=1626170152&sr=8-3
03:00 Purchased: Leaving the Sex Trade By Deanna Lynn (12-8-20), https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=135668
04:00 Purchased: Leaving the Sex Trade By Deanna Lynn (9-2-20), https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=134246
06:00 The experience of being interviewed
24:00 Work ethic
26:00 Going from the smartest person in the room to…
29:00 The Book of Revelation, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_of_Revelation
34:00 God’s plan
35:00 Deanna’s favorite Bible book is Leviticus, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_of_Leviticus
36:00 Biblical Inerrancy, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biblical_inerrancy
38:00 Proof texting, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prooftext
41:30 Dealing with others’ jealousy
43:20 An appropriate use of social media
45:50 Porn addiction in religious community
51:00 Attachment theory, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attachment_theory
53:00 From being a star to being a worker among workers
1:01:00 How trauma informs our theology
1:04:30 Making friends in recovery
1:07:00 Sponsorship
1:11:00 Self-loathing
1:13:45 Why An “American Nation” Cannot Be Salvaged, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kv8gmEY27G4
1:24:00 Lack of Character: Personality and Moral Behavior, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=139670

Posted in Ethics, Pornography, Sex | Comments Off on Integrated: Living Beyond the Sex Trade (7-20-21)

What Is Authentic Judaism? (7-19-21)

00:00 Lipton Matthews discusses gender quotas, Africa, and IQ with Dooovid, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W42iIA0pKrI
03:00 Luke’s views on authentic Judaism
08:00 Dooovid’s views on authentic Judaism
24:00 David Cole Stein on blacks & Jews, https://www.takimag.com/article/the-dysgenic-duo/
38:00 Cognitive Behavioral Therapy and Understanding Cognitive Distortions: Dr. Dawn Elise Snipes, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dOoowYQmZr8
47:00 In ‘My Unorthodox Life,’ Julia Haart Bares More Than Just Her Knees,

1:00:00 The significance of the number 12
1:10:50 Andy Nowicki: The Luke Ford Experience, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JulDz9uEUjo
1:15:00 Conspiracy Theories are for Losers, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ekiu9maM3wc
1:18:00 Why people believe in conspiracy theories, https://www.apa.org/research/action/speaking-of-psychology/conspiracy-theories
1:21:00 If You Love Conspiracy Theories (Or Know Someone Who Does), Watch This | Michael Shermer, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IGDcnUbqPyU
1:25:00 Not Born Yesterday: The Science of Who We Trust and What We Believe, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=130046
2:00:00 Andy Nowicki: The Luke Ford experience, Part 2 (“This is the end”), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=abrjiDGX18Y
2:13:00 Judas Maccabeus, https://twitter.com/JudasMaccabeus7
2:14:00 Judas is over Covid, he can taste and smell again
2:15:00 Judas’s Youtube channel, https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCLgGCISOp6Ytu1W6adwvAtw
2:24:00 Judas on Reform & Masorti Judaism
2:35:00 Reform, Conservative Leaders Outraged at Orthodox Crashing of Tisha B’Av Ceremony, https%3A%2F%2Fwww.haaretz.com%2Fisrael-news%2F.premium-reform-conservative-leaders-outraged-at-orthodox-crashing-of-tisha-b-av-ceremony-1.10010470
2:44:00 Samaritans, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samaritans
2:45:00 Karaites, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karaite_Judaism
2:51:00 Why is Judas a west-bank settler?
2:55:00 Judas the farmer
2:57:00 Judas’s interactions with Muslims
2:59:00 Judas on Middle East peace

Posted in Judaism | Comments Off on What Is Authentic Judaism? (7-19-21)

Am I a laughing stock? The answer might shock you. (7-17-21)

“If we were all given by magic the power to read each other’s thoughts, I suppose the first effect would be almost all friendships would be dissolved.” (Bertrand Russell)

I interview Andy Nowicki at 7 pm, July 15, 2021.

Luke: “How are you?”
Andy: “I’m good. It’s good to be back with you. It’s been a while.”
Luke: “It has been a while. The last time we spoke was February 25, 2020. I don’t think we even mentioned the Covid.”
Andy: “That was right on the precipice of all this nonsense.”

How is a 1.5 year reduction in average American life expectancy in 2020 nonsense?

Luke: “How was your experience?
Andy: “I live in Georgia. It wasn’t that extreme.”
Luke: “When did you start to take Covid seriously?”
Andy: “Never. I don’t take it seriously.”

Most dissident right Christians I know take the same attitude. I think this is a mistake for them as individuals, as Americans and as Christians because this nonchalance is decidedly at odds with the deadly facts on the ground.

Andy: “I don’t know how deeply we want to get into [Covid]. It is relevant to my new book, The Insurrectionist. As far as taking it seriously as a dangerous global pandemic, I always thought it was absolute fearmongering. I always thought there were nefarious authorities using this crisis to seize power and to practice petty tyranny.”

