Category Archives: Allan V. Horwitz

What Then Shall We Do: The Work Horwitz Left

Allan V. Horwitz has done something rare in the sociology of medicine. He identified a structural problem with precision, named its institutional causes without exaggeration, and refused the convenient resolutions available on both sides of the debate. His central claim … Continue reading

Posted in Allan V. Horwitz | Comments Off on What Then Shall We Do: The Work Horwitz Left

The Gatekeeper: Jerome Wakefield and the Boundaries of Mental Disorder

Jerome C. Wakefield, born in 1946, spent his career asking a question that psychiatry preferred not to confront: what do we mean when we call something a mental disorder? His answer, the harmful dysfunction analysis (HDA), looks at first like … Continue reading

Posted in Allan V. Horwitz, Medicine | Comments Off on The Gatekeeper: Jerome Wakefield and the Boundaries of Mental Disorder

Normal Suffering: The Life and Work of Allan V. Horwitz

Allan Victor Horwitz, born August 22, 1948, in Minneapolis, Minnesota, spent more than five decades at Rutgers University asking a question that sounds simple but turns out to be hard: where does ordinary suffering end and mental illness begin? Horwitz … Continue reading

Posted in Allan V. Horwitz, Medicine | Comments Off on Normal Suffering: The Life and Work of Allan V. Horwitz

Serotonin and the Sovereign

Allan V. Horwitz’s (b. 1948) argument, developed in Creating Mental Illness and later in All We Have to Fear with Jerome Wakefield, is that American psychiatry systematically misclassifies normal emotional responses to difficult circumstances as pathological conditions requiring treatment. Grief … Continue reading

Posted in Allan V. Horwitz, Carl Schmitt | Comments Off on Serotonin and the Sovereign