Category Archives: Marc B. Shapiro

When the Tacit Cannot Stay Tacit: Turner, Shapiro, and the Crisis of Mosaic Authorship

Maimonides’ Principle 8 is an essentialist articulation imposed on a tradition whose operations were tacit. Stephen Turner’s framework, which attacks essentialism in social theory and treats tacit knowledge claims with skepticism, lets us see the move Maimonides made and the … Continue reading

Posted in Bible, Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on When the Tacit Cannot Stay Tacit: Turner, Shapiro, and the Crisis of Mosaic Authorship

The Boundary at Sinai: Principle 8 as Coalition Technology

Principle eight is the live wire of Orthodox theology today, and Shapiro’s chapter on it is the most explosive in his 2011 book, The Limits of Orthodox Theology: Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles Reappraised. The Principle holds three claims at once. The … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Bible, Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on The Boundary at Sinai: Principle 8 as Coalition Technology

Reappraised: The Limits of Orthodox Theology: Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles Reappraised (2011)

Marc Shapiro’s The Limits of Orthodox Theology is a book about a coalition document that does not know it is a coalition document. Shapiro’s argument runs at the level of doctrine and historical scholarship. The thirteen propositions Maimonides put forward … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on Reappraised: The Limits of Orthodox Theology: Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles Reappraised (2011)

The Limits of Orthodox Theology: Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles Reappraised (2011)

The book demands a Stephen Turner tacit knowledge frame. Here’s why, with the others slotting in underneath. Marc Shapiro’s argument structure runs like this. Maimonides articulates thirteen propositions as the explicit content of Jewish belief. The subsequent tradition accepts the … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, Orthodoxy | Comments Off on The Limits of Orthodox Theology: Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles Reappraised (2011)

‘Saul Lieberman and his Ketubah’

Marc B. Shapiro writes: Lieberman begins by saying that he had not written to R. Herzog—who was a very close friend[3]—because he did not want to create difficulties for R. Herzog by bringing him into the controversy swirling around his … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, R. Saul Lieberman | Comments Off on ‘Saul Lieberman and his Ketubah’

‘Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch on Jews in a Non-Jewish World’

This is a small but useful document for understanding the world Rabbi Jehiel Yaakov Weinberg entered when he moved to Berlin and took over the Hildesheimer Seminary. Hirsch is the founder of the tradition Weinberg eventually defends, and the essay … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, R. Samson Raphael Hirsch | Comments Off on ‘Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch on Jews in a Non-Jewish World’

Remnants of the Fire: The Intellectual Life of Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg

Here is Marc Shapiro’s 1995 PhD thesis at Harvard on Rabbi Weinberg. Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg is born in 1884 in Ciechanowiec, a small town then under Russian rule. He shows talent early. By his teens he studies at the great … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, R. J. J. Weinberg | Comments Off on Remnants of the Fire: The Intellectual Life of Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg

Between Zakhor and the Editor’s Desk: What Yerushalmi and Shapiro Reveal About David N. Myers

In 1980, Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi (1932–2009), a professor of Jewish history at Columbia University, gave four lectures at the University of Washington in Seattle that became the 1982 book, Zakhor: Jewish History and Jewish Memory. The work rests on a … Continue reading

Posted in David N. Myers, Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on Between Zakhor and the Editor’s Desk: What Yerushalmi and Shapiro Reveal About David N. Myers

What Then Shall We Do: The Work Shapiro Left

Marc B. Shapiro has shown, with names, editions, footnotes, and before-and-after texts, that Orthodoxy actively manages its own past in order to present itself as unchanging. The Limits of Orthodox Theology (2004) demonstrated that Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles were never the … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on What Then Shall We Do: The Work Shapiro Left

The Archivist’s Paradox: Marc B. Shapiro and the Layers of Managed Disclosure

The previous essays in this series examined Marc B. Shapiro from three angles. The first described what he does: destabilizing the myth of Orthodox uniformity while preventing any clean new myth from forming. The second placed him inside the “quality … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on The Archivist’s Paradox: Marc B. Shapiro and the Layers of Managed Disclosure