While I am conducting the Andy Nowicki interview Thursday night, I am looking at the Amazon page for Andy’s new novel, The Insurrectionist, which says:

* “The most relevant novel to date reflecting on our post-COVID society, Andy Nowicki’s The Insurrectionist is a blend of The War of the Worlds, Brave New World, and your typical fake news channel broadcasts. The story will only seem outlandish and ridiculous to those who haven’t been paying for the past year.” — T.J. Martinell, author of The Song of Wulfgar and The Pilgrim’s Digress

* “The first novel to consider the topic of dystopia from a post-COVID perspective, The Insurrectionist is at its most arresting when it reflects on the chicanery of the language with which our real-world overlords engender inaction, surrender, and despair.” — Matthew Pegas, author of Dragon Day

It seems to me appropriate to ask about Covid when an author is promoting his book as the first post-Covid novel. And how can you promote your first post-Covid novel when you believe Covid was nonsense? It’s the equivalent of promoting the first post-Holocaust novel while saying the Holocaust did not occur, or promoting the first post-Polio novel while claiming there was no such thing as polio.

Luke: “So to make an entertaining show, I’m going to push back on what you just said. How many millions of people would die before you would take this seriously?”
Andy: “The overall death toll, the needle has not moved significantly. Millions, well, thousands, tens of thousands, of people die every flu season. This was nothing… If this virus exists at all, there are all kinds of screwy things about it like the fact that the PCR test doesn’t test for Covid. Apparently the thing can’t be isolated and tested for, which is really strange, yet they get people to take these tests even when they’re completely asymptomatic and they say, oh yeah, you’ve got it. A truly dangerous epidemic wouldn’t need to get reinforced.”

According to the Cleveland Clinic: “PCR test: This tests for the presence of the actual virus’s genetic material or its fragments as it breaks down. This is the most reliable and accurate test for detecting active infection.”

Luke: “But you know better than all the public health experts.”
Andy: “It’s not all the public health experts. It’s the health experts within the system. There are plenty who dissent from what is churned out on CNN. They’re just not heard from. That’s part of what went into my writing of my book The Insurrectionist. It’s disturbing to me that whenever there is a story of someone taking the vaccine and getting terrible side effects and even dying from it, that’s always hushed up and it’s never ever talked about and there’s this increasingly tight grip of control upon the controlled media on this subject and so many other subjects as well. There was a major step in the direction of global tyranny that began in March of 2020 and continues to this day. Twenty twenty was a screwy year. The official account of things didn’t make much sense. I do get a sense of when I’m being manipulated, fear-mongered, when dissenting opinions are forbidden and you are kicked off of platforms. I had 4,000 followers on Facebook and suddenly I was off Facebook. They didn’t want me. Colin Liddell and Affirmative Right also got booted. Tech companies are getting increasingly tyrannical. Governors are running their states like petty fiefdoms, assuming powers that go well beyond what they are constitutionally allowed.”
Luke: “I’m going to give you a hard time.”
Andy: “OK. I would like to talk about my book.”
Luke: “We are talking about your book.”
Andy: “In a way, that’s true.”
Luke: “You said so much, let me take one thing. You said, why doesn’t a PCR test pick up Covid 19? Well, it does.”
Andy: “If you test positive for it, you could have a whole host of things, including the common cold. It’s not a Covid 19 test like a strep test. It has a 50% inaccuracy rate but they’ve been using it to spike up fears. They’re justifying blatantly unconstitutional things such as locking down the entire economy. There’s nothing in the U.S. Constitution that says if something happens that is considered unprecedented, then everything goes out the window and we revert to emergency powers.”

Here is a contrary point of view from Yale Law professors — Constitutional Dictatorship: Its Dangers and Its Design.

Andy: “The Constitution is kind of a joke because it gets violated all the time.”
Luke: “On the one hand, you’re outraged that the Constitution is being violated, and on the other hand, you say that the Constitution is a joke, it gets violated all the time. It seems like you can’t hold both of those positions.”
Andy: “I don’t think the Constitution is a joke. It ought to be abided by, but it is treated as if it is a joke by our rulers. In a way, there’s plenty of precedent for what has been going on for nearly a year and a half. There have been communicable diseases much worse than this Covid 19 thing.”
Luke: “So name one in the last 80 years.”
Andy: “The common flu is more deadly.”
Luke: “How so? We have more than 600,000 dead Americans from Covid?”
Andy: “And the flu numbers go way down.”

According to the Mayo Clinic May 21, 2021:

COVID-19 appears to be more contagious and to spread more quickly than the flu. Severe illness such as lung injury is more frequent with COVID-19 than with influenza. The mortality rate also is higher with COVID-19 than the flu.

So far, more than 32 million people have had COVID-19 in the U.S. So far, more than 580,000 people have died of COVID-19 in the U.S. in 2020 and 2021.

By comparison, during the 2019-2020 flu season in the U.S., about 38 million people had the flu and about 22,000 people died of the flu.

So, according to the Mayo Clinic, Covid-19 is about 40 times more deadly than the 2019-2020 flu.

