Upon reading the headline, my immediate response was, “For whom?”<\/p>\n
For some people, Zionism is naturally a bad word because it represents something that is an affront to their people (Arabs and Muslims) or to their value system (leftism).<\/p>\n
If you believe that ethnic and religious ties are of little importance compared to economic class, then you are a leftist and you are likely to be offended by all ethno-nationalisms including Zionism. <\/p>\n
Eitan Arom writes<\/a>: <\/p>\n I\u2019m not immune to my generation\u2019s ambivalence on the matter of Jewish nationalism. In the vocabulary of my education on a liberal campus, the word \u201cnationalist\u201d is likely to follow the word \u201cwhite\u201d or \u201cmilitant\u201d or \u201cultra.\u201d In other words, mine is a Zionism that\u2019s not without reservations.<\/p>\n But to say that I\u2019m post-Zionist would be tantamount to saying that I\u2019m post-Jewish \u2014 which is simple and easy but altogether untrue. The struggle for Jewish nationhood was written into my biography long before I was born.<\/p>\n After all, if it weren\u2019t for the itinerant Zionism that motivated my grandfather Shmuel to drag his wife, the daughter of a cultured and well-to-do German-Jewish family, to hardscrabble Palestine, where they slept in tents and toiled without end, it might very well have been somebody else\u2019s byline on this story; I may well have never been born. Israel is the center of gravity for world Jewry. You may object to its pull, but you simply can\u2019t free yourself from its orbit.<\/p>\n To be sure, mine is not the blustering, self-assured Zionism of my parents. Even having this conversation with my mother sets her singing an interminable series of Israeli folk songs. Recently, standing in her kitchen, I pressed her on whether she truly believes that God gave us all the land from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea. \u201cListen,\u201d she replied, \u201cI don\u2019t know who gave it to us, but it\u2019s ours.\u201d<\/p>\n I\u2019m not so sure about that. But that doesn\u2019t mean we\u2019re not part of the same movement, she and I, the same multigenerational struggle for identity and soil. The panel at Sinai Temple landed repeatedly on the idea of \u201cbig-tent Zionism.\u201d The tent has to be big enough for my parents and me.<\/p>\n Sometimes, that prospect feels doubtful. But nothing could be more necessary for the continuance of the movement. If Zionism is little more than a narrow political creed, it can be shouted down or reasoned away. What ultimately will win over the next generation of Zionists is what Yebri called \u201cthe beautiful aspect and miraculous magical aspect of Zionism.\u201d<\/p><\/blockquote>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":" Upon reading the headline, my immediate response was, “For whom?” For some people, Zionism is naturally a bad word because it represents something that is an affront to their people (Arabs and Muslims) or to their value system (leftism). If … Continue reading