There are plenty of valid criticisms of White Nationalism. I have outlined a number of them on this website over the years. I think it is fair to say that this criticism has no merit whatsoever. Unlike Pleasureman and Ricky Vaughn, I am happily married and have children. James Edwards is happily married and has children. Peter Brimelow is happily married and has children. Jared Taylor is happily married and has children. Dr. Michael Hill is happily married and has children and grandchildren. Don Black is happily married and has children. David Duke has children. My father-in-law Gordon Baum was happily married and had children and grandchildren. My wife was born into the White Nationalist movement.
Just yesterday, I attended the Alabama Medieval Festival with my wife and son and another White Nationalist couple and their daughter. We watched our children play together. The vast majority of our friends are married and have children. In fact, I learned just this evening that another friend of mine who recently got married is having a baby. He was one of the last bachelors in our circle of friends. I’ve been to as many weddings and baby showers as protests in the movement.
The Alt-Right is full of younger Millennials. Unlike Richard Spencer, most of these guys are still in their early 20s. The vast majority of them will also grow up, get married and have children. Even Richard Spencer is married and has children. Evan McLaren’s wife just had a kid. Caerulus Rex’s wife is having their first child. It simply isn’t true that White Nationalists lack meaningful human relationships.
I can still vividly remember the moment that I became a White Nationalist. As I have explained on countless occasions, it was when I read Pat Buchanan’s book The Death of the West in 2001 and the realization hit me that I was going to become a minority in my own country. My children would grow up as a racial minority in the United States. I already knew how disastrous that would be because I live in a part of the Deep South where Whites are already a minority. What if the whole United States had the demographics of the Alabama Black Belt or the Mississippi Delta?
The starting point of White Nationalism is the failure of conservatism. White identity is important because conservatives like Pleasureman hold that America is based on civic nationalism and has no racial, ethnic, cultural or religious foundation. Americans are whoever has the right paperwork. They have embarked on the most radical experiment in the history of the world which is the demographic replacement of the White majority in the United States and other Western countries. In light of experience, there is no reason to believe this experiment will end in anything but a disaster for our descendants.