Luke: “You say so many things, that I think if we looked at any one of them, they’d fall apart. We [America] get annual flu [deaths] of around 10,000 to 50,000 a year, and Covid killed about 600,000 in a year.”
Andy: “The overall death rate… If you believe the way they were counting cases, somebody dies in a motorcycle accident, and they were diagnosed with Covid 19, they are seen as dying of Covid 19.”

Industrialized nations tend to take care with noting causes of death. Surgeon David Gorski writes at RespectfulInsolence.com:

On the death certificate form, there is a space for the immediate cause of death and then several lines for underlying causes. In brief, death certificates are filled out by the medical certifier (who can be the physician who had treated the patient before death), who provides his best medical opinion regarding the cause of death. Part I of the death certificate includes the proximal cause of death, or what directly caused the death, and Part II lists conditions that contributed to the death…

For example, if a patient dies of respiratory failure due to acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), which was the result of pneumonia, which was the result of COVID-19, the proximal cause of death was the respiratory failure, but contributing causes were ARDS and COVID-19, with the one farthest up the chain being the underlying cause of death under Part I. If the patient had hypertension or asthma, that would go under Part II. As I like to say, if you suffer a cardiac arrest due to blood loss after being shot, the cardiac arrest might have been the proximal cause of death, but you still died of a gunshot wound…

It is true that sometimes determining the most important underlying cause isn’t always straightforward, but in the vast majority of COVID-19 cases it is. If someone with hypertension, obesity, and type 2 diabetes catches COVID-19, then develops pneumonia, then develops failure of multiple organ systems, and finally dies of respiratory failure, the proximate cause of death is respiratory failure, but the underlying cause of death is COVID-19, without which the respiratory failure never would have happened. Yes, it is well-known that certain conditions greatly increase your risk of dying if you contract COVID-19. These include, among several others:

Age (the chance of dying of COVID-19 begins to increase dramatically after age 50 and becomes truly frightening by age 80)
Obesity (BMI > 30)
Being male
Cancer
Chronic kidney disease
COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease)
Immunocompromised state (weakened immune system) from solid organ transplant
Obesity (body mass index [BMI] of 30 or higher)
Serious heart conditions, such as heart failure, coronary artery disease, or cardiomyopathies
Sickle cell disease
Type 2 diabetes mellitus
These are contributory factors, but if you have one or more of these conditions when you contract COVID-19 and later die, it’ll very likely be the COVID-19, not your underlying health condition, that killed you. The underlying health condition(s) might have played a role in making you sicker, but it’ll be the virus that does you in.

“…most countries go to great lengths to ensure that deaths are correctly classified. Death reporting is incredibly important, and in most places it’s a detailed process that has to be checked carefully. In most cases, we can say with some certainty that deaths attributed to COVID-19 are, at best, a solid count, and at worst probably an underestimate. If anything, it’s likely that we are missing quite a few deaths that have been caused by coronavirus, but for whatever reason not picked up in our reporting systems, and thus the death count is actually higher than the reported figure.”

Andy: “The overall death rate is basically untouched. There hasn’t been a significant change in the number of deaths.”
Luke: “Life expectancy dropped by an unprecedented amount, over a year on average during 2020 due to Covid. There’s been nothing like this in over 80 years. Do you think they are just making this up?”
Andy: “I don’t know where you are getting this from. Are you talking the elderly?”
Luke: “I’m talking reductions in average life expectancy due to Covid. If you just put in ‘average life expectancy Covid’, you’ll get average life expectancy dropped 1.3 years and for blacks and latinos, about three times that much [decrease]. That’s from the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.”

From the Los Angeles Times, July 20, 2021:

U.S. life expectancy fell by 1.5 years in 2020, largest drop since World War II

U.S. life expectancy fell by a year and a half in 2020, the largest one-year decline since World War II, according to report released Wednesday by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The decrease for both Black Americans and Latino Americans was even greater: three years.

Close to 74% of the overall life expectancy decline was due to the COVID-19 pandemic. More than 3.3 million Americans died last year, far more than any other year in U.S. history, with COVID-19 accounting for about 11% of those deaths…

Killers other than COVID-19 played a role. Drug overdoses pushed life expectancy down, particularly for whites. And rising homicides were a small but significant reason for the decline for Black Americans…

For decades, U.S. life expectancy was on the upswing. But that trend stalled in 2015 before hitting 78 years, 10 months, in 2019. Last year, the CDC said, it dropped to about 77 years, 4 months.

Other findings in the new CDC report:

• Black life expectancy dropped to 71 years, 10 months. It has not been that low since 2000.

• White life expectancy fell by roughly 14 months to about 77 years, 7 months. That was the lowest life expectancy for that population since 2002.

• COVID-19’s role varied by race and ethnicity. The pandemic was responsible for 90% of the decline in life expectancy among Latinos, 68% among white people and 59% among Black Americans.

