Category Archives: Stephen Turner

The Politics of Essence: Vermeule, the IRGC, and the CCP

Stephen Turner’s deepest objection to Adrian Vermeule is not political or theological. It is epistemological. Vermeule’s common-good constitutionalism rests on an essentialist premise: that the classical legal and natural law tradition carries a determinate moral content across time, that this … Continue reading

Posted in Adrian Vermeule, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on The Politics of Essence: Vermeule, the IRGC, and the CCP

Stephen Turner and International Relations: A Strategically External Observer

There is no Turner school of International Relations in any conventional sense, and Turner himself would probably find the idea faintly amusing. His entry into IR was, by his own account in his 2022 memoir Mad Hazard: A Life in … Continue reading

Posted in International Relations, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Stephen Turner and International Relations: A Strategically External Observer

When the Epistemology Collapses: Stephen Park Turner and the Post-Liberal Catholic Project

There is no famous direct encounter between the sociologist Stephen P. Turner and the Harvard law professor Adrian Vermeule. They operate in different institutional worlds and have rarely, if ever, addressed each other by name. Turner works in the philosophy … Continue reading

Posted in Adrian Vermeule, Epistemics, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on When the Epistemology Collapses: Stephen Park Turner and the Post-Liberal Catholic Project

The Jurisdictional Wars: Alliance Theory and the Battle to Define Legitimate Power in the Trump Presidency

Thomas Edsall writes in the New York Times: Trump’s Smash-and-Grab Presidency Reaches New Heights Moynihan agreed that “there are significant strategic motivations for the U.S. military action” against Iran. But for Trump, “the key point seems to be the impulsiveness, … Continue reading

Posted in America, Elites, Expertise, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on The Jurisdictional Wars: Alliance Theory and the Battle to Define Legitimate Power in the Trump Presidency

Decoding Rabbi Isadore Twersky

Per Alliance Theory: Rabbi Isadore Twersky was the architect of the high-level intellectual ceasefire. He rejected the idea that a scholar must choose between the “sacred” world of the yeshiva and the “profane” world of the university. He argued that … Continue reading

Posted in Alliance Theory, Marc B. Shapiro, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Decoding Rabbi Isadore Twersky

Global Warming

Gemini says: Stephen Park Turner explores global warming primarily through the lens of social theory and the politics of expertise rather than as a climate scientist. His work focuses on how the debate over climate change illustrates the challenges of … Continue reading

Posted in Climate, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Global Warming

The Stephen Park Turner Trajectory

ChatGPT says: Alliance Theory would read Stephen Park Turner’s career as that of an institutional outsider who steadily built epistemic authority rather than coalitional power. Here are the core points in plain terms: Turner is, by training and temperament, a … Continue reading

Posted in Stephen Turner | Comments Off on The Stephen Park Turner Trajectory

Challenges To Academic Freedom

Stephen Turner writes in this 2021 book: The present legal system produces an unequal conflict between academic freedom, which has only the most fragile and indirect legal basis, and employment law. The latter is backed by administrative law, which, in … Continue reading

Posted in Academia, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Challenges To Academic Freedom

Our System Often Rewards BS Rather Than Truth

Columbia University statistics professor Andrew Gelman blogs (here is my collection of his related posts): Last year we discussed the problem of scientists who host podcasts in which they credulously and uncritically interview celebrity scientists who are promoting junk science. … Continue reading

Posted in Science, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on Our System Often Rewards BS Rather Than Truth

‘Lies and D.C. Crime Statistics’

Kimberly Strassel writes for the WSJ: No one should be surprised if investigations show evidence of manipulation, as “downgrading” is nothing new in police departments. A New York Times story from more than a decade ago reported on an anonymous … Continue reading

Posted in Expertise, Stephen Turner | Comments Off on ‘Lies and D.C. Crime Statistics’