Is It A Crime To Be A Jerk?

A friend says: I don’t think I could ever convict someone of a “hate crime”. EIther it is a crime or it is not, no matter the thought in mind.
Still, that guy was an asshole for doing what he did
But is it a crime to be an asshole?

Posted in Homosexuality | Comments Off on Is It A Crime To Be A Jerk?

There Are Parts Of The Talmud We Don’t Want Non-Jews To See

In his second lecture for Torah in Motion on the Chatam Sofer, professor Marc B. Shapiro says: “The Chatam Sofer gave his approval for the Talmud to be translated into German. What were the objections of the other rabbis? They said that there are parts of the Talmud that we don’t want non-Jews to see. This is an old issue. The Chatam Sofer was the only one who gave permission for this until modern times. It’s amazing that Artscroll got away with their translation. Supposedly Rav Shach was ready to ban it but the American rabbis prevailed against him.”

“What are the halachot (Jewish laws) and aggadot (teachings) that we don’t want the non-Jews to see? The halachot are obvious. There are certain laws that discriminate against non-Jews. Some have been taken out of the Talmud. Aggadah is even more problematic. The non-Jews made fun of aggadah. They saw these wild stories and used them to mock the Jews as idiots. Therefore, you didn’t want to give them ammunition.”

The Rav opposed translated aggadot.

“These translations [historically] were written for non-Jews. They were not written for Jews who were ignorant. They wanted to show the non-Jewish world that this was an important text. The Chatam Sofer received several such letters and confessed that he made a mistake. He withdrew his approval. Rather than hurting his reputation, it increased it.”

“It seems that some of the [Artscroll] translations taking place now are taking place because of institutional inertia. It’s like a non-profit foundation exists and people’s livelihood depend on this so it is make-work.”

Posted in Jews, Marc B. Shapiro, Rabbis, Talmud | Comments Off on There Are Parts Of The Talmud We Don’t Want Non-Jews To See

The Path Ahead

A friend says: You know that there are not many fertile orthodox Jewish women out there for you to pick from.
Their parents do not raise them to go for a broke middle aged guy who was born into a gentile family.

Posted in Personal | Comments Off on The Path Ahead

The Sex Appeal Of Illustrious Ancestors

Yichus” in Yiddish means that you have distinguished ancestors.

The more traditional you go in Jewish life, the more important are yichus.

Converts and penitents (baalei teshuva) often have trouble marrying in Orthodox Jewish life because of their lack of rabbinic ancestors.

Blog post:

If you’re a female descendant of a Rabbi/Kabbalist and you’re looking for some post-mikvah fun in Flatbush (Heaven, please save us!), you might want to contact this pervy Yid on CraigsList.
I must say that I take umbrage at his classist exclusion of Young Israelites!! (And would Kabbalist extend to the new ‘Ka-ba-la’ cult that Madonna belongs to?)

Date: 2006-12-04, 4:26PM EST
If you are a girl who is descended from big rabbis and kabbalists I want to have sex with you.I want you to come over to my house and tell me about your family yechus and then come to the bedroom and make love. Two weeks ago I did the granddaughter of the chafetz chaim and last night I did the great-great-great grand-daughter of the chozeh of lublin.I am trying very hard to locate relatives of reb moshe feinstein who have big bosoms. Do not apply if your daddy is the rabbi of a young israel.that just doesnt do it for me. No YEECHES No Teeches !!!
Location: Flatbush

VEGANOVICH COMMENTS: For those that do not get the reference to “relatives of reb moshe feinstein who have big bosoms” in the post, MF had two granddaughters, the Shisgal twins, who posed for Penthouse in the early eighties. The photos never ran, because someone paid off Bob Guccione not to run them because they thought the photos would dishonor their grandfather.

Posted in Sex | Tagged , | Comments Off on The Sex Appeal Of Illustrious Ancestors

The Chatam Sofer Wanted His Daughters To Marry Rich

The Chatam Sofer lived at the turn of the 19th Century. His responsa (answers to questions of Jewish law) are the most important responsa of the past 200 years according to Marc B. Shapiro who relates the following story in his eight lecture on the Chatam Sofer for Torah in Motion: When his daughters were ready to be married, he looked to marry them to rich Jews. The rabbi said, I have yichus (illustrious ancestry). I’m not looking for yichus. I want that my daughter should have a good life without worries about money. Most problems in life come because you don’t have enough money.

I think that’s amazing. The rabbi wasn’t rich. It shows that he wanted his daughters to have a good life.

