Category Archives: Intellectuals

Who Are The Leading Public Intellectuals Doing The Least Alliance Work?

Alliance work is a behavior, not a property of a man. The same writer can do almost none of it on one subject and a great deal on another. John McWhorter (b. 1965) imposes costs on his own side when … Continue reading

Posted in Intellectuals | Comments Off on Who Are The Leading Public Intellectuals Doing The Least Alliance Work?

The Cost of Refusing the Misunderstanding Myth

Most intellectuals hold a flattering belief. They think the world breaks because people fail to understand things. Fix the understanding and you fix the world. Polarization comes from bias. Bigotry comes from ignorance. War comes from miscalculation. The intellectual, the … Continue reading

Posted in David Pinsof, Intellectuals | Comments Off on The Cost of Refusing the Misunderstanding Myth

Famous Writers Stuck In The Trap Of Audience Expectations

Most famous writers know more than they say but they keep turning out blinkered work anyway. A few have refused. Stuck in the trap: Ta-Nehisi Coates (b. 1975) writes for college-educated liberal Whites who buy his books and grant him … Continue reading

Posted in Intellectuals | Comments Off on Famous Writers Stuck In The Trap Of Audience Expectations

The Neglected Intellectual

The sociology of intellectuals has a thin but useful shelf on this. Lewis Coser (1913-2003), Edward Shils (1910-1995), Pierre Bourdieu (1930-2002), Russell Jacoby (b. 1945), and Randall Collins (b. 1941) all treat the complaint of neglect as a structural feature … Continue reading

Posted in Guru, Intellectuals | Comments Off on The Neglected Intellectual

Did Israel Go To War With An Idea On October 7?

Intellectuals see a world rotating around ideas. They love the idea, for example, that America is an idea, and that Israel went to war with an idea on October 7. I don’t see things this way. I think America is … Continue reading

Posted in Intellectuals | Comments Off on Did Israel Go To War With An Idea On October 7?

The Lonely Path Of The Unauthorized Jewish Intellectual

The unauthorized Jewish intellectual occupies a specific structural position. He speaks in his own name, accepts the social cost, and refuses to let Jewish meaning be mediated entirely by rabbis, states, or universities. He writes for adults rather than committees. … Continue reading

Posted in Intellectuals, Orthodoxy | Comments Off on The Lonely Path Of The Unauthorized Jewish Intellectual

‘More on the decline and fall of Steven Levitt’

If you optimize for truth, you are less likely to go downmarket chasing likes. Optimizing for truth is good, but like all good things, it can be taken too far. Just as you can drink too much and engage in … Continue reading

Posted in Intellectuals | Comments Off on ‘More on the decline and fall of Steven Levitt’

Why Are Intellectuals Antinomic?

I didn’t know the meaning of “antinomic” when a philosopher emailed that analysis of intellectuals so off I went to ChatGPT, which explained: If we take Edward Shils’ theory seriously—that intellectuals are structurally antinomic—then the consequences run through their inner … Continue reading

Posted in Intellectuals | Comments Off on Why Are Intellectuals Antinomic?

On Public Intellectualism in the Twenty-First Century

Michael Zuckert writes in the 2016 book Public Intellectuals in the Global Arena: Professors or Pundits? * the lure of public fame, power, and even wealth made available through the mass public audience leads to suspicions about the motives of … Continue reading

Posted in Intellectuals | Comments Off on On Public Intellectualism in the Twenty-First Century

The Existentialist Moment: The Rise of Sartre as a Public Intellectual

Cambridge sociologist Patrick Baert writes in this 2015 book: * There is fourthly the authenticity bias. We are referring to those studies of intellectuals that assume that intellectuals have a clear sense of their identity and values, with these self-notions … Continue reading

Posted in Intellectuals | Comments Off on The Existentialist Moment: The Rise of Sartre as a Public Intellectual