Jews usually ask “how” instead of “why” about Holocaust deniers. We ask, how can they deny the Holocaust? The important question is why do they deny the Holocaust.
In my view, they deny the Holocaust to deny the narrative that Jews were 100% innocent (rather than comprising a group that has interests that clash with the interests of other groups) and to signal to each other that they want to commit another genocide against Jews.
Hating Jews is not socially acceptable in the West today so those who hate Jews usually speak in code.
Holocaust denial is the act of and theory behind denying the genocide of Jews in the Holocaust during World War II. The key claims of Holocaust denial are that the German Nazi government had no Final Solution policy or intention of exterminating Jews, Nazi authorities did not use extermination camps and gas chambers to mass murder Jews, and the actual number of Jews killed was significantly (typically an order of magnitude) lower than the historically accepted figure of 5 to 6 million.
Holocaust deniers generally do not accept the term denial as an appropriate description of their activities, and use the term revisionism instead. Scholars use the term “denial” to differentiate Holocaust deniers from historical revisionists, who use established historical methodologies. The methodologies of Holocaust deniers are criticized as based on a predetermined conclusion that ignores extensive historical evidence to the contrary.
Most Holocaust denial claims imply, or openly state, that the Holocaust is a hoax arising out of a deliberate Jewish conspiracy to advance the interest of Jews at the expense of other peoples. For this reason, Holocaust denial is generally considered to be an antisemitic conspiracy theory, and it frequently encounters criticism.
Greg Johnson runs Counter-Currents publishing and he is a leading white nationalist thinker, tending towards the hardcore end of the spectrum (as opposed to the softcore types like the neo-confederates, who don’t tend to hate Jews).
Johnson does not deny the existence of the Holocaust but he denies it as a tool for destroying white pride. He wrote:
White Nationalists need to deal with the holocaust just as we need to deal with the Jewish Question in general.
It is futile to focus on white advocacy alone and ignore the Jews, simply because the Jews will not return the favor. You might not pick Jews as the enemy, but they will pick you. You might wish to see Jews as whites, but Jews see themselves as a distinct people. Thus they see any nationalism but their own as a threat.
It is futile for White Nationalists to ignore the holocaust, for the holocaust is one of the principal tools by which Jews seek to stigmatize white ethnic pride and self-assertion. As soon as a white person expresses the barest inkling of nationalism or racial consciousness, he will be asked “What about the holocaust? You’re not defending genocide, are you?”
The holocaust is specifically a weapon of moral intimidation. It is routinely put forward as the worst thing that has ever happened, the world’s supreme evil. Anybody who would defend it, or anything connected to it, is therefore evil by association. The holocaust is evoked to cast uppity whites into the world’s deepest moral pit, from which they will have to extricate themselves before they can say another word. And that word had better be an apology. To borrow a turn of phrase from Jonathan Bowden, the holocaust is a moral “cloud” over the heads of whites.
Jews have used the horror of the Holocaust to stigmatize any negative assessment of Jews as a group. Stephen Steinlight wrote in 2001: “For perhaps another generation, an optimistic forecast, the Jewish community is thus in a position where it will be able to divide and conquer and enter into selective coalitions that support our agendas.”
“That America has largely tolerated this dual loyalty — we get a free pass, I suspect, largely over Christian guilt about the Holocaust — makes it no less a reality.”
Life is filled with harsh brutal choices. America’s white nationalists are no longer in preserve mode as more non-white children are born in the U.S. every day than white kids. They’re looking to create a whites-only country.
If the collapse of America happens slowly, Jews may be able to make deals with the future owners of the country. If things collapse suddenly, there may well be genocides.
“How can they hate us?” is not the best question for any minority group to ask right now. A better one is, “Why do they hate us?” And it’s not because we’re all so wonderful. A tiny number of Jewish leftists have worked to diminish traditional ties to race, religion and nation to try to make the world safer for Jews by denying that Jews constitute an alien tribe. These Jews who are largely cut off from the restrictions of Orthodox Judaism (though often still maintaining a strong Jewish identity) have tried to make the world similarly unmoored through things like multiculturalism, Boasian anthropology, Freudianism, MTV, Hollywood, etc. This may create a whirlwind for all Jews, just like in Weimar Germany, when a tiny number of radical Jews excelled at poking fun of all things traditionally German.