• Life expectancy fell nearly two years for men, but about one year for women, widening a long-standing gap. The CDC estimated life expectancy of 74 years, 6 months, for boys versus 80 years, 2 months, for girls.

More than 80% of last year’s COVID-19 deaths were people 65 and older, CDC data show. That reduced the pandemic’s toll on life expectancy at birth, since it is swayed more by deaths of younger adults and children than those among seniors.

Andy: “I don’t want to get bogged down. I get that you enjoy the thrill of the debate. Again, if people want to believe the hype, they have every right to do so.”

A Google search of Andy Nowicki and constitutionality does not reveal that the Constitution has been much of a concern for him until Covid. In a 2012 interview with Counter-Currents.com, Andy says: “We’re all men of the Right here, but I’m talking about the typical Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity-type of “conservative” that’s out there who wouldn’t see any equation at all between liberty and nihilism. “Liberty is enshrined in the Constitution,” “this is the greatest country in the world,” all that kind of rhetoric.”

So in 2012 for Andy Nowicki, the idea that liberty is enshrined in the Constitution was just empty rhetoric. He added in 2012: “Mob mentality, exactly. We enshrine democracy. We enshrine the idea of the righteousness of the majority. There’s a populism that’s a part of the nature of belief in America and what America is supposed to represent that I think could be easily a shortcut to nihilism.”

In this 2005 column, Andy Nowicki, in a more libertarian frame of mind, frequently references the Constitution.

