The Champions Of Chastity

I love reading stories about those great souls who put the realm of the spirit first.

Peter Ackroyd writes in his 2013 book Foundation: The History of England from Its Earliest Beginnings to the Tudors:

At a convent, near Watton in the East Riding of Yorkshire, in the 1160s, one nun had lost her virginity to a young priest; when her condition became obvious, the nuns interrogated her about the offending man. When she revealed his identity, the nuns captured him. They took him to the cell of the pregnant nun. She was given a knife and forced to castrate her lover; whereupon the nuns stuffed his genitals into her mouth. She was then flogged, and bound with chains in a prison cell. In an age when the call of heaven was direct and unequivocal – and when the spiritual world was pre-eminent – a general indifference was maintained to the fate or the sufferings of the physical body. When one English king was asked if he regretted the thousands of soldiers he sent into slaughter, he remarked that they would thank him when they were in heaven. The chronicler, after telling the story of the savage nuns, exclaimed, ‘What zeal was burning in these champions of chastity, these persecutors of uncleanness, who loved Christ above all things!’
These stories of physical cruelty would have been familiar to all the people of England in a period when violence was tolerated to a surprising degree. Village justice could be savage and peremptory, largely going unreported. The violence of lord against villein does not often appear in the historical record. In this society men and women took weapons with them; even small children possessed knives. William Palfrey, aged eleven, stabbed and killed the nine-year-old William Geyser outside the village of Whittlesford in Cambridgeshire. There was in any case what would now be called a culture of violence. Children were educated with severe physical discipline. Corporal punishment was familiar and usual in all elements of society. Public whipping, for a variety of offences from adultery to slander, was commonplace.
A genuine pleasure was also derived from bitter disputation, denunciation and vilification. This was a culture of rhetoric and the spoken word. A wide vocabulary of scatological abuse could be employed, while sexual misdemeanours were commonly and loudly publicized. In a society of intense hierarchy, a preoccupation with good name and standing is only to be expected. Disputes were sometimes settled by ritualized fights in the churchyard. Slights and insults were the occasion of bloody disputes. The smallest incident could provoke a violent fracas. One man came into a hostelry, where strangers were drinking. ‘Who are these people?’ he enquired, for which question he was stabbed to death. An element of gratuitous cruelty could also be introduced, as in the case of one man who was dragged to a local tavern and there obliged to drink a cocktail of beer and his own blood.

Posted in England | Comments Off on The Champions Of Chastity

The Machinery Of Orthodox Judaism

To enter the dance of Yiddishkeit is to enter a mystery that takes you over. You might feel like you have yourself together, you’re all tucked in, you’re choosing your level of involvement, but before you know it, you are caught in the gears of connection and are pulled along into a life that goes back thousands of years.

It might be the warmth of your rebbe’s smile, it might be the Friday night invite, it might be the power of morning minyan, but you are quickly entangled in something greater than yourself. I’ve never encountered anything like Orthodox Judaism for binding people together. Some people do pull themselves out, but it usually comes at enormous cost. People who leave Orthodox Judaism frequently strike me as deformed by the experience (Mormons say the same thing about ex-Mormons).

In 1988 at UCLA, I first became interested in Judaism through listening to Dennis Prager on the radio. I liked his presentation of Judaism as a rational system of ethical monotheism. Then I moved to Los Angeles in 1994, and the mystical social non-rational community of traditional Judaism spoke to a part of my soul that I didn’t know existed.

Book Two of Evelyn’s Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited is called “A Twitch Upon the Thread”:

Father Brown said something like ‘I caught him’ (the thief) ‘with an unseen hook and an invisible line which is long enough to let him wander to the ends of the world and still to bring him back with a twitch upon the thread.’”

Poet Haim Nahman Bialik grew up Orthodox and then left it. His Torah teacher is reputed to have said to him that due to his upbringing, he’ll never be able to enjoy his sins.

On the other hand, I notice that to participate in social distancing is to open up a whole host of possibilities that all tend to reduce religious observance. Many people’s habits were disrupted by Covid and have not returned. Once you get out of the habit of davening and communal Torah study, it’s hard to resume it.

One step leads to another. One mitzvah leads to another mitzvah and one sin leads to another sin.

Posted in Orthodoxy | Comments Off on The Machinery Of Orthodox Judaism

The Purpose Driven Rabbi

If you wanted an example of a great congregational rabbi, you couldn’t do any better than Rabbi Elazar Muskin of Young Israel of Century City (YICC). Forty years into his job, he still exudes purpose, passion and astonishing IQ. He’d be the ideal Jew to write a Judaic version of Rick Warren’s classic, The Purpose Driven Church: Every Church Is Big in God’s Eyes. Warren’s books have shaped how many rabbis, including Orthodox rabbis, run their congregations.

