If David Suissa is right and Marvin Hier is at heart a yeshiva boy, then I am more skeptical of yeshivas. <\/p>\n
I don’t believe David Suissa is right and therefore I don’t regard yeshivas as the enemy of Western civilization. Nobody else regards Marvin Hier as the embodiment of the yeshiva. Everyone I know in 90035 regards him as the Jewish Jesse Jackson.<\/p>\n
David Suissa writes in the Jewish Journal of Los Angeles<\/a>:<\/p>\n \nThe longer I live in America, the more fascinated I become with the story of American Jewry \u2014 how a wandering and persecuted people discovered a free and open nation and have given so much back. When he moved his family to Los Angeles in the mid-1970s, he had no idea he would ever be involved with the Holocaust or fighting anti-Semitism. His plan was to start a yeshiva for post-high school students of all backgrounds and denominations and contribute, as he says, \u201cto the unbroken chain of Torah study that had sustained Jews over the centuries.\u201d<\/p>\n …A key story in the book is how Hier convinced Wiesenthal, the legendary pursuer of Nazi war criminals, to agree to have his name on the center. Hier recounts a long courtship, punctuated by a hairy car ride through the streets of Vienna. If David Suissa is right and Marvin Hier is at heart a yeshiva boy, then I am more skeptical of yeshivas. I don’t believe David Suissa is right and therefore I don’t regard yeshivas as the enemy of Western civilization. … Continue reading
\nAt the heart of this story are some larger-than-life Jews who have influenced every facet of American life, from Hollywood, Wall Street and Silicon Valley to academia, popular culture, media, social action and politics.
\nOne Jew who surely belongs to this prominent cast is Rabbi Marvin Hier, founder and dean of the Simon Wiesenthal Center and its Museum of Tolerance in Los Angeles. Here is a yeshiva boy from New York\u2019s Lower East Side who grows up to become one of the world\u2019s most influential Jews, thanks to a special brew of smarts, chutzpah, faith and humor…<\/p>\n
\nAt a meeting with the great man, Hier mustered all his chutzpah: \u201cMr. Wiesenthal,\u201d he said, \u201cI recently visited a museum in L.A .where people come from all over America to learn about dinosaurs. In fact, there are a half dozen such places in America. But where can people go to learn about the Nazis? Who will teach them that thirty-two years after the Holocaust, anti-Semitism is still going strong? If we don\u2019t teach young people now, we will once again be caught unprepared, and history will repeat itself.\u201d
\nThe Wiesenthal name helped put Hier\u2019s Holocaust center on the map, just as the YU association did the same for his yeshiva. As they both took off simultaneously, the two tracks of Hier\u2019s life began to take shape: an international leader around Holocaust remembrance and fighting anti-Semitism, and a local leader in Orthodox Jewish education in Los Angeles, first with the yeshiva and then with its successor high school, Yeshiva University of Los Angeles (YULA), which he led until 2005.
\nThese two sides symbolize the two Marvin Hiers: the global storyteller who wants to change the world, and the yeshiva boy who stays loyal to his Jewish roots.
\nThe yeshiva boy dreams of keeping the flame of Torah alive with the Jews of his community; the global storyteller dreams of keeping the memory and lessons of the Holocaust alive with people everywhere.
\nThe yeshiva boy wears a yarmulke on his head; the global storyteller wears a smile on his face.
\nThe smile and the stories help Hier attract prominent people to his projects; the yamulke keeps him grounded in the story of his people and the primacy of Torah observance.
\nHier is not just one of these. He\u2019s both. He\u2019s as comfortable telling stories in Yiddish to a group of yeshiva students as he is receiving an Academy Award for one of the documentaries produced by his film company, Moriah Films.
\nBut if I had to venture a guess as to which side is more dominant, I would pick the yeshiva boy. It is the yeshiva boy who drives the global storyteller in a way that always comes back to help the Jewish people. It is the yeshiva boy that nourishes his faith that, in the end, everything will come out for the good.
\n\u201cAs I look back over the trajectory of my life, from New York\u2019s Lower East Side to Vancouver, Los Angeles and Jerusalem, from yeshiva bocher to rabbi, political activist, film producer and museum founder,\u201d he writes near the end of the book, \u201cI realize that I have always held firm to that deceptively simple idea. I have always believed that no matter how many people try to extinguish the flame of the Jewish people, they will never succeed, because the irrevocable covenant God made with Abraham will always produce unexpected helpers and new circumstances to rekindle it.
\n\u201cI have always believed in miracles, whether the ancient types, staves that turn into snakes, seas that split, manna that falls from trees, or the greater miracles of our own time, the creation of Israel, the incredible victories of the Israeli army and the renaissance of yeshivas and Jewish day schools throughout the world.\u201d
\nHier\u2019s obsession with Jewish education counters the critique that, for all of the universal imperatives of Holocaust remembrance, it\u2019s not an enduring source for creating a Jewish identity. Showing how Jews died and how Jews are hated doesn\u2019t teach Jews how to live. Hier understood that only Jewish education can do that.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"