Andy: “There’s been a scam element to it all on very high levels.”
Luke: “If the PCR-DNA test for Covid turns out to be accurate, you’d be wrong, and if it turned out to be inaccurate, then the health professionals would be wrong.”
Andy: “Are you about to ambush me with something?”
Luke: “I think you’re being reckless.”
Andy: “You can believe what you want to believe. You can think that all these organizations are only interested in the public good and to protect us from harm… If you believe in the conventional wisdom, then what do you make of my book? Does it seem crazy?”
Luke: “It depends on your perspective. If you look at things from one perspective, your book makes sense. If you look at things from a different perspective, it seems crazy. Reality is confusing. The only way that reality makes sense is if I impose certain patterns from my head on reality. The only organization for reality lies in my own biases.”
Andy: “You are a man of faith?”
Luke: “I am a man of faith, but I am not a man of faith in my own sagacity… I believe that in the end, God will make things right. As far as ascertaining anything about Covid, my faith provides zero benefit.”
Andy: “In the last two years in particular, there is a limited spectrum of ideas one is allowed to have. While we still nominally have freedom of speech in the United States, it’s almost an afterthought. There’s an eagerness to destroy people who question what they’re told. I imagine you’ve had people who want to cancel you.”
Luke: “Yes. On the other hand, there has never been a time when what you say has no consequences. Throughout history, the words you say have consequences for your well-being. It would be impossible for life to be otherwise.”
Andy: “Of course. You are responsible for the things you say and you shouldn’t slander anyone. You should be scrupulous in the pursuit of the truth, but that doesn’t relate to what I’m saying. When people say you have to face the consequences for having Richard Spencer on your show, what do you say?”
Luke: “I haven’t argued back because there’s nothing I can say… From second grade on, I’ve known real life consequences for things I’ve written. I know what it is to be punched in the face. I know what it is to lose every friend I have in my city. I’ve been pushed out of the car in a bad part of town with no money. I’ve been physically assaulted many times. I’ve had countless death threats.”
Andy: “There’s been a concentration of malevolent power in recent years.”
Luke: “What’s the genesis of your new book?”
Andy: “Twenty twenty… I feel like I’m living in the last days of civilization before it slides into tyranny and despotism. I wrote this book to exorcise the demon of despair that’s crept over me… I’m 50. I’ve never remembered things being as bad, things feeling as grim as they do now. This is a work of dystopian fiction five, seven, ten years down the line from where we are at right now… I feel like we are living on the cusp of a dystopian world, a prison planet. In my book, things have regressed even more. On top of the present problem, there’s also this catastrophic event, which seems to be an alien invasion. There’s no more sovereignty. There’s no more nations. There’s just a global coalition government ruled over by a band of oligarchs.”
Luke: “So when was the last time you went months without this despair?”
Andy: “It’s partly temperamental. I’ve nursed the teat of melancholy for a large part of my life, but I know the difference between what I have sensed… It has gotten worse for me because of my awareness of what is going on in the world. Ten years ago, if I walked into a gas station, I’d glance at a newspaper and see what the headlines were, and I’d listen to talk radio…and not just get terribly depressed and angry and despairing. At some point, they ratcheted things up. Trump was the harbinger. It used to be every election season that I would tune out the news for a couple of months because things would be getting ugly. I just didn’t want to get caught up in it all anymore. So I switch off the news. I don’t want to read any [news]… But it never went back to normal. Since late 2015, it’s been non-stop bad vibes… The behavior of Trump haters has been unprecedented.”
Luke: “My question was when was the last time you were happy. Not sure I got an answer to that.”
Andy: “I was very happy through age 12 and since then…”
Luke: “To what extent are you responsible for your own misery?”
Andy: “There’s probably more that I could do about it then I am doing about it. Not sure about how much more. What do you think?”
Luke: “My perception of you is that you walk around with enormous psychic wounds so that anything beyond despair feels not possible for you now.”
Andy: “Once I became an adolescent, the darkness crept in and it hasn’t crept out… It’s been a low-grade despair.”
“I’m not sure if people are going to want to buy my book after hearing that I’ve been depressed most of my life and have big gushing psychic wounds.”
Luke: “Did this book come to you in images, character, plot?”
Andy: “There was talk earlier this year in mainstream sources that alien technology was real… It came to me that we’ve had the Covid op, maybe the alien invasion op is next. Maybe entire cities would be incinerated by this mystery weapon. I’m typically drawn to writing about Dostoyevskian anti-heroes. The protagonist of this story, instead of going crazy or becoming a murderous psychopath, he becomes a hero. He infiltrates the evil and cunningly climbs his way to the top of the ladder and strikes a blow against the forces of darkness. My feeling about The Insurrectionist is that it could do really well if it got the proper exposure… I feel that there are people who call themselves dissidents and there are people out there who aren’t on board with the world leaders, so that’s why I’m out there to self promote.”
Luke: “How would you compare this book to The Turner Diaries?”
Andy: “Well, mass murder is not presented as a positive thing. There’s nothing about race or Jews. It’s nothing like The Turner Diaries.”
Luke: “Isn’t it true that many people who invaded Capitol Hill January 6 were carrying bootlegged copies of this novel?”
Andy laughs.
Luke: “What was your reaction to what happened on Capitol Hill January 6?”
Andy: “It seemed like a farce. Ashli Babbitt’s death was an atrocity. She was unarmed and the guard shot her in cold blood.”
Luke: “What should they do?”
Andy: “Physically restrain her. Hold her down?”
Luke: “Do you think voter fraud played a significant role in the 2020 elections?”
Andy: “I suspect it did. I don’t know if you want to get into another knock down, drag out about that. I don’t have facts and figures at my disposal right now. If you find something on the internet, I’m not going to be able to retort in a way that sounds like I have one-upped you.”
Luke (1:37:00): “One way I try to figure our reality is that I read what dissidents have to say and I read what the MSM has to say. Sometimes I side with the mainstream and sometimes I side with the dissidents. Where do you get your information? Because this information then pours through your imagination into your new novel.”
Andy: “I don’t consume the news. It filters down to me.”
Luke: “You’ve said a lot of things about how the world works. How do you come to your understanding of how the world works?”
Andy: “I don’t pay attention to mainstream news because I think they’re untrustworthy and lapdogs of the power elite. So if you’re going to play gotcha…”
Luke: “I haven’t played any gotcha. I want to know where you get your information. There has to be some series of sources.”
Andy: “It’s Infowars. 24 hours a day.”
Luke: “Why are you offended by this question?”
Andy: “I don’t have any answer to that [question]. I remember election night. I remember how suddenly voting stopped in battleground states where Trump was ahead and suddenly all these new votes were found and I thought that was strange. I’m allowed to think that.”
Luke: “Nobody is saying you can’t think anything you want. You keep saying I’m allowed, he’s allowed. Nobody’s contesting that. You’ve made a lot of allegations that go against the conventional wisdom. That’s great. I go against the conventional wisdom all the time. I’m wondering if you have any sources.”
Andy: “I don’t have any sources to recommend.”
“You thrive on controversy. Where there’s spectacle, you’re drawn to that.”
Luke: “Yes.”
Andy: “You’re challenging me, not because you think you’re smarter than me, but because you enjoy the give and take of debate. The question — where do you get your information from — that can get someone defensive, because the allegation that’s lurking is that you are only paying attention to people in your echo chamber. I don’t think that’s true to me. I think I am open to people of good faith who aren’t going to call me a kook and get me kicked out of polite society… That’s my aversion to mainstream news. They try to get dissident thinkers [canceled]. It didn’t use to be like this.”
Luke: “I’ll tell you when it changed. After dissident right people started shooting people. After Christchurch and Unite the Right, and Walmart in El Paso, Texas. When people who use dissident right rhetoric go out and slaughter people, that’s going to affect everyone who uses that rhetoric. That’s inherent in how human nature works.”
Andy: “I was at Unite the Right in 2017 and the instigators were Antifa.”
Luke: “And the Alt Right were fine upstanding citizens and they contributed nothing to popular revulsion about what happened on that day?”
Andy: “I’m sure there were some bad applies [on the Alt Right], but the ones who were instigating violence were Antifa. I also saw a total willed failure by the Charlottesville police… The Antifa were throwing bottles.”
Luke: “I saw revolting behavior and I saw the media slanting things against the right-wing.”
Andy: “Now you’re sounding different than a few minutes ago.”
Luke: “No. You can have both. I think people on the Right made bad choices to go to Unite the Right and I think the news media were slanted against them.”
Andy: “Why was going to the rally a bad idea?”
Luke: “Because of the type of people who were going to show up.”
Andy: “Because of the Antifa?”
Luke: “In part. And also because of people on the Right who were going to show up. No normal person shows up to an event where Mike Enoch and Richard Spencer are headlining.”
Andy: “I was there as a sympathetic observer. I believe in free speech. I wanted to hear what people had to say. I wanted to soak it all in. I thought things might get dicey but I had no idea it was going to become the thing it became.”
Luke: “Is any of that on you? Did you make a mistake?”
Andy: “I didn’t do anything…”
Luke: “You did nothing wrong? You didn’t misjudge this situation at all? It was entirely the fault of other people?”
Andy: “I didn’t engage in any violence against anyone. By wrong, you mean it was foolish to be there?”
Luke: “You said you were totally shocked by what happened there. It was unexpected. Were you wrong? Should you have been wiser? Or was it totally the fault of everyone else and you were the victim because you came there in good faith?”
Andy: “I never said I was the victim.”
Luke: “You’ve said that all the fault was with other people. I don’t care. I’m just curious. Were you wrong or were you right to go there and expect to have a civil political demonstration?”
Andy: “There hasn’t been any precedent for it to blow up like that. I had been to a couple of the NPI [National Policy Institute] conferences in DC. I had been to an American Renaissance Conference or two. I went there because it is interesting to hear points of view that are not acceptable in mainstream culture… Like you, I am drawn to spectacle… You said you knew better and that’s why you didn’t go.”
Luke: “I didn’t say I knew better, I said there were reasons why a normal person would not have gone to that event. A normal person with a family, a job, a reputation in the community…”
Andy: “Being at an event like that does not mean that you are supporting anyone. You’re just a spectator.”
Luke: “But that’s not how the world works. You wish that’s how the world reacts, but that’s not how the world reacts. If you attend an event that seems ugly to your fellow citizens, they’re not going to draw the lines you would like them to draw.”
Andy: “That shows a failure on the part of the media for not being honest about what happened. There was a failure of the police to do their jobs, which still irks me to this day. I hang that woman’s death [Heather Heyer] on that the police were given orders to stand down and to let mayhem happen. If Unite the Right attendees are pushed out into a violent hostile crowd, of course things are going to get ugly.”
Luke: “You are writing this book from a certain place. You don’t have $50 million in the bank and a gorgeous wife and three mistresses and high status in your community. If you had those things, you’d be unlikely to be a conspiracy theorist and you would have been unlikely to write this book… We all write from a particular place. I am speaking to you from a particular place with a certain amount of money in the bank. I’m speaking to you from a certain social position. I ask you about your experience of the last five years because you are creating out of your experience.”
Andy: “I don’t feel quite as devastated as someone who’s had a condominium collapse on him… I try not to be a woe is me type person. I might have an exhibitionist side of me…”
“I haven’t felt the pull to write fiction [for seven years].”

