Marc B. Shapiro writes: I completely reject the Kuzari argument not only for logical reasons but because it can be used to “prove” the historicity of miracles in other religions, miracles that we are told were witnessed by many people…
Most Jews don’t keep Torah. What else will they be able to say? Even people raised religious can have the status of anus or tinok she-nishbah. R. Chaim Brisker said that emunah begins where proof (i.e., evidence) stops. But I don’t think the beit din on high will be asking such questions. The people who didn’t keep the Torah will realize then how much they missed out.
