Category Archives: Commentary Mag

Eager to Fight: The Hero System of John Podhoretz

In the weeks after his father dies, John Podhoretz (b. 1961) sits at a keyboard and defends the graves. Norman Podhoretz (1930-2025) goes in December. Within the month a fight breaks out over what the old man stood for. Kevin … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary Mag | Comments Off on Eager to Fight: The Hero System of John Podhoretz

The Hero System of Norman Podhoretz

A milk truck moves through Brownsville before light. The horse knows the route, and Julius Podhoretz lets it lead. Above the streets the boy sleeps in rooms the family treats as a way station, not a verdict. The neighborhood is … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary Mag | Comments Off on The Hero System of Norman Podhoretz

The Commentary Magazine Trajectory

ChatGPT says: Alliance Theory would explain Commentary’s trajectory as a sequence of alliance realignments driven by threat perception, patronage, and audience substitution rather than by ideology alone. Commentary began as a coalition project. It was founded to give Jewish intellectuals … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary Mag | Comments Off on The Commentary Magazine Trajectory

Norman Podhoretz Vs The New York Intellectuals Of Partisan Review (12-30-20)

Posted in Commentary Mag | Comments Off on Norman Podhoretz Vs The New York Intellectuals Of Partisan Review (12-30-20)

Do We Want The Likes Of Norman Podhoretz Running Our Culture?

Jews tend to put more value on success than other groups do. It’s not enough in much of Jewish life to just do your best. You have to succeed to be a real Jew. This pressure leads some people to … Continue reading

Posted in America, Art, Commentary Mag, Jews | Comments Off on Do We Want The Likes Of Norman Podhoretz Running Our Culture?

Whatever Happened To Commentary Magazine?

Comment: Commentary…at this point is just forum for justifying whatever the government of Israel is doing today, plus endless and thinly veiled ethnic cheerleading. I mean, the relatively small readership of Commentary (33 K per month) is almost certainly comprised … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary Mag | Comments Off on Whatever Happened To Commentary Magazine?

Israel Is In Danger

Dennis Prager writes in Commentary Magazine: Here are five points that may help to explain current American-Israeli tensions and American Jewish attitudes toward Israel. 1. To understand President Obama, one must understand that he is the first leftist

Posted in Commentary Mag, Dennis Prager | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Israel Is In Danger

New Commentary Editor Denies Neo-Nepotism

From the New York Times: Mr. Podhoretz, 46, who is currently vacationing with his family, said that his father found out about the job offer just two weeks ago, only after he had already accepted the post. “I didn’t want … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary Mag | Comments Off on New Commentary Editor Denies Neo-Nepotism

Bowling With Others

James Q. Wilson writes for Commentary: In his celebrated book, Bowling Alone (2000), the political scientist Robert D. Putnam argued that America, and perhaps the Western world as a whole, has become increasingly disconnected from family, friends, and neighbors. …In … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary Mag | Comments Off on Bowling With Others

John Podhoretz Named New Editor Of Commentary Magazine

Current editor Neal Kozodoy writes: We are delighted to announce that John Podhoretz has been named to succeed Neal Kozodoy in the position of COMMENTARY’s Editor as of January 1, 2009. Mr. Podhoretz will join the COMMENTARY staff this November. … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary Mag | Comments Off on John Podhoretz Named New Editor Of Commentary Magazine