Sure as much as a gentile can move to the Jewish state and become a full and equal citizen. That’s not easy. Israel is a Jewish state, so non-Jews by definition are second-class citizens.
Orthodox Jews love non-Jews trying to join Orthodox shuls as much as the Alt Right enjoys Jews trying to join the Alt Right.
Orthodox Jews have as much suspicion of gentiles trying to join the tribe as WNs have of Jews trying to join them.
When do groups such as Jews identify as white? When incentives align that way.
Torah makes no room for non-Jewish citizenship in a Jewish state. The Torah of White Nationalism makes no room for Jewish citizenship in a white nationalist state.
Japan is 99% racial Japanese. That might be the model for other nationalist states.
Conversion to Orthodox Judaism rarely works out for either party. People behave more like their genes than their beliefs.
Chaim Amalek writes: “And yet without Jewish guidance, the alt-right is doomed. Just as the USSR would have been doomed without a Leon Trotsky (nee Lev Bronstein) to create it. GOYIM! Amalek the Father sends you his only begotten Son Luke/Levy to guide you in these matters! We understand the inner workings of Hollywood, Wall Street, the Federal Reserve, the News Media, Washington, and Facebook in a way that a mere goy never can. Really, the issue of a gentile belonging to an orthodox/hassidic or litvish synagogue can never arise. It would be like a Somali trying to pass himself off as Japanese.”
Comments at Amren.com:
* I’m Jewish and have read the Forward for years. I applaud the Forward — which is very pro-multiculturalism and anti-Western — for being willing to publish this. The OW is shifting, and even the secular Jewish Marxists can feel it.
But it seems to me that while the author is well-meaning and has his head screwed on straight, he dances around the real crux of what it means to be alt-right. It means that you are concerned with the demographic preservation of the European race, and that you believe that Western civilization and its riches belong to the people of Europe. That’s what distinguishes the alt-right from the alt-light. Alt-righters don’t want people of color to assimilate. We want them to stay and succeed in their own countries. Alt-light sites like Breitbart are A-OK with brown people migrating here as long as they “learn our culture” (whatever that means).
* I want to add that Breitbart does incredibly valuable work — it ranks in the mid-200s on Alexa, and reaches tens of millions of people each month. It’s the gateway drug to race realism and the alt-right. Many people won’t be able to swallow race realism described in genetic and biological terms, but can handle attacks on Black Lives Matter, SJW-culture and illegal immigration.
Once you get used to implicitly pro-white thinking like Breitbart, it will be much easier to swallow the explicitly pro-white thinking of Jared Taylor and Richard Spencer.
* I want to add that Breitbart does incredibly valuable work — it ranks in the mid-200s on Alexa, and reaches tens of millions of people each month. It’s the gateway drug to race realism and the alt-right. Many people won’t be able to swallow race realism described in genetic and biological terms, but can handle attacks on Black Lives Matter, SJW-culture and illegal immigration.
Once you get used to implicitly pro-white thinking like Breitbart, it will be much easier to swallow the explicitly pro-white thinking of Jared Taylor and Richard Spencer.
* The neo-Nazi pro-Hitler corners of the alt-right do a tremendous disservice to the movement and are likely to prevent it from ever going mainstream. For better or worse, the public has a favorable impression of Jews and the Holocaust still has a lot of currency. The movement needs a more nuanced position on where Jews stand in Western society.
You have websites like the Daily Stormer that cheered the death of the great Gene Wilder for no reason other than that he was Jewish. If you think this will ever win over the majority of America’s 200 million whites, dream on. Even 200 years ago, Europeans were not that unthinkingly anti-Semitic.
What’s more, I’m an Orthodox Jew, and Orthodox Jews are mostly not liberal at all. We’re backing Trump by a 3-to-1 margin. As for the “backlash,” Jews aren’t even surviving in these tolerant pluralistic soulless Western countries. Israel could benefit tremendously from the immigration of several million white European Jews — so a bit of anti-Semitism could lead a lot of Jews to move there and help strengthen the state. The window for such immigration is closing fast, since more than half of Diaspora Jews are intermarried, and within two generations they will be absorbed by the general European-American population. I think a little bit of anti-Semitism is necessary for Jews to survive outside of a Jewish country (Israel). What kept Jews together throughout centuries of exile was the brutal reality that we weren’t accepted and had no choice but to stick together.
