Monthly Archives: November 2014

Rabbi Shmuel Kamenestky Opposes Vaccination

Marc B. Shapiro writes: There has recently been a lot of discussion about R. Shmuel Kamenetsky’s statements against vaccination, even against the polio vaccine(which he sees as a money-making scam). Understandably, there have been many negative comments about R. Kamenetsky, … Continue reading

Posted in R. Shmuel Kamenetsky, Rabbis | Comments Off on Rabbi Shmuel Kamenestky Opposes Vaccination

Does Torah Endorse The Maiming Of Sinners?

Marc B. Shapiro writes: The Bible, Judges 1:6, already mentions cutting off the thumbs and large toes of the defeated Canaanite king. R. Moses Isserles, Shulhan Arukh, Hoshen Mishpat 388:10, refers to blinding a moser or cutting out his tongue. … Continue reading

Posted in Torah | Comments Off on Does Torah Endorse The Maiming Of Sinners?

How To Deal With Jewish Fornicators

Israel Zinberg, A History of Jewish Literature, vol. 7, p. 164, quotes R. Isaac ben Elyakim’s (17th century) Yiddish book Lev Tov, which indeed does give license to kill transgressors: For the sin of lying with a gentile woman is … Continue reading

Posted in Adultery, Sex | Comments Off on How To Deal With Jewish Fornicators

What’s The Torah’s Position On Intentionally Injecting Somebody With HIV?

Marc B. Shapiro writes: Finally, I want to discuss a recent article by Rabbi Shalom C. Spira and Dr. Mark A. Wainberg that appeared in Hakirah entitled “Criminalization of HIV Transmission.”[30] They begin by quoting R. Zvi Spitz who argues … Continue reading

Posted in AIDS, Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on What’s The Torah’s Position On Intentionally Injecting Somebody With HIV?

Spinoza The Righteous

Marc B. Shapiro writes: R. Hirschensohn discusses Spinoza’s pantheism and states that he was not guilty of two of the big heresies: (1) regarding God as a corporeal being, or (2) avodah zarah. He was simply in error, and that … Continue reading

Posted in Marc B. Shapiro | Comments Off on Spinoza The Righteous