Is Trump threatening Canada because he believes it has been taken over by China?

Grok says:

Whether Donald Trump is threatening Canada specifically because he believes it’s been “taken over by China” is tough to pin down with certainty—it’s more inference than explicit statement. As of March 15, 2025, Trump’s public rhetoric and actions don’t directly say, “Canada’s a Chinese puppet, so I’m coming for it.” Instead, his threats—like tariffs and annexation talk—tie to broader grievances: trade imbalances, border security, and drugs, especially fentanyl. But the China angle floats around, especially among his supporters and in online chatter, and it’s worth decoding.
Trump’s been hammering Canada with 25% tariffs on most imports (10% on energy), effective since early March, citing fentanyl and illegal immigration as justification. He’s also mused about Canada becoming the “51st state,” a line he’s dropped since late 2024, often with a smirk but enough repetition to rattle nerves. On X, some claim he’s dead serious, arguing he sees Canada as a backdoor for Chinese influence—pointing to Trudeau’s past praise of China’s “basic dictatorship” in 2013 or alleged CCP ties in Canadian politics. Posts suggest he’d rather annex Canada than let it drift into Beijing’s orbit. No hard proof he’s said this outright, though.
What’s he actually said? At a March 13 Oval Office meeting with NATO’s Mark Rutte, Trump called the Canadian border “artificial” and doubled down on wanting Greenland and Canada for “international security.” He’s vague—security could mean anything—but China’s a frequent boogeyman in his worldview. During his first term, he slapped tariffs on China over fentanyl precursors, and now he’s hitting Canada too, despite U.S. data showing only 0.2% of 2024’s seized fentanyl came from there. Critics, including Trudeau, call it a pretext; Trudeau’s speculated Trump wants to tank Canada’s economy for an easier takeover.
The China theory gains traction from context. Canada’s got Huawei execs tangled in extradition fights, Chinese investments in its resources, and reports of CCP interference in elections—stuff Trump could spin as a threat. X posts amplify this, claiming he’s countering a “CCP-compromised” Canada. But his public focus stays on trade and drugs, not a grand “China’s running Ottawa” reveal. If he believes it, he’s not shouting it—yet it’s plausible he sees Canada as a weak link in a bigger geopolitical game, especially with China flexing in the Arctic.
So, is it about China? Maybe partly. He’s not on record saying it’s the sole reason, but his pattern—tariffs, security talk, and a history of China hawkishness—suggests it could be a piece of the puzzle. His mania’s still roaring; no sign it’s breaking soon. What do you think—does the China angle feel like the core of it to you, or just one thread in the mess?

About Luke Ford

I've written five books (see Amazon.com). My work has been covered in the New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, and on 60 Minutes. I teach Alexander Technique in Beverly Hills (Alexander90210.com).
This entry was posted in America, Canada. Bookmark the permalink.