* For a genuinely compassionate person, there’s always moral principle. Whites are in danger; for some non-white people, that is (for the moment) enough of a reason if their own people aren’t gravely endangered in the process of supporting us.
Jews might be endangered; on the other hand, has any group of people on the planet done more for Jews than whites?
* This guy likes the Alt-right for one reason: He thinks it will eventually benefit Israel, more than the Left does.
The Alt-right exists for one reason: To benefit Europeans.
We don’t need people like Dingleberry and Minsky (who are probably the same person) to twist the flow of support for European people into support for Israel.
We don’t need them to thump their chests over a contrived testing of supposed Ashkenazi intelligence, the legitimacy of the occupation of Palestine, the support of Israel by gullible evangelicals.
The Alt-right is for Europeans. Get your derrieres out, you swindlers.
* Well… partly to cut the author some slack and partly to play Devil’s Advocate… he was writing for Forward. Most of what he wrote aligns fairly well with what ethnic/racial nationalists think, so maybe the usual obsession with Israel was an attempt to coax some of the Jewish readers into softening their views on the Alt-Right – in much the same dynamic by which conventional “conservatism” has peeled many Jews from the Left.
* To the fence sitters, “Alt-Right” comes across as more friendly than “White Nationalist”. It sounds edgy, cool and new. We are mad that non-whites get to use identity politics while whites can’t; that the conservative establishment stabs its voting base in the back at every opportunity and hasn’t conserved anything; that Jewish intellectuals, media figures, lobbyist and financiers played a disproportionate role in many of our national problems. We are mad that they opened our borders and promote multiculturalism while that state of Israel shuts its borders. Even among the more conservative Jews in the American sense who oppose liberal lunacy, they are pro-Zionist and want to spend American blood and treasure defending the Jewish state. Just as Jews during the post WW2 period moved away from the left and co-opted the right (Neoconservatives); Jews know the Alt-Right is going mainstream and will try to make as Jew-friendly as possible. Whites are fighting a two front war: a street-level one against black/brown criminality and dysfunction, and an ideological one. Jewish intellectuals are at the forefront of anti-white ideologies and have much more political influence at the national level than Rev. Al or some other street hustling buffoon.
* Fascinating how they want to join all of our movements. Why not work for the Truth in the many Jewish organizations and then report back to us from time to time? That would be a real contribution. Instead it’s almost as if they want to take over the Alt-Right, much as they did before to Conservatism in decades gone by.
* Europe is sacred to us. Sacred. If we can secure America, Whites will go and fight the Muslim hordes there with their brothers. Now how many Jews will go? Zero. How many would go fight for a threatened Israel? Many. I think you see my point. Super American David Brook’s son is in the military – the Israeli military. Israel is the Brook’s family real country. That’s the proof you see. Now isn’t that the same for you as well?
Jews have thousands of interlocking local, state, national, and international organizations that work on their behalf. How many organizations are you comfortable with Whites having that do the same for them? Zero. You simply refuse to grant us our own existence – and that makes you an enemy. If you were sincere, you would full acknowledge the validity of our mistrust. And if you still wanted to help us for some idealistic reason, you would focus on changing the Jewish mindset by advocacy of one kind or another.
* Iran has not hurt the American people – although it may stand in the way of Jewish interests. Thus Israel and America have different interests. No more wars for Israel. If you want to take on Iran, go for it. Take out their nuclear power plants – if you can. The counter-attack will be terrible. You’d much rather America do this and take the brunt of the counter-attack.
After 9/11, people in Israel reported the feeling of smug satisfaction that suffused the country. Now those stupid Americans know what it’s like and will help us. Your Leaders themselves have said the Jews are a Nation without borders. They’re too discrete to say that anymore, but the attitude remains the same. Without strong counter evidence, I simply assume you hold the same viewpoint – just like David Brooks and his son.
Jews are pro-American only insofar as America serves their interests and the interests of Israel. They would turn on a dime once those interests are no longer being catered to or a better offer comes along as per WW1 Germany and the Balfour agreement.
Also, Russia and Iran are allied and we don’t want to anger Russia. Not only do we not want a WW3, but we want to be allies with this Great Nation and its Heroic Leader, Vladimir Putin. Trump and Putin are the God Brothers, Castor and Pollux reborn. They will usher in the Northern Alliance that Lindbergh called for before you slandered him in your “news” papers and what Yockey called “the Imperium” before he was found suicided in your prison.