Even though I haven’t seen the rabbi in years, if he entered my vision, I would immediately straighten up and fly straight. For example, I’d be ashamed to walk past him on Shabbos not wearing a suit. I couldn’t tell a dirty joke for at least an hour afterward. Everybody transmits a force field, but Rabbi Muskin’s force field pulses at 50,000 watts. He lives in LA, but you might feel him in Chico at night if there aren’t too many clouds.

If R. Muskin hadn’t become a rabbi like his father and grandfather, he may have ended up as a professor of history or literature.

As he wraps up one chapter of his life (rabbi of YICC), I wonder what he’ll do next?

Posted in R. Elazar Muskin | Comments Off on The Purpose Driven Rabbi

The Balfour Declaration

Wikipedia says: “The Balfour Declaration was a public statement issued by the British government in 1917 during the First World War announcing its support for the establishment of a “national home for the Jewish people” in Palestine, then an Ottoman region with a small minority Jewish population. The declaration was contained in a letter dated 2 November 1917 from the United Kingdom’s Foreign Secretary Arthur Balfour to Lord Rothschild, a leader of the British Jewish community, for transmission to the Zionist Federation of Great Britain and Ireland.”

So who was this Lord Balfour? Obviously, a man of high integrity and stern moral principle.

Simon Kuper writes in his superb 2022 book Chums: How A Tiny Caste of Oxford Tories Took Over The UK:

Lord Curzon (Eton and Oxford, where he was president of the Union) [critiqued] Arthur Balfour (Eton and Cambridge), Britain’s foreign secretary after 1916. Curzon describes “the lamentable ignorance, indifference and levity of [Balfour’s] regime. He never studied his papers, he never knew the facts, at the Cabinet he had seldom read the morning’s Foreign Office telegrams, and he never looked ahead. He trusted to his unequalled powers of improvisation to take him through any trouble and enable him to leap lightly from one crisis to another.”

Curzon (chancellor of Oxford University when he wrote this, and Balfour’s future successor as foreign secretary) is also, of course, describing Boris Johnson.

Posted in England, Israel | Comments Off on The Balfour Declaration

We Choose Our Wage & Crime Rates (10-26-22)

00:50 John Fetterman stumbles through his debate with Dr Oz
15:00 We can set wage rates by dialing back immigration
22:00 We can choose our crime rates
26:00 Why was Elon Musk so threatening?
45:50 Alex Jones
55:50 Alex Jones complained Glenn Beck stole his shtick
57:00 Conservative media will always take your side
58:00 Conservative media supported Nick Fuentes, presented him as a guileless kid
1:01:45 Richard Spencer cares more about his dog than the Palestinians
1:05:00 Richard Spencer wants to become the anti-Christ
1:10:30 Power, Privilege, Parties: the shaping of modern Britain

Posted in America | Comments Off on We Choose Our Wage & Crime Rates (10-26-22)

The Right To Sex (10-25-22)

00:45 Tucker Carlson on extremist ideologies
08:00 Hillary Clinton calls Donald Trump an illegitimate president
10:30 Why are only Democrats allowed to deny election results?
20:20 WP: A ‘right to sex’ is not the cure for what ails so many men
24:20 Sam Vaknin on the psychology of victimhood movements
36:00 Diversity, Debate, Decline | Amy Wax & Richard Hanania
49:30 Jennifer Rubin: There is no compromise with election deniers
55:00 Rep. Jamies Raskin declares holy war on Russia
1:01:00 PBS: LIES, POLITICS AND DEMOCRACY

Posted in America | Comments Off on The Right To Sex (10-25-22)

Kanye West vs the Jews (10-24-22)

02:00 Tucker Carlson on American crime
13:00 Richard Spencer looks forward to the apocalypse
15:00 Examining the posture and grace of political leaders
45:00 Hasidic School to Pay $8 Million After Admitting to Widespread Fraud
49:00 Report: Banner saying ‘Kanye is right about the Jews,’ hung over the 405 Freeway in Los Angeles
52:00 Dooovid joins
1:04:15 Ricardo joins to talk Kanye West
1:32:00 Liberals urge Biden to rethink Ukraine strategy

Posted in America | Comments Off on Kanye West vs the Jews (10-24-22)

Seduced by Story: The Use and Abuse of Narrative

Peter Brook writes in this 2022 book:

* Seth Godin, who runs the Story Skills Workshop, much appreciated in the corporate world, posted his response to the events roiling the United States in the summer of 2020: “The way forward is through. Through empathy and through practice. We are each charged with standing up and telling our story, a true story of possibility, as we weave together a better future. We’ve all seen, firsthand, the effect of a powerful story. This proven workshop will help you craft one that makes things better.”

