Category Archives: Philosophy

The Examined Soul: Christian Philosophical Custodianship and Its Aftermath in American Universities

We need a book documenting America’s gains and losses when Christians surrendered custodianship of Philosophy departments. Chapter One: Christian Philosophy as a Custodial Formation. This chapter establishes the book’s central analytical framework by specifying what distinguished Christian philosophical custodianship from … Continue reading

Posted in Christianity, Philosophy | Comments Off on The Examined Soul: Christian Philosophical Custodianship and Its Aftermath in American Universities

The Jurisdictional Wars: Alliance Theory and the Battle for Philosophical Authority

Philosophers in the academy do not compete for authority by saying they want power. They compete by invoking moral and intellectual languages that frame their claims as fidelity to rigorous inquiry, loyalty to truth-seeking, or responsibility for sustaining philosophical seriousness … Continue reading

Posted in Philosophy | Comments Off on The Jurisdictional Wars: Alliance Theory and the Battle for Philosophical Authority

‘Academic Ethics In A Preposterous Environment’

The late philosopher Susan Haack often discussed the cliquishness of the philosophy profession, particularly regarding her time at Oxford. Her essay “Out of Step: Academic Ethics in a Preposterous Environment” was later included in her book Putting Philosophy to Work: … Continue reading

Posted in Philosophy | Comments Off on ‘Academic Ethics In A Preposterous Environment’

Philosopher Of Virtue Mark Alfano Posts To Nathan Cofnas: ‘You’re about to learn why people generally avoid fucking with me.’

Mark Alfano’s tweet to Nathan Cofnas on January 20, 2020 reads, at first glance, like raw aggression. “You’re about to learn why people generally avoid fucking with me.” Most people encountering that line assume it reflects personal animosity or academic … Continue reading

Posted in Nathan Cofnas, Philosophy | Comments Off on Philosopher Of Virtue Mark Alfano Posts To Nathan Cofnas: ‘You’re about to learn why people generally avoid fucking with me.’

Decoding Philosopher Charles Taylor

ChatGPT says: Charles Taylor is best decoded, through Alliance Theory, as a coalition repair theorist whose central project is to make modern moral order livable for people who still need thick belonging. Start with Pinsof’s premise. Moral frameworks exist to … Continue reading

Posted in Philosophy | Comments Off on Decoding Philosopher Charles Taylor

Decoding Martin Heidegger

ChatGPT says: Martin Heidegger can be decoded, through Alliance Theory, as the philosopher who tried to rescue pre moral belonging from a world increasingly organized around abstract, universalist alliance rules. Start with Pinsof’s premise. Moral language coordinates alliances. It tells … Continue reading

Posted in Philosophy | Comments Off on Decoding Martin Heidegger

Rethinking Jewish Philosophy: Beyond Particularism and Universalism by Aaron W. Hughes (2014)

Aaron W. Hughes’s book, Rethinking Jewish Philosophy: Beyond Particularism and Universalism, presents a critique of Jewish philosophy that aligns closely with David Pinsof’s Alliance Theory. Hughes argues that “Jewish philosophy” is not a neutral quest for truth but a form … Continue reading

Posted in Judaism, Philosophy | Comments Off on Rethinking Jewish Philosophy: Beyond Particularism and Universalism by Aaron W. Hughes (2014)

Decoding Existentialism

ChatGPT says: Existentialism flourished when elites needed moral seriousness without authority, and faded once that function was no longer scarce. Here’s the decoding. First. Existentialism solved a post-authority crisis Mid-20th century Europe had experienced: collapsed states discredited churches failed ideologies … Continue reading

Posted in Philosophy | Comments Off on Decoding Existentialism

‘Understanding right-wing populism—and its critics—through a novel theory in political psychology’

Philosopher Dan Williams writes: right-wing populist ideology functions to demonise its alliance’s chief rivals. First, it’s partly defined by its opposition to corrupt, failing, conspiring, and disgraceful “elites” and the “establishment”. However, these malevolent elites are not defined by their … Continue reading

Posted in Philosophy, Politics | Comments Off on ‘Understanding right-wing populism—and its critics—through a novel theory in political psychology’

I Don’t Like Contempt Before Investigation

I’m not immune from this tendency. ChatGPT says: Here are common examples of contempt before investigation: AI is just hype – Dismissing AI as a passing fad or gimmick without learning how it’s already reshaping industries, relationships, and cognition itself. … Continue reading

Posted in Philosophy | Comments Off on I Don’t Like Contempt Before Investigation