David Stanley comments: “To be fair to Luke, he did manage to make Andy even more depressed, which is something of an achievement.”

Audio problems in first three minutes.
08:10 Andy Nowicki’s reflections on a disastrous interview, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YewAR9XrtYE
20:00 Are you a sex and love addict? https://slaafws.org/download/core-files/The_40_Questions_of_SLAA.pdf
25:00 The problem, https://adultchildren.org/literature/problem/
27:30 Self-Justification in Everyday Life, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aYcgiX70WsI
53:00 Anita Busch, https://www.lukeford.net/profiles/profiles/anita_busch.htm
1:02:00 Constitutional Dictatorship: Its Dangers and Its Design, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=130386
1:08:00 Andy Nowicki’s new novel, The Insurrectionist, https://www.amazon.com/Insurrectionist-Andy-Nowicki-ebook/dp/B09881NYM9/
1:15:00 Noam Smith: Yes, lockdowns were good, https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/yes-lockdowns-were-good
1:17:00 Fear of infection hurt economy more than lockdowns, https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-06-18/fear-of-coronavirus-infection-hurt-economy-more-than-lockdowns
1:20:00 COVID lockdowns saved lives without harming economies, https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2021-05-19/covid-lockdowns-worked
1:40:00 Lack of Character: Personality and Moral Behavior, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=139670
1:42:00 Fruit of the Holy Spirit, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fruit_of_the_Holy_Spirit
1:43:00 Works of the Flesh, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galatians_5#Verses_19%E2%80%9321:_Works_of_the_Flesh
1:49:00 Voter fraud, https://lukeford.net/blog/?cat=42874
2:55:00 Did I follow my own code of conduct? https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=125692
3:05:00 Deep resentment against Big Tech, https://youtu.be/CFK0pPRK-ks?t=3363
3:18:00 The Shield TV Show, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Shield

Posted in Andy Nowicki, Conspiracy, Covid | Comments Off on Am I a laughing stock? The answer might shock you. (7-17-21)