* Rita Charon and her followers have insisted on the importance of “narrative medicine,” based on listening to patients’ stories and reciprocating with stories about illness and recovery—and death.

* As the finale of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Hamilton asks, with a poignancy to which any of us can respond: “Who lives, who dies, who tells your story?”

* Anthony Amsterdam and Jerome Bruner state in Minding the Law that the traditional view that adjudication could proceed by “examining free-standing factual data selected on grounds of their logical pertinency” has been superseded by the view that “increasingly we are coming to recognize that both the questions and the answers in such matters of ‘fact’ depend largely upon one’s choice (considered or unconsidered) of some overall narrative as best describing what happened or how the world works. ” 13 In other words, the “facts on the ground” are not cognizable at all until we make them into a narrative, and that narrative and its meaning are not determined by the facts but shaped by our expectations of narrative coherence and meaning, which in turn can derive from our preformed beliefs about human behavior, motivation, morality, gender identity, and so on.
Legal adjudication doesn’t in theory make a place for storytelling, though narrative may be crucial in creating facts, judgments, verdicts. Stories are regarded by law as suspiciously emotional, as making a kind of appeal to empathy—or prejudice—that legal rules must cabin and confine. 14 Yet there is ample evidence that the law relies far more than it is aware on stories, not only those of the courtroom —usually opposing stories, one of which will trump the other—but also at the appellate level, where the “facts of the case” established at trial must be retold as part of the attempt to judge whether the case has been decided according to the legal rules. And there are other stories as well: those of precedential cases, and maybe of the Constitution—its text and how it was decided upon and interpreted.

Posted in Literature | Comments Off on Seduced by Story: The Use and Abuse of Narrative

My Better Stuff

Here are some of my better blog posts:

* Process (Liberals) Vs Ends (Conservatives) (10-23-22)
* Wired: The High Cost of Living Your Life Online (10-3-22)
* The Nihilism of Illness (8-16-22)
* Dearly Beloved (7-30-22)
* NYT: How Streaming Stars Pay the Price of Online Fame (7-29-22)
* How The News Differs From Reality (7-28-22)
* Rabbis & Rapists: A New Novel Exposes California Judaism (7-9-22)
* Death Be Not Proud – A Celebration of the Life & Work Of Musicologist Robert M. Stevenson (7-1-22)
* Is The Washington Post Hinting That Cassidy Hutchinson Was Sleeping With Mark Meadows? (6-29-22)
* When Did Intellectuals Stop Supporting The Free Market Of Ideas? (5-29-22)
* Vouch Nationalism (5-28-22)
* American Fear (5-22-22)
* Blacks Ride Free (5-22-22)
* When Your Options In Life Dwindle (5-22-22)
* Should I Stay Or Should I Go Now? (1-4-22)
* Translating Inspiration Into Perspiration (11-25-21)
* Running Towards My New Life (11-21-21)
* Like Many Right-Wing Pundits, Dennis Prager Has Been Consistently Awful With Regard To Covid
* How did the American Right react to Covid? (8-12-21)
* HBO’s Small Town News & That Noble Dream: The ‘Objectivity Question’ (8-3-21)
* Dennis Prager Biography
* Antonio Villaraigosa (2007)

Vlogs:

