Second thoughts on this petition to take down Syria’s regime?

I email Professor Jonathan Sarna about this petition he signed in 2013 along with Leon Wieseltier, Joseph Telushkin, Shmuly Yanklowitz, Avi Weiss, Yosef Blau, David Wolpe, Eric Yoffie, Menachem Genack, Steven Weil, Haskel Lookstein, Mark Dratch, Jeffrey K. Salkin to push America to overthrow Bashar al-Assad in Syria:

I wonder if you have any second thoughts about signing your name to
this petition?

I think it is fair to say that the destabilization of the Assad regime
in Syria has been the “most globally destabilizing event since 9/11.”
(@thelateempire)

Perhaps organized Jewry’s push to knock off the Assad regime was not
such a great idea.

He replies:

No second thoughts. Had Pres. Obama knocked off the great mass murderer Assad, as he should have done, and had he set up a no-fly zone in Syria for refugees, as he should have done, thousands of people would today be alive and the European refugee crisis would not exist.

Posted in Jonathan D. Sarna, Leon Wieseltier, R. Avi Weiss, R. David Wolpe, R. Mark Dratch, R. Steven Weil, Syria | Comments Off on Second thoughts on this petition to take down Syria’s regime?

WSJ: Indiana Gov. Mike Pence, Donald J. Trump’s running mate, gained renown as a social and fiscal conservative whose policy positions have at times drawn him into national debates.

Dennis Prager shared this WSJ article on his Facebook wall, drawing the following comments:

* Janet Twaddle Carpenter Pence is the ONLY positive thing about Trump. Wish pence would muzzle Trump and tie his hands, lock him in an empty room, then take over the leadership.

* Barney Hadden Dennis, if he were at the top of the ticket, and Trump were sealed in a steamer trunk and dumped in the East River, Pense would have my vote in a heartbeat.

* Andrew Mihelich Conservative bona fides like caving to LGBT pressure on religious freedom. Pass.

Posted in Conservatives | Comments Off on WSJ: Indiana Gov. Mike Pence, Donald J. Trump’s running mate, gained renown as a social and fiscal conservative whose policy positions have at times drawn him into national debates.

Which American Intellectuals Pushed For Overthrow Of Assad In Syria?

As the Twitter user #thelatempire notes: “Syria war has been the most globally destabilizing event since 9/11.”

So who pushed for this disaster? People like the neoconservative Charles Krauthammer.

8/29/13 Washington Post:

Having leaked to the world, and thus to Syrian President Bashar al-Assad, a detailed briefing of the coming U.S. air attack on Syria — (1) the source (offshore warships and perhaps a bomber or two), (2) the weapon (cruise missiles), (3) the duration (two or three days), (4) the purpose (punishment, not “regime change”) — perhaps we should be publishing the exact time the bombs will fall, lest we disrupt dinner in Damascus.

So much for the element of surprise. Into his third year of dithering, two years after declaring Assad had to go, one year after drawing — then erasing — his own red line on chemical weapons, Barack Obama has been stirred to action.

Or more accurately, shamed into action. Which is the worst possible reason. A president doesn’t commit soldiers to a war for which he has zero enthusiasm. Nor does one go to war for demonstration purposes.

Want to send a message? Call Western Union. A Tomahawk missile is for killing. A serious instrument of war demands a serious purpose.

The purpose can be either punitive or strategic: either a spasm of conscience that will inflame our opponents yet leave not a trace, or a considered application of abundant American power to alter the strategic equation that is now heavily favoring our worst enemies in the heart of the Middle East…

Of Assad’s 20 air bases, notes retired Gen. Jack Keane, six are primary. Attack them: the runways, the fighters, the helicopters, the fuel depots, the nearby command structures. Render them inoperable.

We don’t need to take down Syria’s air defense system, as we did in Libya. To disable air power, we can use standoff systems — cruise missiles fired from ships offshore and from aircraft loaded with long-range, smart munitions that need not overfly Syrian territory.