Do Your Networks Pull You Apart? (7-16-21)

00:00 Marilyn Monroe’s networks pulled her apart, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=141257
10:00 Genres, Objects, and the Contemporary Expression of Higher-Status Tastes, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=141245
17:00 How to live given the certainty of death, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8Hu465KL1w
20:00 ‘School athletics at the center of attention devalues intellectual students’, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=141254
26:00 Seven Reasons Cops Are Disliked, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=141252
36:30 Why Be Jewish? (Jonathan Sacks), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NA2U3zF_BmY
54:00 Rethinking Jewish Philosophy: Beyond Particularism and Universalism, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=140872
1:22:00 Getting to Know the North American Association for the Study of Religion, https://www.religiousstudiesproject.com/podcast/getting-to-know-the-north-american-association-for-the-study-of-religion/
1:29:00 Resisting History: Historicism and Its Discontents in German-Jewish Thought, https://lukeford.net/blog/?p=136098
1:55:00 Reflections on “Thinking with Jonathan Z. Smith”, https://www.religiousstudiesproject.com/podcast/reflections-on-thinking-with-jonathan-z-smith/
1:57:00 Religious scholar of Jonathan Z. Smith, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Z._Smith
1:58:00 Jonathan Z. Smith, Now You See it Now You Won’t’: The Study of Religion Over the Next Forty Years, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lfuypty7LGw
2:42:45 Tucker Carlson on Big Tech censorship

Posted in America | Comments Off on Do Your Networks Pull You Apart? (7-16-21)

The Contrasting Judaisms Of Franz Rosenzweig and Ron Jeremy

How did the essentialist discourse of the late German philosopher Franz Rosenzweig compare with the more contingent but still ultimately essentialist problematic hegemonic discourse of Ron Jeremy? How and why do these two intellectuals attempt to reify the Jewish essence?

Posted in Judaism | Comments Off on The Contrasting Judaisms Of Franz Rosenzweig and Ron Jeremy

MARILYN MONROE’S NETWORKS PULLED HER APART

Randall Collins writes:

Marilyn Monroe had a famous career: famously good, famously bad, pretty much simultaneously. Once launched, everything she did made her famous; and everything she did caused her grief.

Why? Look at it from the point of view of her networks.

[1] Hollywood film industry. She grew up on the periphery of Hollywood, and from an early age her ambition was to be a star. She went along with the casting-couch system, and as a result got looked down upon as just a studio whore. But she kept coming back, from other angles…

[2] Glamour photographers. This network provided her early livelihood, and caused the first big scandal that propelled her to the center of attention. Photographers were her comfort zone. They kept her in the public eye (for better or worse, including the second scandal that broke up her celebrity marriage). And photographers and their spouses were her strongest friends, the fallback whenever everything else went bust.

[3] A celebrity among celebrities. She hung around with big names like Frank Sinatra and Joe DiMaggio, her second (but first famous) husband. The result was a home vs. career conflict, and even worse, a spotlight contest that she was bound to win, and lose a husband.

[4] Theatre intellectuals. These became allies in her battle versus Hollywood studio scorn, low pay, and stereotyped roles. She got in tight with the New York elite of acting coaches and directors, and married the most famous playwright of the day. But from now on, her acting coaches would be in tension with whatever film directors she worked with.

[5] The star/politician nexus. Already during third husband-to-be Arthur Miller’s fight with the House Un-American Activities Committee, Marilyn was becoming connected with the liberal intellectuals. With the coming of Camelot, the media-beloved Kennedy White House was glamorized by its overlap with the Hollywood “rat pack” of Sinatra, Kennedy in-laws, and other party animals. Marilyn is linked sexually with JFK and his brother Robert, until it becomes a little too openly scandalous and she is dropped. Later, Joe DiMaggio would blame Sinatra and the rat pack for the drugs and drinking that led to her death.

[6] Her psychiatrists. By this time, she is dependent on psychiatrists, if not to sort things out, at least to give her drugs and a semblance of allies. One of them betrays her—worried over suicide—by having her locked up an mental hospital. Who gets her out? Her most heavyweight lover, Joe D. Not long after, her alcohol-and-drugs diet kills her anyway.

Her networks offset each other, providing a succession of reliefs, which turn into new strains. [1] clashes with [2]; [1-2] clashes with [3]; [1-2-3] clashes with [4] and with [5]. [6] claims to deal with the clashes but just extends the damage.

Her networks canceled each other out—as support networks. But their overall effect was to make her as big a star as could be: the center of maximal attention whatever she did. Whatever you can say about Marilyn, there was no dead air.

