Category Archives: Rabbis

May God save the children of Israel from their leaders

When NYPD Chief William Bratton leaves, and his policies are rolled back, and the crime and chaos begins like before, remember tonight, rabosai. Just like the chasidim, the neo-chasidim pay no heed to rational thinking or reality. Like the regular … Continue reading

Posted in Jews, New York, Police, Rabbis | Comments Off on May God save the children of Israel from their leaders

Rabbi Shmuel Kamenestky Opposes Vaccination

Marc B. Shapiro writes: There has recently been a lot of discussion about R. Shmuel Kamenetsky’s statements against vaccination, even against the polio vaccine(which he sees as a money-making scam). Understandably, there have been many negative comments about R. Kamenetsky, … Continue reading

Posted in R. Shmuel Kamenetsky, Rabbis | Comments Off on Rabbi Shmuel Kamenestky Opposes Vaccination

Los Angeles Has Its Own Barry Freundel

The Modern Orthodox rabbi arrested in Washington DC yesterday on charges of voyeurism has a long history of accusations reported to rabbinic organizations about his improper behavior with women, similar to Rabbi Abner Weiss in Westwood. Rabbi Weiss is still … Continue reading

Posted in Abuse, Conversion, Rabbis, RCA, RCC | Comments Off on Los Angeles Has Its Own Barry Freundel

How Many Orthodox Pulpit Rabbis On The West Coast Earn More Than $500K A Year?

I am sure Rabbi Elazar Muskin at YICC and Rabbi Kalman Topp at Beth Jacob earn (or could earn) over $500,000 a year (counting all benefits and tax advantages and paid tuition for their children, unless the rabbis decline this … Continue reading

Posted in Rabbis | Comments Off on How Many Orthodox Pulpit Rabbis On The West Coast Earn More Than $500K A Year?

Professor Marc Shapiro – Have the Rabbis Always Been Honest With Their Readers?

To what extent have modern rabbis rewritten the Jewish past eliminating what does not fit in with their contemporary religious self-interpretations and world view? This wide-ranging and original review of how this policy is applied in practice adds a new … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, Orthodoxy, Rabbis | Comments Off on Professor Marc Shapiro – Have the Rabbis Always Been Honest With Their Readers?

The Path Of The Righteous

From historian Marc B. Shapiro’s new blog post: “Maimonides famously spoke of the sense of touch as being a “disgrace to us.” The Gaon actually had the same opinion in that he regarded sex as something to be loathed and … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro, Orthodoxy, R. Chofetz Chaim, Rabbis, Vilna Gaon | Comments Off on The Path Of The Righteous

God, Orthodox Judaism, And The Rabbis

John Updike wrote in his novel SEEK MY FACE: “Or perhaps, if she is Jewish, she is unable to put the question of God quite the way a Christian would put it, in urgent terms of either/or. For the chosen … Continue reading

Posted in Adventist, Christianity, Jews, John Updike, Judaism, Personal, Rabbis | Comments Off on God, Orthodox Judaism, And The Rabbis

How Much Confidentiality Should You Expect When You Consult With A Rabbi?

What expectation of confidentiality should you expect when you consult with a rabbi? For instance, with the priest in the confessional, you expect 100% confidentiality. But I heard the other night that there should be no expectation of confidentiality when … Continue reading

Posted in R. Michael J. Broyde, Rabbis | Comments Off on How Much Confidentiality Should You Expect When You Consult With A Rabbi?

When Did You Last Hear A Rabbi Berate His Congregation?

I’ve never heard a rabbi berate his congregation. I know it happened in the past but it is rare these days. Marc Shapiro replies to my question: “[It is] not very common today, but in traditional societies it certainly happened. … Continue reading

Posted in Christianity, Marc B. Shapiro, Rabbis | Comments Off on When Did You Last Hear A Rabbi Berate His Congregation?

What Significance Did R. David Hartman Have To Judaism?

Now that Rabbi Hartman is dead, his constituency, the news media, is publishing flattering obituaries. I’m wondering what was R. Hartman’s significance aside from headlines? He was undoubtedly a scholar, but to me he was an abstruse thinker like R. … Continue reading

Posted in Rabbis | Comments Off on What Significance Did R. David Hartman Have To Judaism?