All of the major Jewish organizations support immigration amnesty in the United States while they frequently fight hard for Israel as a Jewish state. These are contradictory stands until you realize that in the minds of some Jewish leaders, weakened goyisha identity is good for the Jews. It makes America more “user-friendly” for Jews in the words of Abraham Foxman of the ADL.
If you want to stop future holocausts, you should worry about the American currency, because if that crashes (due to the welfare state bloat and insane costs for needless overseas wars), Jews and other minority groups are in trouble.
The hardest thing for minorities to accept is that no people is entirely innocent, including Jews, and that the actions of a tiny number of their group have fueled the whirlwind. Among Orthodox Jews, Agudah Yisrael signed on to expanding the definition of hate crimes. The OU supports immigration amnesty. All significant American Jewish organizations support immigration amnesty, an idea that will diminish the United States. How can I stay silent? How can Jews stay silent when all of our major organizations are hurting our country by pushing the multicultural agenda?
Adolf Hitler said in 1941: “I’m convinced that there are Jews in Germany who’ve behaved correctly — in the sense that they’ve invariably refrained from doing injury to the German idea. It’s a difficult to estimate how many there are, but what I also know is that none of them has entered into conflict with his co-racialists in order to defend the German idea against them… Probably many Jews are not aware of the destructive power they represent.” (December 1941, Pg. 494 of Esau’s Tears)
These Jewish organizations all demanded amnesty for undocumented immigrants in the United States, invoking the language of the Torah about our obligation to do kindness to the stranger in our midst. They have largely remained silent, however, in the face of Israel’s rounding up and forcible deportation of African asylum seekers. They should all be held to account for their hypocrisy – especially because the Torah was referring to how we treat non-Jews in Israel, not the United States.
American Forum of Russian Jewry (AFRJ)
American Jewish Committee
Bend the Arc: A Jewish Partnership for Justice
B’nai B’rith International
Bukharian Jewish Congress of the USA and Canada
HIAS (Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society)
Jewish Council on Public Affairs
Jewish Federations of North America
National Council of Jewish Women
Reconstructionist Rabbinical College
Tikkun Olam Commission of the Jewish Reconstructionist Movement
T’ruah: The Rabbinic Call for Human Rights
Union for Reform Judaism
Women of Reform Judaism
AJC Los Angeles
AJC New York
AJC Philadelphia/Southern New Jersey
Anti‐Defamation League of Eastern PA and Southern NJ
Congregation Meor Hachaim of Luna Park (New York, NY)
FEGS Health & Human Services (New York, NY)
Greater Philadelphia Jewish Coalition on Immigration
HIAS Pennsylvania (Philadelphia, PA)
Indianapolis Jewish Community Relations Council
Jewish Alliance for Law and Social Action (Boston, MA)
Jewish Community Action (St. Paul, MN)
Jewish Community Center at Starrett City (New York, NY)
Jewish Community Relations Council of Philadelphia
Jewish Council on Urban Affairs (Chicago, IL)
Jewish Family & Career Services (Atlanta, GA)
Jewish Family & Children’s Service (Pittsburgh, PA)
Jewish Family & Children’s Services of the East Bay (Berkeley, CA)
Jewish Family Service of Buffalo & Erie County New York
Jewish Family Service of Western Massachusetts, Inc.
Jewish Family Services (Ann Arbor, MI)
Jewish Labor Committee Western Region (Los Angeles, CA)
Jewish Social Policy Action Network (Philadelphia, PA)
Jewish Vocational Service of MetroWest (East Orange, NJ)
Jews for Racial & Economic Justice (New York, NY)
Massachusetts Board of Rabbis (Newton, MA)
National Council of Jewish Women ‐ Greater Philadelphia
National Council of Jewish Women Texas State Policy Advocates
UJA‐Federation of New York
Women of Vision (Philadelphia, PA)