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on The Chatam Sofer Wanted His Daughters To Marry Rich

Seventh-Day Adventists Consider Themselves People Of The Book

The modern state of Israel had no significance in my Seventh-Day Adventist upbringing.

I heard ten times as much anti-Catholic sentiment as anti-Jewish sentiment.

Compared to other Protestants, Adventists are scholarly. They have a bigger school system than any other Protestant group. They give more tithe. And they probably study more Bible than any other Protestant group. The average Adventist spends a few minutes a day reading the Bible while the average Christian probably spends zero minutes in Bible study.

Few Adventists have any facility in the original languages of the Bible and the type of intensive text study that Jews engage in is virtually unknown by lay Christians.

Adventist religious services on Sabbath morning last about three hours, approximately the same time as the average Jewish religious service on Sabbath mornings.

Services for other Christians on their day of worship usually last about an hour.

According to Wikipedia: “As stated on its official world website, the Seventh-day Adventist Church (SDA) also embraces the term People of the Book. As also noted in its official flagship publication Adventist World (February 2010 edition), it is claimed prominent Islamic leaders have endorsed Seventh-day Adventists as the Qur’an’s true People of the Book.”

Seventh-Day Adventist leader William G. Johnsson writes:

Three years ago General Conference president Jan Paulsen asked me to work on developing interfaith relations with leaders of the world’s religions. With Adventists numbering some 17 million in more than 200 countries, it makes sense—indeed, our mission demands—that we make efforts to understand people of other faiths, so that we may share with them our values and hope in the return of Jesus.

During these three years I have focused on making contacts with leaders of Islam. Slowly, steadily, several convictions have taken deep root in my psyche.

…Several months ago I received a message totally outside my previous frame of reference: a spiritual leader of many thousands of Muslims in several countries, a sheikh, stated that God had given him a vision about Adventists. He had made contact with lay Adventists; now he was asking to meet with leaders from the General Conference. What to make of such a request?

After consultation with Pastor Paulsen and others it was decided that a few of us from headquarters should follow up, with a view to entering into serious discussions if they should seem warranted. In preparation for this meeting, I made an advance trip to get acquainted with the sheikh. The nine hours I spent with him, spread over two days, were, to say the least, memorable.

…I turn now to a second conviction: Seventh-day Adventists are uniquely positioned to bring the gospel to Muslims.

Adventists have the following advantages over other Christians in taking the good news to Muslims:

The place of the Scriptures. We base our practices and beliefs on the Bible and the Bible alone. This devotion and loyalty to the revealed Word impresses Muslims, who look to the Koran as God’s revelation.

Lifestyle. Our abstinence from pork and alcohol comes as a welcome surprise to Muslims, who are not used to associating Christians with these practices. This means that Adventists and Muslims can enjoy table fellowship without apprehension—an important factor in establishing basic relationships. Beyond these practices, the Adventist emphasis on simplicity and modesty resonates with sincere Muslims, whose religion is a 24/7 matter.

Concern with the last days. The ideas of the last judgment, the second coming of Jesus, and the resurrection play a prominent role in Islamic thought. For serious Muslims all of life is lived with a view to one’s standing in the final judgment. Their teachings differ from ours in important respects, but the key ideas in common present an opportunity for Adventists to present instruction that will enlighten their understanding.

The Sabbath. The Koran mentions the Sabbath, and in a positive light; it makes no mention of the first day of the week as a day of worship. Our observance of the Sabbath, enshrined in our very name, sets us apart as a people obedient to divine revelation.

Cosmic conflict. Muslims understand events on this earth against the backdrop of a cosmic struggle between good and evil, in which Iblis—Satan—and evil beings play a major role. This broad framework has obvious parallels—along with significant differences—with the Adventist understanding of the great controversy between Christ and Satan.

Creation. Both Muslims and Adventists believe in the doctrine of creation and reject the theory of evolution.

Health. Muslims have a keen interest in health and healthful living. Adventists and Muslims enter into easy partnerships to improve the quality of life. In the Middle East, Adventists operated a series of hospitals and clinics in Muslim countries, while Loma Linda University and Medical Center has an ongoing relationship with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan.

Relation to Israel. The fact that as a church Adventists refuse to be identified with any geopolitical lobby is a huge plus in the Muslim world. We are not part of a pro-Israel lobby: we believe in justice for all peoples, Israelis and Palestinians alike.