* Process (Liberals) Vs Ends (Conservatives) (10-23-22)
* People Never Say What They Mean (10-21-22)
* Kanye West and the Rise of Christian Nationalism (10-20-22)
* Kanye West is not a Political Philosopher (10-19-22)
* Two Live Jews Discuss The Rise Of Christian Nationalism (10-6-22)
* What If Social Media & Universities Prohibited Christ Denial? (9-22-22)
* Fordy’s Great Leap Forward In Moral Thinking Begins Now (9-21-22)
* A voice and character analysis of Alt Right livestreamers (9-19-22)
* The Ballad of Richard Spencer (9-18-22)
* How do we spread multi-culturalism to uncontacted peoples? (9-4-22)
* Pain, Fear, Stigma: What People Who Survived Monkeypox Want You to Know (8-31-22)
* Dearly Beloved (8-1-22)
* TRS Exposed (7-28-22)
* Dispelling The Ugly Myths About Orthodox Judaism (7-10-22)
* The Sinister Path (6-27-22)
* The Monster Inside (6-19-22)
* Biodiversity Crisis Drives Eradication Campaign Against Super-Predators (6-10-22)
* Where can marginalized losers get self-esteem? (6-3-22)”>
* What Unites Opposition To Nationalism? Disdain For Individual Dignity (6-1-22)
* The Media Are The Lapdogs Of The Experts (5-31-22)
* The Market for Goods and the Market for Ideas (5-29-22)
* A Solution To Social Media Censorship (5-27-22)
* Can you change your personality? (5-22-22)
* I Want To Break Free (5-21-22)
* How Do Republicans Build A Counter-Elite? (5-19-22)
* Should we bring souls out of hiding? What’s our right level of visibility and responsibility? (5-19-22)
* Don’t trust anyone under 25 (5-13-22)
* What’s The Purpose Of Politics? (5-12-22)
Competing for your attention — Baked Alaska declares himself innocent (5-11-22)
* Fame and Friends (5-10-22)
* Please Respect My Rebrand: The Mia, Nick & Richard Story (5-10-22)
* My chat room is not a public toilet (5-9-22)
* What if cults and livestreams are our only hope? (5-1-22)
* Only the Lonely (5-1-22)
* Why Do Entrepreneurs Embrace Woo-Woo Ideas? (4-19-22)
* The Alt Right Hagadah (4-14-22)
* Checking out of the national project (4-14-22)
* Teal Swan – The Suicide Catalyst (4-13-22)
* Tucker Carlson Talks To Amy Wax About Saving Western Civilization (4-11-22)
* Ordinary World (4-7-22)
* The Flight 93 Election Reconsidered (4-3-22)
* How Did Russia Vs Ukraine Become A Battle Of Good & Evil? (3-31-22)
* Historian Matthew Ghobrial On Russia Vs Ukraine (3-29-22)
* Will Smith, Chris Rock and the downward spiral of the dissidents (3-28-22)
* The Energy Stars (3-20-22)
* Putin Seems Disrespectful Of Human Rights, Bro (3-1-22)
* What is Fascism? (2-20-22)
* Dr. Fordy Will See You Now: Be Quiet And Accept Reality (2-9-22)
* Saturday Night Right: Joe Rogan’s apology, the rise and fall of internet blood sports (2-5-22)
* Deconstructing Holocaust Denial With Graduate Student Matthew Ghobrial Cockerill (1-22-22)
* Living by principles in an unfair world (1-25-22)
* The One Study That Changed JF Gariepy’s View On Vaccines (1-2-22)
* The Lies We Tell Ourselves: How to Face the Truth, Accept Yourself, and Create a Better Life (12-31-21)
* Walkabout Guru: Decoding Joe Rogan, Jocko Willink & Life After Youtube (12-29-21)
* The magic key vs the situational key (12-28-21)
* Self-verification theory (12-24-21)
* Shabbat on Christmas (12-26-21)
* Why Are Americans Bowling Alone While Aussies Bowl Together? (12-7-21)
* Sometimes You Need Less Faith (11-19-21)
* The Structure and the Situation (11-8-21)
* America is not a hell hole – the hole is in your soul (10-18-21)
* How talk radio makes people worse (10-18-21)
* What are the spiritual lessons of Covid? (10-7-21)
* Pompous Luke (9-27-21)
* It’s easy to dismiss information you don’t understand (9-3-21)
* You can’t pray your way out of a problem you behaved your way in to (9-3-21)

Posted in America | Comments Off on My Better Stuff

Means vs Ends

01:00 Process (Liberals) Vs Ends (Conservatives)
40:00 Alex Jones & Jared Taylor try to capture conservatives
49:30 Lew Rockwell
55:25 Kevin DeLeon and the latino city council members in LA saying racist things
58:10 Vox Day scammed?
1:00:30 Michael Flynn’s Holy War
1:06:00 Is the media the biggest threat to democracy?
1:44:00 Donald Trump Is ‘Blind to the Beautiful Mosaic’
1:55:00 Jason Kessler: Richard Spencer and former NPI head Evan McLaren confirmed working with SPLC by spokesperson Michael Edison Hayden.
2:09:45 Rubio, Christie exchange blows at GOPDebate
2:14:00 Israel vs Palestinians
2:17:00 DEBATE: Cenk Uygur VS Dennis Prager on Israel & Palestine

Posted in America | Comments Off on Means vs Ends