Posted in Hollywood | Comments Off on MARILYN MONROE’S NETWORKS PULLED HER APART

‘School athletics at the center of attention devalues intellectual students’

Sociologist Randall Collins writes:

Anyone who has been to high school in the United States knows there is a prestige system, with the jocks and cheerleaders at the top, and the nerds at the bottom. The term “nerd” has no equivalent in foreign languages; here it means someone who is a grind, not part of the youth culture, not just deficient in athletics but inferentially lacking in sexual appeal and klutzy at social skills. With the rise of the high-tech economy and dissident counter-culture movements this hierarchy has gotten somewhat blurred, but it still has a very strong hold in the way American schools operate. Successful school teams are the way a school—from high-school up through university—gets a public image and public support; and it is the main school-spirit-building activity inside the school. Athletics are sacrosanct, as the center of most schools’ image, prestige, and money.

There are exceptions: tech schools like M.I.T. and Cal Tech opt out of that system entirely; some elite colleges (mostly Ivy League and nearby) have so much reputation for their graduates going to the top of the corporate and political worlds that they don’t need famous athletic teams. As I will argue later, these are seeds for an American academic system that would replace our current one, if the sports-centered school system self-destructs over the professionalization of athletics.

Murray Milner (University of Virginia sociologist) did a massive study of prestige hierarachies at high schools across the country. He went on to develop an explanation of why jocks and cheerleaders are at the top, and serious students near the bottom. Games by a school team are the one activity where everyone is assembled, focusing attention on a group of token individuals who represent themselves. Games also have drama, plot tension, and emotion, thus fitting the ingredients for a successful interaction ritual. Predictably, they create feelings of solidarity and identity; and they give prestige to the individuals who are in the center of attention. Jocks are the school’s heroes (especially when they are winning). Cheerleaders are their number-one worshipers, high priestesses to the cult, sharing the stage or at least the edge of it. And they are chosen to represent the top of the sexual attractiveness hierarchy, hence centers of the partying-celebration part of school life—out of the purview of adult teachers, administrators, and parents.

In contrast, outstanding students perform mostly alone. They are not the center of an audience gathered to watch them show off their skills. There are no big interaction rituals focusing attention on them. Their achievement is for themselves; they do not represent the school body, certainly not in any way that involves contagious emotional excitement. The jocks-&-partying channeling of attention in schools devalues the intellectuals. When it comes to a contest between the two, the athletic-centered sphere always dominates, at least in the public places where the action is. The social networks of intellectual students are backstage, even underground. *

* These are not the only identity-groups among students; there are also the theatre crowd, musicians, druggies and counter-culture types, thugs, working class kids and part-time job-holders looked down upon by the fun-and-consumption culture of middle-class kids. Thus nerds tend to be more in the lower-middle of the school prestige hierarchy than at the absolute bottom. See Milner [2004] for details.

Not surprisingly, the majority of American students who could go either way in emulating athletic/partying or intellectual stars, choose the former and downplay the latter. In the era of increasing competition over admission to higher-ranking colleges, most students in the middle prestige levels aim for a respectable level of academic performance (only the top jocks can afford to be largely oblivious to grades); but they don’t pour themselves into it. They are surrounded by counselors and easy-grading teachers who sympathize with the existing prestige system, who make sure they don’t have to work too hard on academics.

* Arum and Roksa [2011] found that American college students average only a few hours of studying per week. This does not hurt their grades much, as professors have adapted to their clientele by giving fewer and easier exams and papers. And what they learn does not sink in or last long; students retested a year later retained very little of what they once knew. All this has taken place during a period in history when the percentages of the youth cohort who attend undergraduate colleges has risen to over 60%, with those attending graduate and professional schools rising proportionately. This is credential inflation, where the value has declined of a high school diploma, undergraduate degree, or even an M.A. (or for science fields, even a PhD, which now is only preliminary to getting a post-doctoral fellowship). It is a race in which the finish line keeps receding into the distance as more students compete at each level. Universities do well (and professors get paid) as long as they have plenty of paying students (including those subsidized by student loans); it doesn’t matter how little they learn as long as it fits the average that moves them along the pipeline. Grade inflation and lax standards are a way that schools adapt to a system in which there is a great deal of competition to move from one level to another, but this is mostly on formalities rather than what they actually learn.

Ethnographic studies of student life (by young-looking researchers living in the dormitories) show how the culture operates on the ground. Armstrong and Hamilton’s Paying for the Party [2013; see also Moffatt 1989; Sanday 2007] shows that kids from comfortable middle-class (or higher) families are happy to enter big state universities known for being party schools. These are places with big-time athletic programs, football and basketball teams playing in huge stadiums, surrounded by school rituals, partying, an active sex life; they quickly learn how to coast through their classes. Students from working-class backgrounds have a harder time with it, balancing the partying with studying and part-time jobs, and they often drop out without a degree. Universities try to be attractive to students who can finance their own way, and to subsidized students too; outside of the most elite colleges, these universities get what name-recognition they have by their athletic teams and their appearance on TV. Having a team that is a contender generates the atmosphere of the college experience; party schools go in tandem with the big-time athletic schools. Universities pretend otherwise, but big-time athletics usually goes along with academic mediocrity; its sine qua non being sheer size of its student population, hence size of budget that can invest in big-time teams.

Posted in Academia | Comments Off on ‘School athletics at the center of attention devalues intellectual students’