Posted in Adventist, Jews | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Seventh-Day Adventists Consider Themselves People Of The Book

Aish HaTorah’s Rosh Hashanah Video

In his second lecture for Torah in Motion on Rabbi Moses Kunitz, professor Marc B. Shapiro says: “Simcha says that naming the yeshiva Ohr Somayach is good marketing. Why? I can almost guarantee you that almost 100% of all the students who begin studying at the yeshiva have never heard of Rabbi Meir Simcha of Dvinsk. These people are baalei teshuva (penitents). They don’t know anything.”

“If you know the kiruv world, Ohr Somayach is more of a dour place than Aish HaTorah, which is all about fun and rejoicing and happiness. All you have to do is to look at their nonsensical videos, which annoy me to no end. If you’ve seen the Rosh Hashanah video, as though any shul in the world you go to you’re going to find people dancing like that guy on the motorcycle.

“It annoys me to no end because you have to be honest and tell people that Rosh Hashanah can be boring. It’s a long service. We sit there but that’s part of the struggle. We don’t do this often, just twice a year, Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur. To try to bring in the non-religious by making it seem that if you go to shul you’ll find people dancing like Purim, like that guy on the motorcycle. I think that video is disgraceful. You’ll never find Ohr Somayach something like that. Ohr Somayach is a standard Lithuanian yeshiva. They have limits beyond which they don’t believe in going. They don’t honor inter-married people. It’s much more serious.”

Posted in Aish HaTorah, Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on Aish HaTorah’s Rosh Hashanah Video

Shmuel Kamenetsky – America’s Pope

In his second lecture for Torah in Motion on Rabbi Moses Kunitz, professor Marc B. Shapiro says: “They’re building Shmuel Kamenetsky into America’s pope. He now is the man to deal with all issues, be it Orthodox gays… Ten years ago, five years ago, I wouldn’t have said Shmuel Kamenetsky. I would’ve said Dovid Feinstein or someone else. The roshei yeshiva at YU (Mordecai Willig, Hershel Shachter, David Bleich), there’s no comparison [in their superiority in Torah knowledge when compared to Rav Shmuel Kamenetsky and the Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah in America.”

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, Orthodoxy | Comments Off on Shmuel Kamenetsky – America’s Pope

Do Jews Need To Listen To Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah?

According to Wikipedia: “Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah[1] (Heb.: מועצת גדולי התורה (“Council of [great] Torah Sages”)) refers to the supreme rabbinical policy-making council of any of several related Haredi Jewish organizations.”

In his second lecture for Torah in Motion on Rabbi Moses Kunitz, professor Marc B. Shapiro says: “There was a plan [in 1912] put forth by Agudath Yisrael that there would be 23 rabbis on this Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah.”

“This whole thing is a fiction. It hasn’t existed for many years. Yes, there is a so-called council of Torah sages in Israel. First, they never meet. They can go years without meeting. In the Agudah world, decisions are made by important rabbis (such as Rav Elyashiv or Rav Shach). These groups find one great rabbi and he makes the decision. For the Hasidic world, decisions would be made by the Gerrer rebbe or the Belzer rebbe. I’ve termed this the papal model. These groups find one great rabbi and he makes the decisions. No one took on Rav Shach [except the Gerrer rebbe] and Chaim Ozer Grodzinski.”

“Agudah wanted to make it 23 sages, which would correspond to the small sanhedrin of ancient times, with the idea that when they made a decision, it would be authoritative. They still think it is authoritative. Just watch some of the videos online of some of the spokesmen at the Agudah convention. It’s a joke. This Rabbi Sherrer and others. Many people in the Lithuanian world don’t go anymore. These guys getting up and saying everyone is obligated to listen to the Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah. There’s no one on the Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah who comes near Rav Hershel Schachter in Torah knowledge.”

“The American Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah used to meet. You had people of huge stature such as Reb Moshe Feinstein. Rav Aron Kotler kept Rav Ruderman off it for a while. There was a famous dispute where Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky got so angry at Moshe Feinstein because Reb Moshe would not condemn Chabad. Reb Moshe was always sympathetic to Chabad.

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, Orthodoxy | Comments Off on Do Jews Need To Listen To Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah?

Torah Geniuses Uncrushed By Convention

In his second lecture for Torah in Motion on Rabbi Moses Kunitz, professor Marc B. Shapiro says about the Ohr Somayach: “All of his education came from his father. He comes into that category of people with the Chazon Ish and Rav J.B. Soloveitchik, because he did not study in a structured setting, that allowed his mind to wander and grow.”

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on Torah Geniuses Uncrushed By Convention