If we can openly discuss the power and influence of the Christian Right in America (in public education, public space, politics), why can’t we openly discuss the power and influence of the Saudi Lobby and of Jews, Chinese, etc?
Chaim Amalek: “Because we tell you not to, that’s why. We can discuss this in shul tomorrow. There will be lots of time.”
Luke: If Ann Coulter survives and does not back down from her comments about Jews and Israel, does that mean there is a tidal wave of more caustic criticism of Jews is about to flow over America?
Chaim Amalek: “I’m afraid so, which is why she MUST BE RUINED.”
I think that all groups, including Jews, benefit from accurate criticism and appropriate stigma. All groups have strengths and weaknesses and unique gifts and it is not hate to accurately and publicly point that out. For instance, in general and by comparison with other groups, Jews are good at business, good at negotiating, good at academics, good at making money, good at developing group cohesion, good at exercising political and cultural influence, good at telling stories and making entertainment.