Depriving Assad of his total control of the air and making resupply from Iran and Russia far more difficult would alter the course of the war. That is a serious purpose.

Would the American people support it? They are justifiably war-weary and want no part of this conflict.

Posted in America, Syria | Comments Off on Which American Intellectuals Pushed For Overthrow Of Assad In Syria?

Who Were The Rabbis & Jewish Intellectuals Who Pushed For America To Declare War On Syria?

As the Twitter user #thelatempire notes: “Syria war has been the most globally destabilizing event since 9/11.”

So who pushed for this disaster?

From September 2013:

Letter to U.S. House of Representatives

Dear Congressional Leaders,

We write you as descendants of Holocaust survivors and refugees, whose ancestors were gassed to death in concentration camps. We write you as a people who have faced persecution for many centuries, and are glad to have found a safe refuge where we can thrive in the United States. We write as a people proud of our religious and historical tradition of helping the needy and defending the weak.

The recent chemical weapons attacks on the Damascus suburbs constitute a serious crime against humanity. These attacks killed upwards of 1400 people, the majority of them innocent women and children. As a people who themselves once faced the horrors of genocide and survived, we had hoped that we would never again open our newspapers to images of mass graves filled with suffocated young children. Now that we have seen such images coming from Syria, we call upon you to act.

Intelligence assessments from the U.S., U.K. France, Israel, Turkey, the Arab League, and many other allies all show conclusively that the Assad regime was responsible for the horrific chemical attacks of August 21st. We fear that if this attack passes without a decisive response, we might open our newspapers to more images of mass graves from Syria – and elsewhere — in the near future. We have learned from our own history that inaction and silence are the greatest enablers of human atrocity.

For this reason, we call upon you with great urgency to authorize the President to use force in Syria “in connection with the use of chemical weapons or other weapons of mass destruction,” as outlined in his August 31st draft legislation. Through this act, Congress has the capacity to save thousands of lives.

These are the Days of Awe for the Jewish people. In one of the climactic moments of our High Holiday prayers, we read “On Rosh Hashanah it is written, and on Yom Kippur it is sealed, who will pass and who will be created, who will live and who will die, who in his time and who before his time.” May this coming year be one of life and creation the world over, in which we cease to witness the deaths of so many innocent human beings.

Sincerely,

Rabbi Dr. Shmuly Yanklowitz, Founder & President, Uri L’Tzedek

Leon Wieseltier

Rabbi Avi Weiss, President-Emeritus, YCT Rabbinical School (Yeshivat Chovevei Torah)

Rabbi Yosef Blau, Rosh Yeshiva, Yeshiva University

Professor Jonathan Sarna, Joseph H. & Belle R. Braun Professor of American Jewish History, Brandeis University

Rabbi David Wolpe, Senior Rabbi, Sinai Temple

Rabbi Eric Yoffie, President- Emeritus of the Union for Reform Judaism

Rabbi Menachem Genack, Orthodox Union

Rabbi Steven Weil, Orthodox Union

Rabbi Haskel Lookstein, Senior Rabbi, Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun (KJ)

Rabbi Richard A. Block, President, Central Conference of American Rabbis

Shlomo Bolts

Rabbi Mark Dratch, Executive Vice President, RCA (Rabbinical Council of America)

Rabbi Joseph Telushkin

Rabbi Jason Herman, Director, IRF (International Rabbinic Fellowship)

Rabbi Sid Schwarz, Senior Fellow, Clal: The National Jewish Center for Learning and Leadership

Rabbi Jeffrey K. Salkin, writer, Temple Beth Am, Bayonne, NJ

Rabbi Dr. Yehudah Mirsky

Rabbi Barry Dolinger

Rabbi Andy Koren

Rabbi Steve Greenberg, Director, Eshel and Senior Fellow, Clal: The National Jewish Center for Learning and Leadership

Rabbi David Jaffe, The Kirva Institute

A year later:

Sep 17, 2014 — From Petition Creator: One year ago, we pushed for Congress to hold Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad accountable after his vicious chemical attack on his own people. As you know, he was not punished for his crimes but was allowed to continue slaughtering civilians right and left. As a result, it’s been a difficult year for Syria:– Over 150,000 more people have died– 2 freed cities have been forced back into tyranny (1 to Assad, 1 to ISIS)– A new terrorist threat the U.S. officials describe as “like nothing we’ve seen before” has emerged.This all could have been avoided if Congress had heeded our calls a year ago. But at the very least, national security considerations have created the urgency that should have already been there for humanitarian reasons.Today, Congress authorized the President to arm pro-democracy rebels in fighting the powerful terror group Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, which barely existed a year ago.Tell all your friends, tell the skeptics: this is why we don’t ignore genocides.

Posted in Jonathan D. Sarna, Rabbis, Syria | Comments Off on Who Were The Rabbis & Jewish Intellectuals Who Pushed For America To Declare War On Syria?

So Who Were The Men & Institutions Who Pushed For America To Go To War In Syria?

As the Twitter user #thelatempire notes: “Syria war has been the most globally destabilizing event since 9/11.”

So who pushed for this disaster?

9/3/13
Urgent Rosh Hashanah message from Rabbi Marvin Hier, SWC Dean and Founder

Dear SWC Supporter,

As we are about to usher in the High Holidays, the United States Congress will be voting about whether we should respond to the terrible crime against humanity committed by the Assad regime in Syria. Enclosed is a letter (see below) we have just sent to each U.S. Senator and Representative urging them to vote for the President’s proposal of a limited strike against the Assad regime.

I have no doubt that Simon Wiesenthal, who spent his whole life preserving the legacy of the Holocaust would have been the first to speak out against such a crime.

Wishing you and your family a healthy and happy New Year!

Rabbi Marvin Hier
Founder and Dean
Simon Wiesenthal Center

September 3, 2013

It was seventy-one years ago in August 1942, just a few weeks before Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, that Gerhard Riegner, the World Jewish Congress representative in Switzerland informed the US and British governments of the diabolical plan to exterminate Europe’s Jews using gas. Riegner had learned of the plan from a source close to the highest Nazi officials, German industrialist Eduard Schulte. Both governments were skeptical about the information and tragically wasted precious months doing nothing about it. By 1945, six million Jews were murdered; most gassed in Nazi death camps in what became known as the Holocaust, the greatest crime in the annals of human history.

Since then every American President, British Prime Minister and other political leaders around the world have pledged again and again that they will never allow history to repeat itself.

But on August 29, 2013, when the British parliament was presented with incontrovertible evidence that the regime of Syria’s President Bashar Assad used illegal chemical weapons against his own people, murdering 1,400 innocent men, women and children, they again opted to do nothing.
Now, on September 9, it will be up to you to vote, following President Obama’s request for Congressional approval before embarking on a limited strike against the Assad regime.

On behalf of the Simon Wiesenthal Center, we urge you to vote for the limited strike, because to do otherwise would only embolden the perpetrators and encourage them to gas more victims, while at the same time signaling the world that America’s assurances and promises mean nothing at all.
This may not be the perfect solution, but it will send a dramatic signal to the Assad regime and all others, that you will have to pay a very high price if you continue to perpetrate such crimes against humanity.

As you contemplate your vote, we ask you to reflect on the lesson taught in the Ethics of the Fathers, “In a place where there are no men (leaders), strive to be a man (leader).”
We hope you will support taking action against Assad’s crimes against humanity.

Thank you and Happy New Year,

Rabbi Marvin Hier
Founder and Dean
Simon Wiesenthal Center

Rabbi Abraham Cooper
Associate Dean
Simon Wiesenthal Center

Posted in America, R. Abraham Cooper, R. Marvin Hier, Simon Wiesenthal, Syria | Comments Off on So Who Were The Men & Institutions Who Pushed For America To Go To War In Syria?