Category Archives: Alliance Theory

Why do educated people use “distasteful” to condemn?

It seems weak and prissy and the opposite of compelling and logical and forceful. ChatGPT says: Because “distasteful” is doing alliance work, not moral work. Among educated elites, open condemnation is risky. Strong moral language signals passion, anger, or certainty. … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory | Comments Off on Why do educated people use “distasteful” to condemn?

When Status Games Collapse

David Pinsof writes: When a status game collapses, the players experience something like an inversion of the social hierarchy. The higher one’s rank, the more people one must have stepped on to acquire it. The more time and energy one … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, America, Status | Comments Off on When Status Games Collapse

Life Under A Clicktatorship

Gemini says: A “clicktatorship” is a term coined to describe a form of government that merges a social media-first worldview with authoritarian tendencies. It represents a governing style where decisions, policy, and official actions are driven by, and responsive to, … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, America, Journalism | Comments Off on Life Under A Clicktatorship

Rupert Murdoch vs The Establishment

I’m reading the new Gabriel Sherman book, Bonfire of the Murdochs: How the Epic Fight to Control the Last Great Media Dynasty Broke a Family –– and the World, and it seems like a case study in Alliance Theory, elite … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Elites, Fox, Journalism, Rupert Murdoch, Tucker Carlson | Comments Off on Rupert Murdoch vs The Establishment

Charisma Requires Managing Social Paradox

David Pinsof writes Feb. 2, 2026: Being charismatic means being good at social paradoxes. Think about a charismatic person—Elizabeth Holmes, Robert Downey Jr., Bob Dylan, whoever does it for you. What powers do they have? What can they do that … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Charisma, Economics, Status | Comments Off on Charisma Requires Managing Social Paradox

What Is Charisma?

David Pinsof writes: Being charismatic means being good at social paradoxes. Think about a charismatic person—Elizabeth Holmes, Robert Downey Jr., Bob Dylan, whoever does it for you. What powers do they have? What can they do that we can’t? Well, … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Charisma | Comments Off on What Is Charisma?

How goes the elite crusade to extend the HRification of society?

ChatGPT says: Poorly, and in ways Alliance Theory would predict. The “HRification of society” was an attempt to scale workplace compliance norms into culture wide governance. It worked briefly when elite legitimacy was high and dissent was marginal. That window … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory | Comments Off on How goes the elite crusade to extend the HRification of society?

The Trump-Tucker Relationship

ChatGPT says: Alliance Theory sees Tucker and Trump as two high-status actors with overlapping but nonidentical coalitions, locked in a recurring coordination problem rather than a stable alliance. Trump is a coalition leader. Tucker is a coalition amplifier. They need … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Tucker Carlson | Comments Off on The Trump-Tucker Relationship

The Vetting Of Josh Shapiro

Since it was revealed in 1985 that American Jew Jonathan Pollard had stolen American national security secrets and given them to Israel which may have then traded them to the Soviet Union, Jews in national security have undergone more intense … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, America | Comments Off on The Vetting Of Josh Shapiro

Conservative Claims of Cultural Oppression: On the Nature and Origins of Conservaphobia

ChatGPT says: Through an Alliance Theory lens, Rony Guldmann’s Conservative Claims of Cultural Oppression is not mainly about whether conservatives are “objectively” oppressed. It is about how alliance psychology generates and stabilizes claims of victimhood when a group loses control … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory | Comments Off on Conservative Claims of Cultural Oppression: On the Nature and Origins of Conservaphobia